• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How far were Gandhi's actions after 1920 responsible for Indiagaining her independence in 1947?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

How far were Gandhi's actions after 1920 responsible for India gaining her independence in 1947? Hailed by B.R Nanda as the 'Father of the Nation,'1 Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi rose from political obscurity to challenge and help secure India's independence from the British Empire in 1947. As a character with seemingly so much influence in politics after 1920 up until his death in 1948, Gandhi galvanised and united the movement for independence. Yet, he was ineffective in channelling its potential; his 'all or nothing' approach, whilst admirable, was not the technique required to achieve concessions after so many years of Imperial rule. Without him, India would still have achieved independence if solely on the basis that Britain was no longer in a position of strength to maintain power. The effects of the Second World War as well as a rise in nationalism are just some of the other causes for British power in India to capitulate. This essay will argue that these other factors played a greater role in dictating the arrival of Indian independence than the role of Gandhi and his actions after 1920. Gandhi's opposition to the British Empire stemmed from his experiences of colonialism in South Africa, where he was discriminated against, along with the other members of the Indian minority in South Africa. The basis for his actions was shaped by recent writings such as Leo Tolstoy's The Kingdom of God Is Within You (1893) and John Ruskin's Unto this Last, (1862); this led to him developing a form of non-violence called satyagraha,2 to which he encouraged the society of the times to adhere. However, he is criticised by Parekh, who claimed that, as "with many things in his life," Gandhi "made up his brand of Hinduism as he went along."3 Indeed, there was a prominent nationalist movement before the era of Gandhi. However, its lack of success in achieving desirable steps towards independence show it lacked momentum and direction; partly due to poor communications within India and the high illiteracy rate in rural regions, meaning that promulgation of ideas that existed at the time was virtually impossible. ...read more.

Middle

However, 1927 saw Lord Birkenhead, the new Secretary of State for India call for a review of the 1919 Act, which included a provision for parliamentary review after ten years. The significance of this, however, was that the commission which was entrusted with conducting the review contained no Indian members. The Congress, which, despite having much more political power than it had enjoyed in its history, and Gandhi, who in these circumstances rejoined the Congress ranks, could do little to stop the commission carrying out its review, except protest. The following year saw the Congress concluded a more aggressive stance, after the Commission concluded in its findings that government for India should be kept at provincial level. Its 1928 meeting declared that the party would push for complete independence. Lord Irwin, the new Viceroy persuaded Baldwin that a declaration of dominion status "was the goal of British policy" and called for Round Table Conferences to consider the next steps. Therefore, as Spears states, it puzzled many when such a great advance on the British side was met by direct action by the Congress. However, he concurred that accepting the compromise may split the Congress altogether, forcing Gandhi himself to take measures of his own against the British. The Salt Tax levied by the British on the Indians in 1930 saw Gandhi respond by walking 240 from Ahmedabad to the coastal town of Dandi, where he was arrested for gathering salt. Congress gave support to Gandhi by calling upon all of its followers to break the salt laws. Soon, processions, arrests, hartals, and occasional riots were widespread across India. In the course of that year some hundred thousand went to prison. Lord Irwin was forced to release Gandhi in 1931, enabling him to attend the second of the Round Table Conferences. However, he failed to impress the delegates at the conference, and, there were more pressing financial issues at home; Nanda highlighted that the "financial crisis was for it (the British public) ...read more.

Conclusion

These synonyms were frequently associated with Hindu nationalists in their quest for independence. 6 Age of Extremes - The Short Twentieth Century - Eric Hobsbawm 7 Source: A History of India - Percival Spear 8 Ibid. 9 Wilson's Fourteen Points, released in January, 1918, contained the point that, as Woodrow Wilson felt, every country should have the right to self-determination, thus heralding great significance to Indians. 10 The act gave five million Indian citizens, for the first time, the right to vote. 11 The passing of the Rowlatt Act substantively exploited the privacy of Indian citizens, as the Act allowed a suspect's freedom of movement or speech. The Legislative Council passed two bills, allowing judges powers to try political cases without juries and gave to provincial governments (as well as the central government), the power of internment without trial. 12 Ibid. 13 Source: Empire, Welfare State, Europe: English History 1906-1992 - T. O. Lloyd 14 No mention of specific people; Gandhi: A Very Short Introduction - Bhikhu Parekh 15 Ibid. 16 Mahatma Gandhi: A Biography - B. R. Nanda 17 Ibid. 18 Cited by Percival Spear - A History of India 19 Cited by T. O. Lloyd - Empire, Welfare State, Europe: English History 1906-1992 20 Mahatma Gandhi: A Biography - B. R. Nanda 21 Source: Britain: Foreign and Imperial Affairs 1919-39 - Alan Farmer 22 India received an elected Indian government, giving significant powers to Indian politicians by establishing provincial governments. 23 A History of India - Percival Spear 24 The Congress at its Bombay session passed the famous Quit India resolution, calling for mass struggle on non-violent lines on the widest possible scale, under the leadership of Gandhi. 25 Source: www.historyofindia.com 26 Sanskrit for "self-rule" 27 Gandhi: A Very Short Introduction - Bhikhu Parekh 28 Source: History Today, The Indian National Congress - Francis Robinson 29 Opinion of Percival Spear from A History of India 30 Gandhi: A Very Short Introduction - Bhikhu Parekh Dhaval Shah 27/04/2007 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Green is the Colour: "how people of different races, the heirs of colonial and ...

    As a consequence, the people would suffer, for their issues would not really be addressed, and they would be subjected to become pawns in the hands of those political opportunists who are only interested in furthering their personal ambitions. Hence, Fernando tears off the mask of Panglima to reveal the farce which certain administrators are attempting to hide.

  2. Party system in India

    The Janata party came through the merger of different parties - Socialist Party, Bharatiya Lok Dal, Bharatiya Jan Sangh and the Congress (O) - with long-standing mutual opposition but now united in their will to defeat the Congress. The emergence of a viable non-Congress party and its capturing of power

  1. The Rise and fall of the Ottoman Empire.

    The kanun refers to situational decisions that are not covered by the Shari'ah. Although the Shari'ah provided all the necessary laws, it was recognised that many situations fell outside the parameters of the Shari'ah. In Islamic tradition, if a case did fall outside of the parameters then a judgement could

  2. 'Nationalist Groups in the Sub-Continent played the most significant role in Britain's decision to ...

    Some people felt that the very nature of Islam called for a communal Muslim society. These memories might have made it exceptionally difficult for Muslims to accept the imposition of colonial power and culture. They refused to learn English and to associate with the British.

  1. This dispute dates back to the partition of the British Indian Empire, in August ...

    The Indian armed intervention in the State of Jammu and Kashmir was illegal and took place against the wishes of the Kashmiri people. Despite the decision of the UN Security Council for the holding of a plebiscite to allow the people of Jammu and Kashmir to determine their own future,

  2. The British Suffragette movement.

    Members might wear a badge, scarf, or sash in the WSPU colours of purple (for dignity), white (for purity) and green (for hope) and such signs of belonging to an "unladylike" organization could attract verbal and physical abuse, even at the hands of the police.

  1. Apartheid in South Africa.

    Source D shows the crowd surrounding a vehicle sticking their thumbs up which is a peaceful but significant sign indicating protest. Source G shows the crowd fleeing from the police. These are major hints that the only action the crowd took was to run away in order to save themselves.

  2. Representation and Democracy in Britain 1830 – 1931

    In the first ever Labour government the survival of MacDonald's small Commons majority depended on the good will of opposition parties. This difficult situation prompted him to call an election. During the campaign a newspaper published the notorious 'Zinoviev' letter.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work