• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Too much democracy is a recipe for anarchy. Discuss.

Extracts from this document...


"Too much democracy is a recipe for anarchy." Discuss. Political theorist have often accepted the claim that a modern regime in which most or at least a large number of men have the vote is regarded as democratic. "Democracy belongs to the sphere of collective decision making for the association for all. Democracy in other words entails the twin principles of popular control over collective decision-making and equality of rights in the exercise of the control". This is a statement from 'Introducing democracy'. The word 'democracy' originates from Athens. Athens called itself a democracy because all its citizens could take part in political decision but this was not the case as 'all citizens' did not include 'all adults', women, slaves and resident aliens and people from different parts of Greek cities could not participate. Political theorist have often accepted the claim that modern regimes in which most or at least a large number of men have the vote is regarded as democratic. 'Majority' is therefore regarded as more than half and as Concordant in late eighteenth century stated the plurality rule where the largest single number of votes win even though half of them voted the opposition party are allowed to rule is still called a democracy. These statements are taken from the 'Oxford concise dictionary of politics'. In my essay I will be discussing the content of democracy and how different political theorist have conflicting opinions of what democracy means. Most writers have been nervous that too much democracy may lead to anarchism. ...read more.


There is a present danger in 'tyranny of the majority'. In anarchy community where all adult citizens are members of the legislature, it is virtually impossible to limit the power of the majority. Unchecked rule by the majority leads to the majority's abuse of political authority and the minorities loss of rights, the majorities self interests and governing in an overbearing fashion, deprives members of the minority of their legal rights, there are no institutions safeguards to moderate and restrain the exercise of movement power and prevent the majority from riding roughshod over the rights and vital interests of members of the minority. Mill and Tocqueville made clear that there were matters over which minorities should remain sovereign, which could not be decided by the majority vote. In this way people would feel secure enough what mostly concerned them...knowing that their decisions would leave their fundamental freedoms unaffected'. In this content balancing democracy would allow citizens to feel free knowing their freedoms will not be effected and thus in turn will not turn to anarchism as the state is giving freedom to the individual rights and liberty which the state has to obligate to. Theorist in the traditional 'protective theory of democracy', started from the Hobbesian assumption that government is necessary in order to avoid civil war and social breakdown and to these ends governments are needed with enough power to enforce order. (Hobbs 1651) but Hobbes paid less attention to: if governments have enough power to stop civil war and breakdown they almost have enough power to exploit their own populations. ...read more.


With the 'unwritten constitution' it would be easier to overthrow the government and make laws and legislation, which will only benefit a minority group, taking the freedom and liberty away from the majority, which is exercised by representative democracy. In conclusion it would be right to say 'too much democracy would lead to anarchism'. As people lack the capacity to govern society effectively. I do not hold the view of Plato who favours aristocracy and well educated of only making decisions in government. I do believe though we are not all created equal as some people in society are gifted by parental occupations and social backgrounds which help develop an individual faster than a child who is born from a poor background. That is not to say a person from a poor background cannot participate in government and are incapable of making a decision. Instead I believe citizens are capable of choosing a small group of leaders and even participating within government themselves who are to govern society. Democracy according to its underlying and supporting political theory is superior over anarchy. It safeguards liberty and ensures justice as James Madison stated. This would include holding the government accountable to the electorates through checks and balances. While being impractical to expect the people to govern society without any authority, it is quite practical to expect them to choose societies rulers from among rivals who will be in office until their term expires. I will end by quoting 'Democracy it would seem has ceased to be a matter of contention and has become a matter of convention.' (Democracy Albert Weild). ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Malta at the turn of the 19th Century.

    However Maitland was more interested about the problems he head about the sanctuary and the Church of St. John. He threatened to abolish the right to sanctuary if this fact over-involved the administration. He was ready to retain the church power in its authority, if the latter didn't go against the British policy.

  2. The Impact of Electoral Design on the Legislature.

    constituencies do far less well than those like nationalist parties with a strong concentration in key regions. Hence, for example, in the 1993 Canadian elections the Progressive Conservatives won 16.1 percent of the vote but suffered a chronic meltdown to only two MPs.

  1. WWI, The Twenty-One Demands and The May Fourth Movement

    is to be the subject of an exchange of notes as has already been agreed upon by the Representatives of both nations, will undertake to detach the Group V from the present negotiations and discuss it separately in the future.

  2. Devolution is not a "constitutional settlement" but a dynamic (and potentially destabilising) process. ...

    This regionalism however, is not as popular as Mr Prescott would like. By May 2000, London had its own mayor, ken Livingston. This was a major change of the Greater London borough, as since the Thatcher years, the Greater London Council had been abolished.

  1. Citizenship - participating in society

    All four pupils in year 7 said that the slideshows was fantastic and fabulous. They also commented on the pictures saying that the pictures were funny. I chose to make the PowerPoint appealing because it would be fun as well as informative and I think I achieved that purpose.

  2. J. S. Mill Despre Libertate

    De aceea se poate considera ca Mill a pregatit �n felul acesta separarea dintre teoria comertului international si teoria valorii �n munca, separare care va fi totala si desav�rsita ulterior de adeptii marginalismului. Mill cu toate eforturile si multe merite nu a reusit sa rezolve total problema legii valorii pe

  1. Social Anarchism

    The motivation for this sort of governing is to prevent social class division between the "bosses" and "the working class" and also allow people to have the right to make a difference, since it's their country and their lives these decisions affect.

  2. Notes on Citizenship and Democracy.

    We have majority rule without imposing on the minority 1. We can remove the government from power. This happens because that party didn?t keep the promises he made before the election. 1. Equality in front of the law. Everyone has the right to a fair trial.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work