• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Mazzini's ideas and inspiration transformed attitudes to change in Italy in the 1830's - Do you agree with this statement?

Extracts from this document...


Jonathan Howell 12MK 08/10/2002 History Essay Mazzini's ideas and inspiration transformed attitudes to change in Italy in the 1830's. Do you agree with this statement? Introduction Guisseppe Mazzini was born in piedmont in Genoa; was a son of a doctor and a professor. He was a depressive and physically frail. In the revolutions of 1820 he became a nationalist. He tried two occupational directions, Medicine but became bored and kept fainting as well as Law that didn't interest him. In 1827 he amalgamated (joined) the Carbonari but was disappointed. In 1830 he took part in the revolts and was arrested then sent to France. In 1831 he formed young Italy when he was 26 years old in Marseilles and was based on Mazzini's own views of how revolution was to succeed in Italy. It was a youth movement. The maximal age limit was 40(Later raised), but most members were much younger. Their motto was 'Thought and action'. They displayed a uniform of the national colours -Green shirt, red belt, white trousers and a beret. They equipped themselves with armaments -a rifle and 50 rounds of ammunition each member. 'Young Italy' was not a localised affair. Its aims were for the whole of Italy, and its contacts international. Mazzini had grand plans for liberal change throughout Europe, and soon groups such as 'young Germany', 'Young Ireland'. 'And young Europe' kept pace with similar patterns. ...read more.


In March 1821 the liberals (moderate and non-violent reformers) appealed to him to lead the revolution, and it seems that he agreed to do so, although he later denied it when it failed. There are also suggestions, though there is no clear evidence for it, that he may have been acting as a government agent and only pretending to be in sympathy with revolutionaries in order to gather information about their plans. Such actions would be in keeping with their clandestine personality. Perhaps, and probably the most likely, he had not made up his mind and just dithered as he hesitated between two or more possible causes of action. 'The legend of Charles Albert' as someone who could not make up their mind has begun. While he was dithering (he was nicknamed the wobbler for this) a revolutionary group seized the fortress of Alessandria in Genoa and established a provisional (Temporary) government calling itself the 'kingdom of Italy' and, rather foolishly declaring war on Austria. This declaration came to nothing because Victor Emmanuel, tired of being strained by revolutionary groups to grant political and social reforms, and worried by reports of new army mutinies in Turin, decided to abdicate. He left for niece, close to the western frontier of piedmont, as revolution spread throughout his kingdom. His brother and heir, Charles Felix, succeeded him, but died in 1831.This left his son Charles Albert to become, at last king of Piedmont. It looked as though his reign was to be as absolute (powerful) ...read more.


Where revolutions were successful in ousting their rulers, the success was only temporary and due more to the failure of Governments to take effective united action. Local affairs, concerned only with limited areas, weakened the revolutions. There was little communication between the revolutionaries in the different states and even less co-operation. The revolutionaries in the different states had even less co-operation ; the revolutionary government in Bologna refused to send help to Modena and elsewhere revolutions were not co-ordinated. They relied heavily on a network of small assemblages of revolutionaries set up by the carbonari and other secret societies, but these were isolated units so their aims differed from place to place. Most revolutionaries were surprisingly moderate in their demands and not accustomed to violence. Usually all they were trying to achieve was the granting of a constitution to allow the people some part in government. The revolutionary governments were mainly middle class, except in Sicily where peasants were involved. Elsewhere revolutionary leaders didn't encourage popular interest and support. Not surprisingly, ordinary people often welcomed back their past rulers with open arms because middle class revolutionaries didn't want mass involvement in revolution. They feared allowing the mob to intervene that was less well educated and would animate a democracy that would unsettle society and its class divisions would reinstate monarchies as well as Republics. In conclusion: I do not accord with the statement that he transformed attitudes but he did adapt many ways of thinking and aided reform. I believe Mazzini to be a famous important publisher and revolutionary that made many changes, that improved society. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. How far do you agree that it was Cavour's diplomacy rather that Garibaldi's ideas ...

    Although, throughout the Risorgimento it is Cavour who is commended for being pragmatic and flexible, Adriana Stiles comments that Garibaldi was also willing to be flexible, but unlike Cavour he would only change in order to increase the chances to liberating Italy: 'He had come under the influence of Mazzini

  2. J. S. Mill Despre Libertate

    si documente considerate eretice sau pe care laicii nu le puteau citi dec�t dupa obtinerea unei aprobari speciale foarte dificil de primit. Aceasta stare de fapte nu era prezenta si �n statele protestante, asa ca �n aceste locuri oricine avea acces la diversele scrieri, acest fapt influent�nd �ntr-o oarecare masura

  1. jeffersonian republicanism

    He wanted peace, commerce and honest friendship with all nations without forming alliances with any. He proposed that a peoples' militia would be implemented to protect the country rather than an army or navy; Jefferson felt a country, so isolated as America, needed little defence.

  2. The causes and the political and social consequences of the Dreyfus Affair in France

    The actual hatred of the Jews increased and certain social classes lent themselves to the impassioned 1200 pages of Drumond's "La France Juive"; on the horrors of Judaism. 150.000 copies sold in 1886. Drumont's book was well documented; it described the genesis of modern Anti-Semitism developed from traditional Anti-Semitism, racism, the occult, Christian anti-Judaism and economic anti-Semitism.

  1. "By 1942, SEAsian Nationalism was largely a failure." How far do you agree with ...

    For example, the Burma Constitution established in 1935. Three Burmese Cabinets were formed, but Governor could not veto any decision made by the Burmese and the Burmese ministers were increasingly allowed to make decisions relating to Burma's society and economy. (iv) SE Asian nationalism saw the formation of intangible aims like raising political consciousness of the people.

  2. How far is it true to say that 'having made Italy', Italian governments were ...

    As at last everyone began to benefit from the new Italy, confidence in the government was re-established, and with it came loyalty and belief in the country. This brought everyone together, although there were of course still dilemmas to overcome.

  1. During the year of 1848, a revolutionary tide broke out in Europe. Revolutions ...

    People wanted to identify their language, culture, traditions and their country. "Nationalists sought to promote the national culture, defined primarily in terms of language and historical heritage, and to equate political structure with the culture."2 Countries such as Germany and Italy were seeking one big united country instead of having different parts of states.

  2. WWI, The Twenty-One Demands and The May Fourth Movement

    This period of Chinese development was instrumental in establishing Communist philosophies throughout China. End Notes 1. "Chinese History, Regent Tour China." http://www.regenttour.com/china/history/roc.htm 2. "The Tragedy of China" http://www.uglychinese.org/revolution.htm 3. China Window :: Chinese History-Republic of China." http://www.china-window.com/china_basic/china_history/chinese-historyrepublic-o.shtml 4. 4Reference || May Fourth Movement."

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work