• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How far do these sources support the view that Irish nationalism remained a 'curious blend of conservative Catholicism and political radicalism' between 1820 and 1921?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Ireland Coursework How far do these sources support the view that Irish nationalism remained a 'curious blend of conservative Catholicism and political radicalism' between 1820 and 1921? The leaders of the Catholic Board best illustrate the definition of "conservative Catholicism" as they desired Emancipation but were cautious and conciliatory in their approach, they hoped for reform to be achieved peacefully, which was a stark contrast to political radicals such as Wolfe Tone who wanted a Republic Ireland and was prepared to use violence in order to attain his aims. K.T. Hoppen quoted Garvin's view that Daniel O'Connell's nationalism was a "blend" because O'Connell wanted reform (which he achieved in 1829 through his Catholic Association) and repeal peacefully, but he threatened civil disobedience in Ireland to achieve this. The "blend" is therefore "curious" in that O'Connell successfully fuses two conflicting political traditions into one, but it is debateable on whether or not the "blend" remained together between 1820 and 1921. Source 1 supports Garvin's view of a "blend" as Mitchel describes O'Connell as being too conservative to defy "all British law" yet acknowledges that O'Connell entwined democracy with militancy and used, albeit it not very well ("phantom"), radical tactics such as brinkmanship. ...read more.

Middle

Griffith is one of the clearest examples of the "blend" as he compromises with the British over the treaty, something which Eamon De Valera, another radical, is strongly opposed to. The idea of a "blend" is continued to an extent in source 6 where George Bernard Shaw uses a analogy of a man to depict nationalism as though it were one movement and thus does not distinguish any separate strands. He also concludes nationalism to be curious as he calls it "twaddle" and states that it is anti-progressive and unhealthy, which also makes it very ineffective. Source 5 continues Shaw's view that nationalism was widespread as the source shows that the IPP, which contained both moderates and radicals, was consistently popular in Ireland and thus indicates that many people supported this blend. Housing both traditions enabled the party to act as a hybrid, in that Parnell combined parliamentary tactics with civil disobedience. The notion of a "blend" is contradicted in source 1 as Mitchel identifies two separate strands of nationalism and indicates there is no common ground between radicals like himself and "respectable Catholics" like O'Connell. ...read more.

Conclusion

The formation of the Sinn Fein party is a clear indication of the blend dissolving, as there were now two political parties with their own views on nationalism and one was more successful than the other. This split within nationalism is also depicted in source 7 where De Valera and Griffith both have different views regarding the Anglo-Irish treaty; hence demonstrates the end of the blend in 1921. To an extent, many of the sources identify a "curious blend" within Irish nationalism; figures such as O'Connell and Parnell embody the two very different political traditions, which was "curious" in that the traditions were two complete opposites. The "blend", which remained just over the period, was not equal as both men came from "conservative Catholic" backgrounds and both had tried to implement this approach in the beginning, but after seeing the futility of "conservative Catholicism" they began to use "political radicalism". Over time, the sources suggest that "political radicalism" became more dominant with the rise of the Fenians and Sinn Fein, thus by 1921 the "blend" had all but dissolved. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. The Successes and Failures of Charles Stuart Parnell!

    Another of Parnell's successes was to follow swiftly after as the First Home Rule Bill was issued. Allow the First Home Rule Bill was defeated, it was the beginning of the "Liberal Alliance", in which Parnell and the Home Rule Party continued to support the Liberals as long as they remained committed to Home Rule.

  2. Sharpeville Massacre Sources Question

    death scenes" This disagrees with Source B, where it states very clearly that "demonstrators attacked the police with assorted weapons including firearms" Source E shows no fallen weapons on the ground, suggesting either that there were none present or that the police had cleared them away.

  1. How far were Gandhi's actions after 1920 responsible for Indiagaining her independence in 1947?

    If we consider an India without Gandhi, would India have still conceivably achieved independence? Whilst historians akin to Nanda has taken a biographical view of Gandhi's life and stressed his importance, it can be strongly argued that the nature of biography means he gives a bias and contorted view of Gandhi, leading to a difference in interpretation to historians (i.e.

  2. HUMANITIES COURSEWORK

    However, in this kind of conflict, actions speak louder than words which led to unending war, murders and death. Israel tried to pacify (when someone refused to get involved in violence) by controlling their military forces because they had the most power.

  1. Parnell and the Irish Parliamentary Party 1882-5 After the Kilmainham ...

    grasp the Irish nettle', proceeded with a Home Rule Bill swiftly and boldly. The Home Rule Package The Home Rule package was presented to the Cabinet in March 1886, consisting of two closely related Bills which aimed to solve the political and the social problems of Ireland together.

  2. British History Coursework: The Irish Famine 1845-1849

    capacity to help those afflicted by hardship; both of which were lacking in an Ireland ruled from afar by unsympathetic British Politicians, who typically represented the interests of the privileged industrialist and the landed gentry. The population of Ireland in 1800 was five million.

  1. WWI, The Twenty-One Demands and The May Fourth Movement

    http://www.cartage.org.lb/en/themes/GeogHist/histories/history/hiscountries/C/china.html (07/13/04 19:38:56) "China." http://www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk/2WWchina.htm (08/10/04 17:39:02) "China: History." http://www.infoplease.com/ce6/world/A0857295.html (07/13/04 19:35:43) "Chinatown Online - Chinese History: The First Republic." http://www.chinatown-online.co.uk/pages/culture/history/first.html (07/13/04 19:35:05) "Chinese History, Regent Tour China." http://www.regenttour.com/china/history/roc.htm (07/13/04 19:34:31) "Chinese history:Republican China." http://www.chinavoc.com/history/republic.htm (07/13/04 19:34:12) "History of China." http://www.allstarz.org/yaoming/chinahistory.htm (08/03/04 18:43:33) "History of the Republic of China." http://www.worldhistory.com/wiki/H/History-of-the-Republic-of-China.htm (07/13/04 19:44:01) "MSN Encarta - Print Preview - China."

  2. How effectively did Irish Catholic and nationalist leaders advance their cause in the years ...

    Though aiding the Great Reform Act in 1831 did bring greater fairness to British and Irish democracy. In 1835 O'Connell pre-empted future Irish leaders by taking advantage of a weak British government. As apart of the 'Litchfield House Compact' the O'Connellites earned greater influence over the Whig government.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work