• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

One of the functions of the House of Commons is to effectively scrutinize the government. Is the House of Commons doing that in today's day and age?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

One of the functions of the House of Commons is to effectively scrutinize the government. Is the House of Commons doing that in today's day and age? The notion of democracy stems from the famous quote by the former U.S President Abraham Lincoln "government of the people, by the people, for the people. The ideal of a democracy is where the government is responsible to its people. Political sovereignty lies with the electorate and therefore it is their representative's i.e. the legislature which ensures an in depth scrutiny of the operations of the government. This view of accountability to the electorate is far more stringent in the English democratic setup where the majority party in the legislature forms the government. The House of Commons is the only body which has the power to scrutinize the government as they are from among themselves. The Commons holds what is known as Question Time on Mondays, Tuesdays and Thursdays every week for 55 minutes and the MP's specially belonging to the non-government party get a chance to put forward their questions to ministers concerning current matters or of public interest etc. ...read more.

Middle

Prime Ministerial Question time is also held once a week on Tuesdays for 30 minutes, the same rules apply here but the notice of questions being asked is fairly limited, which provides for a more effective scrutiny of the Prime Minister and his knowledge regarding the entire government policy is put to the test. The questions put forward to him are of a general nature, focusing on issues on a national level. Otherwise specific questions, if asked, are then put forward to the concerned minister during his question time. Question Time does have its flaws, as any person is allowed to ask a question an MP of the Prime Minister's own political party may be planted to put forward a question. As Prime Ministerial Question time is being aired on national television the planted question is asked just to make him look good in the eyes of the electorate. This completely defeats the purpose of such an exercise and makes a mockery of the proceedings. Private Notice Questions are oral questions which are put forward to ministers without having to follow the rules of giving notice. These questions are normally on urgent matters or of public importance. ...read more.

Conclusion

The sole discretion to adjourn proceedings and allow a 3 hour debate on issues of national importance is upon the Speaker of the House, which like private notice questions is hardly ever given. Select Committees are formed under the Standing Order of the House. There are many different committees formed for specialized fields. For instance there are committees on Human Rights, European Legislation Committee and Accommodation and Works Committee. By convention these committees are made up of back benchers of the political parties sitting in the Commons. The proportion of the MP's in these Select Committees is the same proportion of the political parties in the House of Commons. Therefore the party in government will always have a majority in the Select Committee aswell. A system such as this defeats the purpose of the entire scrutiny as party members in blind faith would allow Bills to be passed proposed by the Government. Most backbenchers are trying to prove their allegiance to their parties and thus do not really encumber the progress of legislation. The processes by which the Commons examines the governments working is therefore satisfactory to a certain extent but party politics play an important role in hindering effective and authentic scrutiny. IBAAD LARI ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Functions of the House of Commons.

    Another function of the House of Commons is debate. Matters of interest are discussed, and this takes place in both the House of Commons and the House of Lords. An example of important debate that has taken place in the House of Commons recently is the debate on whether or not we should go to war against Iraq.

  2. How effectively does Parliament carry out its functions?

    Parliamentary departments create select committees to investigate policy areas, but these are often inconsistent as they can discover potentially damaging information that is often censored. However, in comparison with the pre-1979 period they are a valuable asset to our democratic system.

  1. For my creative piece I have written a short story set in the future, ...

    "Welcome to the Renewable Energy Flight Service. Passengers are now asked to fill up the internal combustion engine using the standard four farts. Any subsequent additions to the standard four shall be multiplied by three, and the cost deducted from your flight." "This is your auto-pilot speaking.

  2. Distinguish between the different functions of the House of Lords and House of Commons

    The House of Lords could either pass the law onto the monarchy if they agree with it and then, it would become an official law or they could delay or amend the bill but only up to a year. With an exception, the House of Lords cannot deal with money bills or public expenditure.

  1. The Impact of Electoral Design on the Legislature.

    Those who become the party's MPs, will be those placed highest in the party's list of candidates. Voters simply vote for the party, they have no say as to which candidates are elected. An open party list system is one that allows the voter to vote either for the list

  2. How effectively do select committees perform their functions?

    Committees only have a small research staff, this is not enough to be able to gather sufficient information to challenge the government. Because committees are not courts, they have no means of enforcing any of their recommendations. Also, it is very difficult to obtain meaningful information from civil servants and

  1. To what extent does ministerial responsibility ensure accountability to the government?

    responsibility for policy errors or failed policies, and whether they go or not usually depends on the support or otherwise of their party. Usually what happens though, if a departmental mistake is brought to the attention of a Minister he usually denies any foreknowledge therefore asserting no personal blame.

  2. Consider the contribution of select committees to the House of Commons' scrutiny of government ...

    The issue on the effectiveness of the select committee can be studied in "The Second Report from the Procedure Committee 1990", which simply assessed the first 10 years of the working of this system. It was submitted that the Select committee is a highly significant and not so much a total break with an evolutionary development albeit.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work