• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Internal disunity was the main reason for the failure of Chartism.' To what extent do you agree with this statement?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'Internal disunity was the main reason for the failure of Chartism.' To what extent do you agree with this statement? By the time the petition was rejected in 1848 it can be seen that Chartism had lost its importance amongst its former supporters and to the government and thus dying out as an important political campaign movement. A big question that has remained amongst historians is the cause of this downfall of a once hugely popular movement that 'effectively raised fundamental constitutional questions in Parliament and rattled the bars of the establishment' (H.Browne). In this essay I shall discuss whether or not the internal disunity of the Chartists was the main reason for their failure or was it as a result of many other factors including the following; no general middles-class support for cross-class alliance, power of the state that enabled them to make mass arrests, exhaustion of constitutional means to reform, the strategy and tactics used by the chartists and the effective abandonment of the charter by the majority after 1848. The chartist movement was one that had a tendency to break up due to arguments amongst the key leader figures in the organisation. Some believe that this internal disunity showed that the chartists were not politically nor intellectually mature enough to obtain and use the vote. ...read more.

Middle

With the help of the middle classes the chartists could have gained more attention from the government; as they would have been fearful of the results of the combinations of the working and middle classes and thus may have paid more attention to the ploys of the chartists. The chartist received much opposition and hostility from those within the House of Commons and the Government, who were mainly the landed interest as they believed the Chartists to be a potential threat to public order and who should be 'contained' many had no intention of conceding in anyway to there demands or even accepting there was a case. This in it's self can be seen as a reason why the chartist campaign failed, facing such opposition as they clearly did, with no way into the house of commons how were the chartist going to produce the changes they wished for. Nothing that the chartists were campaigning for was in the mood of the political times of those who had 'stake in the country.' It almost seems that it would be impossible for the Chartists to get the changes they wanted and reforms they believed were needed until England's rulers had accepted the need for a more democratic government, as without the cross-class alliance and virtually no support in the Houses of Commons reform through pressure form the Chartists alone looked very unlikely to be beneficial. ...read more.

Conclusion

The chartist believed strongly that improvements and reforms to working class life couldn't come without the vote, so when changes occurred such as the Mines Act 1842, the abolition of the Poor Law Commission in 1847 and the 'Ten Hour' Act in 1847, it become clear that reform was possible without the vote, such reforms many believed came as result of agitation to make issues clear to the government. In conclusion it should be said that to say 'Internal disunity' was the sole reason for the failure of the chartist is untrue, although the lack of clear leadership between differing types of chartist some believing in 'moral force' some in 'physical force' caused agreements and wasted internal disagreements these problems can't be seen as the main causes to the failure. The sheer power of the Government, Judiciary and army stood in the face of the Chartists and to overcome this and the attitudes of many at this time would have been an almighty task for any political organisation. The chartist were a group that put pressure on the government and made many in the society open their eyes to some of the possible changes that should take place yet it seemed that until society and those within the political system felt change was needed little could be done, thus resulting in the abandonment by the majority of the charter after 1848. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Compare and contrast the Chartist and Anti -Corn Law League movements. Explain and illustrate ...

    The two also disagreed about the involvement of the middle classes. Whilst Lovett thought it was essential, O'Connor was firmly opposed. Such divisions at such an important level could only have a negative influence on the movement and it's eventual direction.

  2. To what extent was religion the main causeOf rebellion in the reign of Henry ...

    The monasteries in the north provided a huge boost to the local economy. During hard times the local monasteries provided charity and help for those less fortunate. The monasteries provided jobs for locals, such as building and gardening work. Abbeys also made sure that roads and bridges were in a

  1. Why did Britain have no '1848 revolution'?

    His policies were intended to separate the middle and working classes to prevent a revolutionary situation. This worked by securing middle class support and thus reducing their interest and influence in radical politics. In contrast governments on the continent were unresponsive, even during the economic crisis of 1846-7, thus resistance

  2. Account for the failures of the Chartist movement in the 19th century.

    duties; therefore we must have the privileges of free men."(Norman Lowe 1998) Attwood asked they grant the six points, which was rejected by an overwhelming 235 voted against and 46 for (Edward Royle 1980). This confirmed the thoughts of the extremists, that violence was the only way forward.

  1. The failure of Chartism was due to improved economical conditions rather than the movement's ...

    In addition the railways set up in Britain at the time helped in transporting troops to areas where there were violence had broken out. With reforms came a strong government which remained consistent over the decision to exclude power to the lower classes.

  2. What was Chartism and why did it fail

    One example is the short-lived Hampton Clubs (around 1816) who wanted universal suffrage. Other movements included the trade unions such as the Grand National Consolidated Trade Union and the co-operative founded by Robert Owen a Welsh Socialite that was based on equality for society.

  1. To what extent can the failure of the Fascist Movement to challenge the existing ...

    However, he had a well exposed private life, he was married twice and had a number of affairs, hence being judged untrustworthy by some. As a party there were endless and inconclusive debates, a lack of courage and decision. A number of events in the party highlighted these weaknesses -

  2. "By 1942, SEAsian Nationalism was largely a failure." How far do you agree with ...

    As for Thakins, there was rivalry among Burmese leaders. Freedom Bloc protested against U Pu and organized strikes in 1940 which saw the arrest of Ba Maw and the escape of Aung San. U Saw rose to power against Ba Maw's govt and repressed Thakins. Evaluation: Disunity within the ranks of various nationalist parties saw the fall of various

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work