• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is the Media an independent political actor?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Is the Media an independent political actor? "The news is not a neutral and natural phenomenon; it is rather the manufactured production of ideology."1 The quote, taken from Mark Curtis' book, Web of Deceit, displays an ultra sceptical scrutiny of the media in Britain, and refutes any claim that our news performs an effective and independent political check on the government. The media's role in a pluralist democracy is to supply the general public with impartial coverage of current affairs, and present challenging scrutiny of the political process in order to hold the government of the day accountable and enhance the practice of 'democracy'. On the contrary, the media has arguably become more a tool used and exploited by the government to maintain support and justify its actions. The BBC today is one of the only forms of mainstream media that valiantly attempts to hold the government to account by setting limits and maintaining pressure, along with anomalous journalists such as the Independent's Robert Fisk and the Guardian's Jonathon Steele. The medias role is ever-more important today when a seemingly over powerful government meets limited resistance from its opposition in parliament, and those "independent" media outlets that seek to question government policy, on Iraq for example, are lambasted by government reports and government controlled tabloids. The Hutton Report, as we know, saw the BBC brought to heel after it wrongly claimed that the late Dr David Kelly had 'sexed up' a dossier regarding arms in ...read more.

Middle

Furthermore 60% cited that they trusted television most, BBC1 scoring highest and Trevor MacDonald topping a poll of the most trusted newscasters. The broadcasting market has in recent years become a much more competitive one, companies constantly competing for audience retention, and the growing abundance of channels emerging on the cable and satellite scene pose a significant challenge to the existing dominance that the four major terrestrial channels currently exert. It is argued that the deregulation of British broadcasting, caused by the recent explosion of choice in the television industry, " ensures broadcasting's independence of the state"11 and arguably enhances the practice of a pluralist democracy in Britain. On the contrary BBC One and Two still retain around 40% of the audience, and together with ITV and Channel 4, make up over 80% of the broadcasting market in Britain, giving these major broadcasters the most influential positions in the British media. Broadcasting faces similar problems to the press in that both compete in a market that exists to maximise profits by increasing audiences. Mark Curtis addresses the chief pitfall and consequence of competition in the mainstream media, stating, "Stories have to attract audiences to sell to advertisers in competition with soap operas and game shows."12 Curtis also provides analysis of the role of the media with a rather condemning quote from a study conducted by Brian McNair of Stirling University, that concludes, "The news media of society tend to construct accounts of events which are structured and framed by the dominant values and interests of that society, and to marginalize (if not necessarily exclude) ...read more.

Conclusion

The replacement of hard-hitting and informative news in favour of more human-interest productions, along with the government's ability to intimidate broadcasters, like in 1986 when a Conservative report "almost certainly had some effect on the BBC's subsequent news and current affairs presentation,"23 displays how "the pluralist analysis of the medias role is inappropriate." Although the odd Channel 4 program and selective reporters for the Independent and the Guardian seek to uncover some of the darker secrets that the government wish to keep secret, their efforts seem to fall on deaf ears as their reports are only picked up by a minority of viewers and therefore never seem to generate the desired effect. Journalistic mavericks use the Internet to uncover truths and construct arguments that openly question and challenge British foreign policy but their efforts are swamped by mainstream spin and government propaganda and so the truth remains untold. The medias role in society is to produce clear, impartial accounts of current affairs and scrutinise or even challenge the actions of the government in order to contribute to a pluralist democracy. However the British media today reflects more a government institution, controlled to create a fa´┐Żade of democracy and quell any challenges, in essence creating a system that preserves the status quo and the interests of the elite. "The news is not a neutral and natural phenomenon; it is rather the manufactured production of ideology. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. The media plays an important role in society. What is its role and to ...

    daily lives and has been since it was coined back in 1921 when the first wave of Mass Media came about. The world's people cannot live without media and are so used to it that people use it to work, entertain and communicate.

  2. 'Liberal pluralist views of policy making are hopelessly naïve.' Discuss.

    However, Smith (1990) pointed out that the influence of pressure groups derives not so much from their resources but from the organization of government. This means whether a pressure group can exercise influence on policy-making mainly depends on the government, not the resources they have.

  1. How much influence does the media have on the political process

    The show has specialized in decoding the hidden message behind the news in the mainstream media and ridiculing the hypocrisy and incompetence of public figures. Brian Williams NBC News anchor describes Jon Stewart as a "freestanding branch of government in this country."

  2. To what extent can the failure of the Fascist Movement to challenge the existing ...

    There were also events Mosley had no control over and these considerably weakened the Fascist effort to challenge the British political system. One of the major events was the depression and if Mosley had launched his party at the right time it may well have seen him in power.

  1. What is Politics

    Lukes suggests that power can be exercised through manipulation. People with power can pursuade others that what is being offered is what is wanted or desired. For example, some feminists would argue that a male dominated patriarchal society exercises power over women by persuading them, through the way that they

  2. The causes and the political and social consequences of the Dreyfus Affair in France

    Nationalist party crisis, which threatened the political stability of the society and the national unity. After the Affair ended with the reinstatement of Dreyfus, Waldeck-Rousseau indirectly attacked the Anti-Dreyfusards. He fought against nationalism by strengthening the State: the civil servants having revealed their incompetence were subjected to transfers or retirements.

  1. The executive is the dominant policy actor in the HKSAR, other policy actors exert ...

    of the people and on the adequacy and priorities of government programmes in their respective districts. The district councils also undertake environmental improvements and promote recreational, cultural and community activities within their respective districts. The Judiciary The judiciary is responsible for the administration of justice in HK.

  2. Research Project - "Can the Central Bank in Jamaica be truly independent?"

    public policy" The functions of the Central Bank can be summarized as: * It issues notes * It acts as a bank: * to the government * to recognized banks * to overseas central banks * It manages the government's borrowing program * It overseas the activities of banks and

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work