• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Keeping Nelson Mandela in Prison Between 1964 and 1990 was a mistake" Do Sources B to G Prove that this interpretation is correct? Explain Your Answer Using the Sources and Knowledge from your Studies.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Keeping Nelson Mandela in Prison Between 1964 and 1990 was a mistake" Do Sources B to G Prove that this interpretation is correct? Explain Your Answer Using the Sources and Knowledge from your Studies. Whether keeping Nelson Mandela in prison between 1964 and 1990 was a mistake or not is a very controversial issue. His imprisonment and release from prison where very important. I will be examining six sources, some of which suggest it was a mistake keeping him in prison and others which do not. First of all I am going to look at all the sources to discover which ones will help my investigation rather than hinder it. Source B is from a British newspaper, which was against apartheid. It was written before Mandela's release and so would have taken into account the current opinion of the people concerned with the situation, so there for may be quite reliable. However, because the paper, 'The Observer' was anti-apartheid it can not be 100% reliable and correct due to the risk of bias. Also it does not mention the possibility that if Mandela was not imprisoned, he may have continued to e a terrorist in aid of black resistance. Source C is very different from source B, as it is a propaganda poster. ...read more.

Middle

It has turned an ordinary man into a saint." This source published by the observer on the 17h August 1988 also goes onto say that if Mandela hadn't have gone into prison he would have displayed weakness like all other political leaders. This suggestion is coming from someone with a particularly strong view that Mandela's imprisonment was a mistake for the white Afrikaans. Source F also suggests that Mandela was very important for the transition from white oppression to black rule. "Mandela has shown himself to be the great peacemaker, remarkably free of bitterness after his bitterness after his 27 years in prison. His heroes stature has been further increased by his ability to work amicably with his former jailers." What this source suggests is slightly different to what source B suggests. Source F has the opinion that Mandela was a world class statesman whose talents were wasted in prison, where as source B is in the opinion that if Mandela had not gone into prison he would have "displayed weakness like all other political leaders." It is difficult to say whether Mandela would have become the same person, as we will never actually know. Also from prison Mandela would have been able to see the failure of the violence towards the white Afrikaners and so may have decided to change from a terrorist to a peacemaker because of this. ...read more.

Conclusion

If this attitude was continued there may have been several more years of conflict and violence. However when he came into power Mandela decided not to gain revenge by reversing the situation and beginning an era of black oppression and instead became the peacemaker between the two races, this meant the aggravation between the two races could begin to stop. From looking at all the evidence and having the use of my own knowledge I still believe it is difficult to find out whether Mandela's imprisonment was a mistake or not. After analysing all the sources together we are able to see the fuller picture, however when looking at some sources individually we can see that they do not prove a specific point. This is most present in sources C, the poster issued in 1985 by the United Democratic Front (UDF), as there is no real link to Mandela's imprisonment and the issue of whether it was a mistake or not. Also in source E, the election results from 1994 from a book written for use in British schools entitled "South Africa 1948-94" by Rosemary Mulholland. Again there is no real link with his imprisonment and the actual question for which we are analysing the sources. However it does suggest more relevant for which I have been able to use in the answering of this question, such as how Mandela's imprisonment increase support for the ANC and such like. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. How far has the release of Nelson Mandela in 1990 influenced South Africa's social, ...

    Further pass laws were implemented; these identity documents became a sort of passport by which migration to so called 'white' South Africa enforced. 1953 brought The Separate Amenities Act which created separate beaches, buses, hospitals, schools and universities. Everything was segregated.

  2. South Africa 1945-1994 The end of Apartheid.

    The Soweto Riots were also a group who added on time to the ending of apartheid. The riots burnt down the library and the administration block of the University of Zululand on 18 June 1976. The riots spread trouble all around the country and the police met violence with violence.

  1. The ending of white minority rule in South Africa was achieved only because of ...

    what he had seen; and what he hoped to see in South Africa's future. Macmillan's 'wind of change' speech criticised the South African government. In it he said that the aim of the Commonwealth was '...to create a society which respects the rights of individuals'.

  2. Using your own knowledge and the evidence of Sources 1, 3 and 5 what ...

    The modified version of the Humble Petition and Advice still left the army in control. Due to the conflicts between Parliament and Cromwell, an acceptable settlement could not be established, as it would not satisfy everyone. The presence of the army can be considered a weakness as it led to further tensions with Parliament as well as the nation.

  1. Comparative Analysis: The churches and their affect on society and politics in the cases ...

    The testimonies of the released detainees shook the churches and caused a great deal of embarrassment for SWAPO. The Detainee Crisis, compounded with the problem that the CCN became involved in corruption scandals, e.g. the food-aid scam44 led to the CCN losing a great deal of popular support.

  2. Using the evidence of Sources 2, 3 and 5, and your own knowledge explain ...

    This shows that the abandonment of the godly cause was a major reason as to why Cromwell rejected the crown. In addition, "the Providence of God" was a further vital consideration into rejecting the crown. God had already expressed his dissatisfaction with Cromwell by causing the failure of the Western Design.

  1. Use sources E, F and G, and your own knowledge, to explain why the ...

    Other Government Censors edited news papers; pictures of dead bodies were banned from being shown, and so were interviews of people complaining and some stories were suppressed altogether! The government could do this with ease because it had gained total censorship on all newspapers and other publications.

  2. In what ways were the lives of South Africans changed by the policy of ...

    They also believed that without native labour the whole economic system would collapse, if some were communists, it was because they saw the way the capitalist class exploited them as colored proletariat. These developments pushed the hitherto relatively conservative African National Congress into action.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work