• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  6. 6
    6
  7. 7
    7
  8. 8
    8
  9. 9
    9

The Clarity Legislation is a part of a 40 year struggle between Canada and Québec.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The Clarity Legislation is a part of a 40 year struggle between Canada and Qu�bec. It is another step in the debate of Qu�bec's political status, a battle that has been going on for much too long. But that is the price that has to be paid for an issue of such importance to be settled democratically (Beaudoin 8). The Clarity Legislation aims " to create a referendum framework for Qu�bec, should Qu�bec express the desire for total sovereignty" (Beaudoin, 8). Therefore, if Qu�bec decides to hold a referendum on sovereignty the Clarity Legislation will mean that Qu�bec's self-determination will lie in unsupportive hands. The Clarity Legislation, also referred to as Bill C-20, means that In the event of any future referendum on sovereignty, the proposed act would give the House of Commons the final right to determine whether or not a "clear question" had been asked, and a "clear majority" achieved, before agreeing to negotiate Qu�bec's secession from Canada (Cariou 1). The issue of Qu�bec's separation has been an issue for far too long, the simple reason is that it is extremely important for the future of Canada as well as Qu�bec. There are many people, including Minister of International Relations Louise Beaudoin, who believe that if Qu�bec separates it has the essential tools needed for positive development. ...read more.

Middle

Whereas in Qu�bec laws of this nature cease to exist. Therefore if Qu�bec is successful in its separation from Canada, the two societies may eventually learn to accept one another because the aforementioned problems will no longer exist. The Clarity Legislation is not a positive step for Qu�bec, despite the attempts of the Chr�tien government to make it seem so. One of the most significant gestures of the federal government towards Qu�bec occurred when the government asked the Supreme Court of Canada "to rule on the legality of a unilateral declaration of independence by Qu�bec" (Montreal Gazette 6/23/2000). In the Canadian system, unlike the system in the United States, it is possible to ask The Supreme Courts opinion in a hypothetical situation. That is why a great number of people also think that, by formulating the questions in a way that would ensure it received the answers it sought, the Canadian government attempted to use its Supreme Court to give the impression that the Qu�bec referendum process was illegal. At the end of this exercise, the Supreme Court found that, in the event of a referendum win by Qu�bec sovereignists, the rest of Canada would have a constitutional obligation to negotiate Qu�bec's sovereignty (Beaudoin 9-10). In a CNEWS interview, Joe Clark spoke on his views on the Clarity Legislation. ...read more.

Conclusion

For those who believe that Qu�bec does not have what it takes to become it own country, here is some information on the actual economic state of Qu�bec. According to the OECD studies Qu�bec ranks seventeenth among the world's economies, which shows that it is a viable State. It also "expresses its modernity fully integrate with its French character, and despite the average size of its population, it is very competitive" (Beaudoin 12). Also Qu�bec is a democratic society. The National Assembly has provided the framework for the debates about Qu�bec's future and the people have made their voices heard through referendums. The Government has respected the people's decision every time and acted on their mandate (Beaudoin 12). The Clarity Legislation is a tactic used by the Canadian Government to try and maintain the upper hand in the continuous battle for Qu�bec's separation. It is an infringement on the democratic rights of Qu�becers. It is a Bill designed to make separation almost impossible for Qu�bec. Through the manipulation of the system, including the hypothetical questioning of the Supreme Court as well as the distribution of members in Parlaiment, the Canadian Government has been able to more or less guarantee its victory against the pro-independent movements. Therefore, if Qu�bec decides to hold a referendum on sovereignty the Clarity Legislation will mean that Qu�bec's self-determination will lie in unsupportive hands. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Multiculturalism in the basis for the Canadian identity.

    Only much later did the French and British arrive to colonize the new world. These three distinct cultures, the roots of Canadian society, form the structure within which Canadian multiculturalism would begin to prosper. After Confederation in 1867, settlers began to move west into the Canadian prairies from Ontario.

  2. Minority Rights, Identity Politics and Gender in Bangladesh: Current Problems and Issues

    (Guhathakurta, 1999) Although women have had constructive role in peace-building during and after conflicts, there is a general tendency to ignore their contribution in formal peace processes i.e. one that entails the drawing up of the peace accord or peace negotiations.

  1. Britain has no written constitution or comprehensive Bill of Rights, and is found partly ...

    However an advantage to our system of ruling as that opposed to codified systems is that it is more effective as, " in the interpretation and application of the law the courts have and rightly have the last word."2.

  2. How do the writers attempt to influence the reader and why do you think ...

    is a bit suspicious and the readers probably would not notice this gap. Some other big names has also been shown in the article like NASA (line33) and the Brazilian National Space Research Institute (line 30) when quoting the facts and figures just to persuade the readers that these figure

  1. Comparative analysis of aboriginal as well as federal government perspective on native self-government in ...

    ------------------------------------ But the right to govern their own lives and affairs is a collective human right that would accrue to them if they were living collectively, no matter where they might live. Second, First Nations believe that there are extraterritorial rights that do not stem from title but from preservation of sovereignty (6).

  2. Civil Service Reform.

    Bogdanor says that it is inevitable that ministers will be tempted to intervene. There is therefore a danger that the 'Next Steps' programme will lead, not to clarification, but to a confusion of responsibility. Bogdanor says that this was certainly the case with the Prison Service (which is an agency)

  1. Should western Canada separate from the rest of Canada?

    Although Western Canada holds only 27% of Canada's population, it produces 52% of Canada's GNP for fishing, forestry, mining, and agriculture, and 90% of Canada's petroleum production. Billions of dollars in both Alberta and British Colombia are lost every year because more taxes are given to the federal government than what is received back in forms of all services.

  2. Tobacco Regulations in Canada and the US.

    He sent copies of a major tobacco company's internal communications from a law firm to Stan Glantz at the University of California at San Francisco who then published The Cigarette Papers. This analysis of what the tobacco companies knew and how they concealed it from the public was also published

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work