• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How important a contribution is made by the Ombudsmen to the task of ensuring that government decision-making is conducted in

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

How important a contribution is made by the Ombudsmen to the task of ensuring that government decision-making is conducted in defensible ways and produces defensible results. Discuss The Parliamentary Commissioner for Adminstration (PCA) was set up under the Parliamentary Commissioner Act 1967 as a result of the Crichel Down affair in 1954. It was thought that pre-existing judicial and parliamentary remedies did not provide adequate redress for members of the public who suffered as a result of maladministration in central government. No action was being taken towards defective administrative workings, either because it fell outside the jurisdiction of the courts or because MPs did not have sufficient powers to investigate it satisfactorily. The Ombudsman stands as an independent body, empowered to investigate a wide range of complaints than could be investigated by a court. Where as a court can intervene in judicial review proceedings only where a decision is ultra vires, the Ombudsman is required to consider 'maladministration' (under s 10(3) ...read more.

Middle

The government has always resisted the extension of the Ombudsman system into these areas. Furthermore, Schedule 2 does not include public corporations, tribunals, the Criminal Injuries Compensation Board or, crucially, the police. A further important limitation, the system of making the complaint through a Member of Parliament, has been much criticised: it is thought that this 'screening' of complaints does not serve the best interests of complainant. This is where direct access to the ombudsman is denied and the MP is made to be the middleman. The involvement of MPs in the process may mean an inadequate working system since MPs do not possess the power to investigate in great detail as to scrutinise the matter at hand to its depths. Another problem that is seen within the role of PCA is also due to the lack of power to award remedy. However, the fact that the PCA operates informally and privately has been thought to enhance his powers of persuasion. ...read more.

Conclusion

The Department of Trade and Industry (responsible for licensing such investment companies) was found to be involved in maladministration, including errors, lack of information, etc. all of which resulted in injustice. It should be remembered that in some respects, certain Ombudsmen might be more effective than others in comparison with other available remedies. It should also be noted that the public has direct access to Health Service Commissioners, the Local Commissioners (since 1978), and the European Community Ombudsman. Although, as a system, the Ombudsman suffers from a number of drawbacks- no direct access (with the exceptions); the concept of maladministration being relatively narrow and being linked to injustice suffered as a result of a decision; a significant number of matters fall outside his jurisdiction- a survey by the Select Committee shows that the advantages of retaining the filter system outweigh the disadvantages. It may, therefore, be concluded that Ombudsman makes a significant contribution to the task of ensuring that government decision-making is conducted in defensible ways and produces defensible results. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. 'Liberal pluralist views of policy making are hopelessly naïve.' Discuss.

    & M.S. Baratz (1970) Power and Poverty New York: Oxford University Press Bachrach, P & M.S. Baratz (1975) 'Power and Its Two Faces Revisited: A Reply to Geoffrey Debnam' American Political Science Review, 69, pp900-904 Dahl, R. (1958) 'Critique of the Ruling Elite Model' American Political Science Review, 52, pp463-469 Dahl, R.

  2. How far do you agree that it was Cavour's diplomacy rather that Garibaldi's ideas ...

    Through studying his letters, Seaman concludes that Cavour's main aim was Piedmontisation and not the unification of Italy. Smith expresses the view that essentially unification was just a fluke under Cavour's ministry. Although, these historians views are valid, it is important not to underestimate Cavour's significance in Unification.

  1. citizenship data task

    about the school premises and the classroom we will be working in, and the resources that the school can provide us with 3. Do research on child behaviour and how to work with year 1 children (suggested by Amy) All group members Each member of group must produce some sort

  2. Free essay

    Women's contribution to the war

    It is clear that women's contribution to the war made a difference, as several changes were made that have continued even to this day however, they were not all long term achievements. As well as this, women were granted part-time schemas in 1943 which led to an increase in productivity in part-time workers in comparison to full time workers.

  1. Did Paul Lahti, the director of the Minahasa Raya mine, make the correct decision ...

    The locals "dug up ore with shovels and mallets, drove it in trucks right past Mr. Lahti's office and processed it just outside Newmont's front gate." (Schuman 1) He had been told by the central government that they would put an end to illegal mining, however it did not stop at all.

  2. The Uk policy making process.

    programmes, and so he deliberately asked very anodyne questions about agricultural policy. He was so successful in fact that perhaps only a couple of dozen backbench Labour MPs had the strategic awareness to realise what their Leader was doing; many were visibly bemused at his apparently weak showing in the Commons.

  1. Discuss the contributions to the academic field of public administration made by the following ...

    What major themes may be said to exist in contemporary intergovernmental relations? The key features of intergovernmental relations in contemporary American politics are the steadily increasing intergovernmental aid and joint efforts that became more important components of public policy making.

  2. Belfast Air Raid Investigation

    Belfast's protection against raids was meagre. The government was more concerned over financial issues, instead of erecting the necessary shelters and preparing accordingly. Belfast had the lowest shelter provision of any comparable city in the United Kingdom - a particularly dangerous situation for the city with the greatest density of population.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work