• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The actions of Nellie Hall alocal Birmingham Suffragette - Do the sources support the view that the government and media regard the suffragettes as irresponsible?

Extracts from this document...


William Pearson Assignment 2: 'The actions of Nellie Hall a local Birmingham Suffragette 4. Use all the sources. Do the sources support the view that the government and media regard the suffragettes as irresponsible? The six pieces are all written by different people and are from all different sources. Some are from media backgrounds, some government and some are slightly ambiguous as who they are from. Sources A and D are written by or a direct link to the government, sources B, C and E are by the media and finally source F is a standard letter from the government with an extra note on the bottom written by Nellie Hall herself. Source B is definitely supporting the view that the suffragettes are irresponsible. It is a transcript from a newspaper article, from a local Birmingham paper. It describes the scene in Marylebone Police Court. The source uses lots of language to imply that the women (Nellie Hall included/suffragette) were very irresponsible in court. 'She indulged in an outburst' this implies that she was enjoying it and that she was irresponsible. ...read more.


But, it does go on to suggest ways in which she can help the war effort from home. 'If you wish to assist, I would suggest you should persuade any man you know who is eligible, to do his duty by enlisting at once.' Source F is a standard letter from the prison, but in addition to this there is a note from Nellie Hall on the bottom. This source does not support or support the view that the suffragettes are irresponsible directly. It is from a government prison so therefore the government must have thought that Nellie Hall was an irresponsible so they put her I prison in the first place. But letting her add a message to the end of the letter, which would have been screened, shows an air of respect and responsibility from the government to her. The message on the other hand is about how she is acting irresponsibly by refusing food and water so that she can be released on the temporary discharge, 'The Cat and Mouse Act'. ...read more.


The head line from the article ' FED BY FORCE HOW THE GOVERNMENT TREATS POLITICAL OPPONENTS IN PRISON' and is a statement from a Mrs. Mary Leigh, a suffragette prisoner in Birmingham. The source is littered with quotes from conversations with prison officers about how he was going to force feed her and if she refused by mouth then it was up to him to decide how, namely through the nostrils. Both were said to be a very mentally and physically destroying experience. This source shows how the media do not support the view that the women are irresponsible but the government are and from the government's point of view, the women are being negligent of their bodies and their lives. Overall I think that all the sources are biased towards one side or another so I cannot draw an exact conclusion and also from all the sources there is no definite trend to wards one side or another. From the sources I think generally the government sees the suffragettes as irresponsible but as the media sources are so biased I cannot say whether the media as a whole supports the idea that they are irresponsible members of the community. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Sharpeville Massacre Sources Question

    Understandably, passbooks prompted much anger in the black community. The pass laws had their origins in the 18th century. An average of 250,000 people were arrested for violations of the pass laws between 1916 and 1981 (John Allen, 1995). The ANC and PAC both protested vehemently against the pass laws, and both groups were reportedly present at Sharpeville.

  2. The Suffragettes Project

    The Britannia also attacked politicians and military leaders for not doing enough to win the war. In one article, Christabel accused Sir William Robertson, Chief of Imperial General Staff, of being "the tool and accomplice of the traitors, Grey, Asquith and Cecil".

  1. Decentralization and development of modern local government systems in Eastern Europe

    privatized by the end of 1990s, but the majority of service provision remained public, or private providers received shares-and sometimes even majority ownership-in enterprises providing public services. Others worked more or less as in-house service providers, closely affiliated with local governments or owned by them.

  2. The British Suffragette movement.

    Emmeline Pankhurst in 1914 In 1903 Emmeline Pankhurst founded the Woman's Social and Political Union (WSPU), an organization dedicated to obtaining the vote for women in Great Britain. The WSPU became militant, smashing windows and burning unoccupied buildings to bring attention to its cause.

  1. Would you regard the Taiping movement as just another

    Porters???? and Cohong?? merchants in Guangzhou?? suffered?? in particular since the opening of Shanghai undermined?? the prosperity?? of Guangzhou. Fixed tariffs???? introduced cheap foreign goods to China, thus?? upsetting?? her self-sufficient????? economy. All in all, anti-foreign and anti-Manzhu feelings took root?? in southern China, which at last provided Hong Xiuquan??? with a host??

  2. Belfast Air Raid Sources Questions

    important than money they also covered up the fact that there wasn't enough antiaircraft guns to cover the city. All in all the first two were intended to raise morale and keep the government on the good side of the public while the second two are internal documents which were never intended to bee seen by the public.

  1. Blitz Sources Questions

    Therefore, this source is very useful in telling you about the localisation of the bombing and also how naive most people were because of government censorship. Source C shows a picture of some people after a nights bombing. All their belongings are piled up behind them and they are all smiling at the camera.

  2. Nationalism as applied to business

    They gave a new fixity to the language and thus helped give an idea of permanence to the nation 3. They created languages of power different to the pre-existing language of Latin. Nationalism was thus, Anderson argues, the result of the fusion between the decline of religion, human diversity, the development of capitalism and the technology of print.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work