• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is there any realistic sense in which Parliament controls the government?

Extracts from this document...


Is there any realistic sense in which Parliament controls the government? The UK is supposed to operate a system of Parliamentary Government, where Parliament holds the supreme authority, but in reality this rarely is the case. Parliamentary Government only really occurs during a low or no majority government or hung Parliament, for example in 1979, when James Callaghan's minority labour government lost it's liberal support and a vote of no confidence voted him out. Parliament was first established to control the reigning monarch, but as the power of the monarch has been reduced, it is debatable whether or not the same power has not just been given to the executive. Theoretically the executive is supposed to be controlled by Parliament, as one of it's main functions, but in reality this is quite the opposite way around. Due to the First Past the Post electoral system the M.P.s and therefore the party, elected need only to have majority in large numbers in certain areas; for parties who's support is thinly spread but not great, these parties may not even be represented. ...read more.


For example in the 2001 election Labour only got 40.7% of the vote but were allocated 62.7% of the seats. This meant that not only was the proportion of seats wrong for them, it was wrong for every other party, and this gave Labour a big majority. This period of Government proves to be a perfect example of how the executive can dominate Parliament. Even the Legislative process, one of Parliament's most important functions, is susceptible to control by the Government. There are many stages of the process which are designed to prevent any one body controlling this but many are flawed and easily manipulated by the Executive. The first stage which can be noted is the Second Reading where the Bill is debated and then voted on in the House of Commons. If the Whips are called in then the M.P.s belonging to the Government will vote with in accordance to this and if it is a Government suggestion and there is majority, the law will pass this stage. ...read more.


Parliament, however, does have certain ways of controlling the Executive and their government. The Public Accounts Committee is chaired by a senior member of the opposition and is a Select Committee, which means it is permanent. This committee has the power to summon Ministers and make them explain the spending of their department. This means that they don't have infinite power to spend or do whatever they want. The National Audit Commission accounts for the spending and ensures minimal dishonesty and incompetence. However they still do not have the authority to compel ministers and civil servants to answer their questions. Another method of control is the Prime Minister's Questions, which means the Prime Minister can be asked any question and must explain himself to the House of Commons. As a last resort, Parliament can call for a Vote of No Confidence which means the M.P.s vote on whether or not to remove a Prime Minister or Government. There is also, of course the stages in the Legislative process but, as I have already discussed, they end up under the control of the Executive in the end. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. To what extent does executive dominance over parliament prevent M.P.'s from carrying out their ...

    If these ms don't vote how they are told to the whip implies a number of sanctions to use against them, ranging from a stiff telling of to withdrawal of the whip. This displays how M.P.'s can be dominated by the executive, and how it can lead them to become ineffective at the role.

  2. Is Legalization a Realistic Alternative to the War on Marijuana?

    Jeffrey Miron discovered that 734,497 people were arrested in the year 2000 on possession charges (6). Some insight into the demographics of the offenders is provided by Somdahl. He states that five times as many non-whites are arrested on marijuana-related charges despite the fact that eighty percent of marijuana-related crimes are committed by whites (97).

  1. Whether or not Parliament is effective as a government watchdog

    Each member of the Commons is elected under the "first past the post" system, this leads to a majority in the commons. Due to this, when the Commons is debating issues, the party with the least members in the Commons has the least time to speak, and put their point forward, in order to scrutinise the government.

  2. UK Written Constitutionshould the legislative process in Parliament be designed to secure that 'unconstitutional' ...

    Since Parliament's legitimacy derives from democracy, its legislation must follow constitutionally democratic principles, and hence the legislative process should ensure that bills adhere to these principles. Many of these principles are inherent in the European Convention of Human Rights, which was internalised into the UK by the Human Rights Act 1998.

  1. A Modernizing Monarch

    Tsar Alexander II, who succeeded Nicholas I in 1855, was a conservative who saw no alternative but to implement change. Alexander initiated substantial reforms in education, the government, the judiciary, and the military. In 1861 he proclaimed the emancipation of about 20 million privately held serfs.

  2. Politics and Parliament - What's it all about?

    India has also shown itself capable of operating a parliamentary system and can lay claim to being the world's largest parliamentary democracy; its lower house, the Lok Sabha, having the largest electorate for a genuine parliament. Next door in Pakistan, however, the experience with parliaments has been less happy and more frequently disrupted.

  1. 'The government controls parliament but it cannot always rely on getting its own way.' ...

    These analysed, it will be possible to draw a conclusion on the government's ability to 'rely on getting its own way,' that is, on the extent of its control. Studies of British parliamentary government have identified four main factors upon a combination of which governments must rely for their power over the House of Commons.

  2. European Parliament

    Robert William Sturdy David Sumberg Charles Tannock Jeffrey William Titford Gary Titley Geoffrey Van Orden Theresa Villiers Diana Willis Graham R. Watson Mark Francis Watts Phillip Whitehead Eurig Wyn Terence Wynn How the European Parliament Works... The European Parliament meets and discusses in public.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work