• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Scottish Parliament despite its powers has been a political disappointment, whereas the Welsh assembly, despite its lack of power has exceeded political expectations.' Discuss.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'The Scottish Parliament despite its powers has been a political disappointment, whereas the Welsh assembly, despite its lack of power has exceeded political expectations.' Discuss. On the 1st of July 1999 the Scottish Parliament assumed its full powers and duties. This was a devolved government, where some legislative powers were transferred from Westminster to the Parliament in Scotland. The Scottish parliament was designed to embody the links between the people of Scotland, the members of the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Executive. The powers of duty are divided between the Scottish Executive (handles ministerial powers and duties) and the Secretary of State for Scotland (holds responsibilities relating to reserved matters). The Secretary of State however, remains a member of the UK cabinet. Most importantly, it can pass primary legislation and has tax varying powers. The Government of Wales act was passed in 1998, which established a national assembly for Wales. This was endorsed by a referendum on 18th of September 1997. This enabled a transfer of the powers from the secretary of state for Wales to the assembly itself. The first secretary, Rhodri Morgan is responsible for ensuring that the cabinet works well as a team, constitutional relationships, cost cutting and Europe. ...read more.

Middle

Unrealistic expectations of the difference between a centre left government in Scotland and also in Westminster are what has possibly been the most important disappointment. In comparison to this, the Welsh Assembly, despite having limited legislative powers has passed 911 statutory instruments of it's own. This is a big difference from the measly 76 from Scotland. However, due to the nature of the Assembly, the legislative passed does not give the most radical changes, such as the reintroduction of free milk for schools, although the Welsh people see it as reinforcing that the Assembly does work and does provide with changes, however small. This is important when you consider that only about a quarter of Welsh people were in favour of the Assembly to begin with. Where the media were seen to gradually portray the Welsh Assembly as a limited yet effective force, the Scottish Parliament, who was more actively involved in the media, was seen to be a failed experiment. Every small failing was blown out of proportion, University Fee's was recorded as being a bigger disagreement than it was leading to distrust from the Scottish people. The Welsh Assembly, attracting little media attention was given a more positive spin from the press. ...read more.

Conclusion

In conclusion, I think that the point has become clear throughout the assessment of the Welsh Assembly and the Scottish Parliament, that both establishments have had failures and successes of their own. However, it can be argued to some extent that the Scottish Parliament has been labelled a political disappointments whilst the Welsh Assembly is seen to have exceeded expectations due to the feelings from both of the country towards devolution; and how that establishment has performed since then. The Welsh Assembly began with very little support and the Welsh people were pleasantly surprised when it started passing a great amount of legislation, whereas there was an outcry for Scottish devolution and although legislation was passed, it wasn't in the leagues and to the effect that it was expected to be. Due to this I think that I agree with the initial statement, even though both establishments had a lot of problems through both leadership and failings in the first few years. I think that the Scottish Parliament simply needs more time to assert itself as an effective devolved institution, then it will be more obvious to people of the actual limits of the Welsh Assembly. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    'First-past-the-post should be replaced as a method of electing political representatives.' Discuss.

    5 star(s)

    An example of this was the 1997 election when the Conservatives gained 18% of the vote in Scotland but not one seat. This is mirrored at constituency level, where the winning candidate may have received only one third of the votes cast.

  2. To what extent was Northumberland more successful in solving mid Tudor political problems than ...

    This was good politics for it showed respect for colleagues. Efficiency came with the acceptance of Pagets advice on the routine of the council. A fixed pattern of business was initiated with a small working group at the heart of the larger council membership of 33.

  1. "The British Parliament is weak whereas the US Congress is powerful." Discuss.

    The superiority of the House of Commons to the House of Lords in the UK makes an unbalanced bicameral legislature.4 The representative role of Parliament and Congress is the fundamental role they perform. They are the bodies to which individuals are elected to represent the people.

  2. This assignment identifies and discusses the major social and political trends expected to affect ...

    It is recommended that Spoornet puts in place an effective and efficient managed care system for HIV/AIDS infected employees. This programme should focus on increasing knowledge, skills and awareness as well as provide continued care and support. Training, education and awareness programmes should be implemented once the infrastructure is in place to ensure prevention.

  1. What are the advantages and disadvantages of the devolution process in Scotland and Wales?

    Polls in both Scotland and England conclude that the public find the situation unfair. For example, the legislation imposing top-up fees for English students was passed by only a small majority in Westminster. At the time opposition education secretary Tim Yeo argued that this low majority indicated that the passing

  2. Tiananmen Square

    Many thought the Chinese government was corrupt because nepotism was being seen among the leaders of the party. Nepotism is when an important figure, such as Deng, allows only his friends and family into the top jobs. And by doing that people like Deng have built an invisible barrier between

  1. Russia - political past, present and future

    How would the shift occur and what would it be successful? The new Russia needed a leader that would lead it to democracy, Gorbachev's rival and the most active leader of the opposition Boris Yeltsin, quickly succeeded as the first president of the post-soviet Russia.

  2. Scottish devolution.

    The first is cast for a constituency Member of the Scottish Parliament (MSP) in the same way that Westminster Members of Parliament are elected. Each voter has one 'X' vote and has a choice of one candidate from each party.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work