• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11

In comparison to Germany's relative political stability, what variables can be identified in order to explain Italy's relative political turmoil since the end of the Second World War?

Extracts from this document...


In comparison to Germany's relative political stability, what variables can be identified in order to explain Italy's relative political turmoil since the end of the Second World War? "As long as the differences and diversities of mankind exist, democracy must allow for compromise, for accommodation, and for the recognition of differences." -Eugene McCarthy - http://www.britannica.com/eb/article?tocId=9049640 INTRODUCTION In order to consider the above question I intend to embark upon a comparative analysis of the two states within the framework of the liberal democratic model of Western Europe. I shall explore the various themes of the model and the role played by its institutions in achieving and maintaining political stability. By using the most similar systems theory I intend to establish similarities and therefore comment upon the causes of differences between each polity. I shall then comment on which influences I can therefore consider relevant and whether they are endogenous or exogenous factors. I shall provide quantitative data to support my opinion and I hope to also shed light upon the societal norms of each country and the detail of their state/institutional structures. ELECTIONS The structure of the party system will be considered later in this research however; at this point the discussion must centre on the role of the Christian Democratic parties of either country. The fall of the Berlin Wall has without doubt left a political footprint upon world politics. For both of the countries I am considering here it has been a huge landmark. Although you would expect there to be greater political turmoil within the German state it was Italy that would face greater challenges. For the Italian people a long running undercurrent of their voting patterns had been the fear of the PCI (The Italian Communist Party) and their image as "the bogeyman from Moscow". This meant that although they received considerable electoral support (never below 25% from 1963-1990) they were never accepted as a possible ruling party and this maintained voter turnout for the opposition DC (Christian Democrats). ...read more.


The Council of Ministers (mostly, but not necessarily composed of members of parliament) must retain the confidence of both houses. The Chamber of Deputies has 630 members. In addition to 315 elected members, the Senate includes former presidents and several other persons appointed for life according to special constitutional provisions. Both houses are elected for a maximum of 5 years, but either may be dissolved before the expiration of its normal term. A bill must receive the positive assent of both houses and the Cabinet is equally responsible to both houses, producing a strongly bicameral legislature - (Comparative European Politics, Hans Daalder (1997), Pinter, Wiltshire, pg 33) Germany is a constitutional federal republic, whose political system is laid out in the 1949 'constitution' called Grundgesetz (Fundamental Law). It has a parliamentary system in which the head of government, the Bundeskanzler (Chancellor), is elected by the parliament.The parliament, called Bundestag (Federal Assembly), is elected every four years by popular vote in a complex system combining direct and proportional representation. The 16 Bundesl´┐Żnder are represented at the federal level in the Bundesrat (Federal Council), which-depending on the subject matter-may have a say in the legislative procedure. Lately, there has been much concern about the Bundestag and the Bundesrat blocking each other, making effective government very difficult. The function of head of state is performed by the Bundespr´┐Żsident (Federal President) in Germany, whose powers are mostly limited to ceremonial and representative duties. - (http://www.bundestag.de/htdocs_e/orga/index.html) ELECTORAL SYSTEM The electoral systems discussed below can be recognised by their use of a two vote system and partial use of a proportional representation. In the elections to the Bundestag, each voter has two votes. The first vote is for candidates in the districts with the candidate receiving the majority vote as the winner. The second votes determine how many representatives will be sent from each party to the Bundestag. The number of representatives for each party is determined according to Hare/Niemeyer formula. ...read more.


Indeed the German "catch-all parties", with less ideological dogma, as described by Kircheimer in 1966 (http://www.janda.org/comparative%20parties/page169.htm) were far more capable of absorbing the political shockwaves. The prevalance of these parties in Germany has created a political population who feel represented and comfortable with their Government. Both countries face challenges from the traditional European cleavages as discussed by Lipset and Rokkan. The urban-rural cleavage has proved an issue, with Italy needing to fund the predominantly agricultural South and Germany the under developed East. The creation and subsequent influence of the Northern League in Italy furthered instability as there appeared a real opportunity for change in regard to political represention The Federal system of Germany has managed these concerns through decentralisation of concerns to a local level, for example tax and the use of manageable electoral districts within a combined electoral system. The German Polity, David Conradt, (2001), Addison Wesley Longman, United States, pg 47) Such an electoral system is now employed in both counties and allows the possibility of strong party grouping within Parliament whilst also reflecting the makeup of society. The system in Italy would always remain volatile as the pure PR system used allowed iodeologically diverse parties to fragment support and make coalitions generally unworkable. Germanys use of the 5% rule in particular, avoided this and created an atmosphere where successful coalition was the norm rather than the aim. Instability arose from the reform to the system as a natural result of this reclassification, but the resulting reduction in parties has supported coalition government. Returning to the point of identification with a political party, the exposure of the corruption inherent in the Italian system left the reputation of the traditional parties and their leaders severely tarnished. Voters were dismayed by the massive aqnd widespread levels of corruption which were obviously so ingrained as to become systemic. I therefore suggest also that the functioning of government within Germany is clearer to the common man and this is an important factor to political stability. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Minority parties in Britain call for electoral reform whereas the two major parties tend ...

    In the 1987 election, Conservatives won only one out of fifteen seats in South Yorkshire, and Labour only won three seats in the South of the country (Smyth, 1992). It can be seen that representation not only reflects public opinion on a national scale, but also on the more personal constituency level.

  2. In What Ways Do Political Parties Promote Democracy?

    The War in Iraq was brought to debate in the House of Commons amongst the political parties, on whether or not they should go ahead with it or not, and despite the fact that many opposed the idea of going to war, Tony Blair, being the Prime Minister with the authority to send troops to war, did exactly that.

  1. What problems did Italy face after the First World War?

    The party mainly consisted of war veterans who were anti-communist and pro-nationalist. Before World War 1 Mussolini had been a member of the socialist party but he left because he fully supported Italy entering WW1. Mussolini signed up in the war, and was wounded.

  2. What is the role of political parties in a democratic political community?

    In the United Kingdom, the Prime Minister is not the head of state that honour belongs to the ruling monarch, at present Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II. However in many other democratic states such as the United States, the winner of the Presidential election also becomes the head of state and must take on the symbolic trappings of that role.

  1. What impact did Mao have on the lives of the Chinese people from 1949 ...

    Mao Zedong was opposed to these policies. He thought that they were too 'capitalist'. In 1962, the Socialist Education Movement was launched, aiming to get people back into Communism. The 'four clean-ups campaign' to get rid of corruption and bad Party leadership was also introduced, to discourage people who showed signs of 'capitalist' behaviour.

  2. Is the President the Most Powerful Man In the World?

    For example, Congress rejected George Bushes nominee for Defence Secretary John Trower, as they didn't trust his financial motives. Although he may have the power to recommend his choice of nominee, by no mean does he have the power to secure their positions.

  1. Why do Liberals think Democracy can Prevent War

    are the ones that may have to fight, or pay the cost of the war, or rebuild from the destruction the war may cause. A dictator or a monarch is not as likely to make these considerations, because they bear none of the aforementioned consequences of war - they simply make the decisions.

  2. Assess the reason why the Italian people were so disillusioned with the liberal government ...

    This showed the middle classes that the government would not stand up and tackle socialism leading them to turn to someone else. The right wing parties criticised the Liberal government due to their toleration of the socialists and allowing it to rise, but also due to what happened at the Treaty of Versailles which D'Annunizio described as a mutilated victory.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work