• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"The last few decades have seen the erosion of the social democratic post war consensus". Discuss.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Helen Leach "The last few decades have seen the erosion of the social democratic post war consensus". Discuss. When talking in general about political culture, we are talking about the 'commonly shared goals and accepted rules of society' (Marcadis). However, we define British political culture as 'those traditions and styles, which contribute to the workable composition of British politics' (Rose). Traditionally, Britain was seen as having a relatively stable political culture during the 1950's and early 1960's and this was due to the key roles played by consensus and deference. During the years 1951 to 1979, there seemed to be a broad agreement between politicians of differing political viewpoints, this was particularly true for the '50's and '60's. 1945 to 1951 saw many heated ideological debates over the creation of the Welfare State, nationalisation and the growth of government. However, the Tory rule from 1951 to '64 and the 1964-1970 Labour government produced merely conflicts over details. The reason for this broad agreement was because the Tories had come to accept the bulk of Labour's post war reforms after 1951. There was also general affluence and rising living standards, due to full employment. The consensus included a commitment to all aspects of the Welfare State, including council houses, state intervention in the economy and multi-lateral defence. ...read more.

Middle

The Liberal Revival of 1974, the short lived success of the Greens in the '80's and the revival of fascism in local policies in the early '90's all illustrate the rise in anti-partyism. The failure in restoring economic stability in Britain has caused the public to loose confidence within the two main parties. Loss of pride within our institutions is claimed to also be increasing in society. The 'mishandling' of Princess Diana's death and the constant media coverage of Prince Charles' private life places the Monarchy under constant scrutiny. Also since the late '60's aspects of British life have been increasingly scrutinised, perhaps because of the economic decline. There are also strong criticisms about the judiciary and the police, after the MacPherson report highlighted the inadequacies of the police during the Stephen Lawrence tragedy. However, although deference was in decline, the old post war consensus was strong till the late 70's. Although it's arguable that from 70-72 this was not the case. Heath tried and failed to tinker with the government's commitment to economic planning and a comprehensive Welfare State in the early '70s and was forced to do a 'U' turn on such policies in '72. It was the 'Winter of Discontent' which developed some support for the more right wing conviction politics of the Conservatives' new leader, Margaret Thatcher. ...read more.

Conclusion

Major was seen as more conciliatory, more caring and a greater readiness to listen. There also was a seemingly more collectivist style of Cabinet government and Major was interpreted as being more consensual. For example the abolition of the poll tax. Some policy proposals even seemed to be borrowed from Labour, e.g. transport, and citizens' charters aimed at improving public services. However many Thatcherite policies were still pursued. Some even argue that the Major government was a government of hesitancy, obsessed with PR and media images in an electorally unpopular time warp. It is now argued that in its desire to look prudent, Labour has accepted a great deal of 'Thatcherist' policies. Labour is more committed to the NHS, constitutional reform and Europe has modified some Tory education policies, but some supporters remain disappointed. Labour may be interpreted as a modernised Butskellism, hence Hague's problems in choosing topics where the Tories appeared different, like Ian Duncan Smith is currently struggling to do. Post war Britain has experienced a sharp decline in international status and relative economic prosperity. It is arguable that this has led to more criticism of the governing elites and may have sapped their confidence. The public also being more critical of procedures and institutions has resulted in less faith in British politicians. The decline in deference has also made the public more demanding of government and less tolerable of failure. M. Moran suggests that Britain's previous stability during the 1950's was an aberration rather than the norm. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. What are the key features of a liberal democratic state?

    This allowed the police to hold potential terrorists in custody for longer than normal suspects. Human rights protest groups opposed this decision but because it was thought another terrorist attack was likely in the west the decision was made regardless. On the whole government intervention can and does vary considerably.

  2. Why Did the Post-war Consensus Breakdown?

    The changes took over two years to complete. The NHS came into operation on 5 July 1948. For the final 'giant', 'want', the Family Allowances Act of 1945 along with the National Assistance Act of 1948, set out to solve the problem. The Family Allowances Act meant that a weekly payment was to be made to all mothers who had more than one child.

  1. What led to the breakdown of the post war political consensus?

    At this point in time Great Britain was seen as 'the sick man of Europe' who, was suffering the 'British disease' and the symptoms of this disease were unemployment, inflation and regular strikes which were led by the much powerful trade unions among many other issues.

  2. To what extent was there a 'post war consensus' between 1945-1970.

    Anthony Seldon was convinced that the N.H.S. would have remained the same regardless of who was in power, stating that it was 'difficult to imagine that Labour would have managed the N.H.S. very differently in these years'. Benefits continued to be paid under the Social Security System and welfare expenditure

  1. What Are The Key Elements Of Thatcherism? To What Extent Was It A Reaction ...

    During the post war concensus the relationship between government and unions was close. Thatchers 'new right' however was hostile towards trade unions. The hostility was due to three main factors. There was an element of fear of the unions. This reached fever pitch when the miners strike of 1974 led to the downfall of the health government.

  2. To what extent have the principles of the welfare state been eroded since 1979

    The conservative leaders Thatcher to Major (1990), based the welfare state direction with notions of 'responsibility and prudence' (Hay 1996). For example 'Poll tax', was very unpopular (important contributor to her resignation) but Thatcher felt everyone should pay equal amounts as everyone gets the same service (Timmins: 1996).

  1. The Creation of the Welfare State

    some children who hadn't had a bath in two months or more, they also found that a few children didn't even know how to use a toilet properly.

  2. Malta at the turn of the 19th Century.

    And knew the Italian and English language. The voter had to have a clean conduct and had a certain amount of money or lands. The election was very successful as nearly everybody eligible to vote went to vote. The Maltese grumbled on the fact that the franchise was based on financial qualifications.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work