• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Using your own knowledge and the evidence of Sources 1, 3 and 5 what do you consider to have been the main strengths and weaknesses of the Protectorate, 1653-1658?

Extracts from this document...


a) Using your own knowledge and the evidence of Sources 1, 3 and 5 what do you consider to have been the main strengths and weaknesses of the Protectorate, 1653-1658? Cromwell was installed as Lord Protector in December 1653, and throughout his time as Protector, Cromwell aimed to 'heal and settle' the wounds of the past and to create a 'godly England'. However, by the end of his life the Protectorate had the support of a narrow population. Nevertheless, the Protectorate had various strengths and weaknesses. An evident strength of the Protectorate was the aim to achieve a civilian based government as shown in Source 3, where Cromwell did attempt to "make parliament representative" as well as to give Parliament "a genuine role in the constitution". The system of government was fairly stable, under the Instrument of Government, both Parliament and Protector were to control the militia and a provision was made for parliaments to be elected every three years and had to sit for a minimum of three years. In addition, the Protector had to rule with the Council of State, particularly in key matters such as finance, appointment of senior ministers. Furthermore, the Humble Petition and Advice accepted in May 1657 represented a compromise between the Protector and Parliament. ...read more.


The Protectorate narrowed its support by restricting the franchise to those who were 21yrs old and had property. The Commonwealth men opposed the single person element in government and felt Parliament did not enough power, and Cromwell was "accused of being both a hypocrite and a turn-coat". In addition, royalists generally opposed the regime, particularly when the Decimation Tax was introduced as it alienated them further. The military element of the regime was resented by the gentry. Therefore, it seems Cromwell "got the worst of both worlds", in that there were conflicting interests and aims, the "excessive demands of others" hindered Cromwell to "bring democracy to its head". b) Using all the evidence of the sources, and your own knowledge, explain how far you agree that "The stability and survival of the Protectorate from 1653-1658 was wholly dependent on Oliver Cromwell himself". It is evident that Cromwell was an ambitious and industrious character; he became Lord Protector out of the "desire to prevent mischief and evil" rather than to "serve...as a King", this he made clear in his speech to the Second Protectorate Parliament in 1657, Source 4. Therefore, Cromwell wanted to lead "as a constable", however Cromwell had become more involved and although he wanted to "keep the peace of the parish", more than that as Lord Protector, he wanted to achieve his personal vision of the 'rule of Saints'. ...read more.


Although, the Protectorate was fairly dependent on Cromwell, Parliament also contributed significantly to the regime, the proposal of the Humble Petition and Advice in 1657 was an attempt to create more checks and balances and to balance power. Cromwell did need to work with Parliament, as he needed the approval of Parliament in order to make the regime legal. Therefore, the "stability and survival of the Protectorate" did very much so depend on Cromwell, as suggested by Cyril Robinson, she identifies that the Protectorate was no longer able to survive after Cromwell's death, because "the Protector himself had been to strong". On the contrary, Michael Lynch believes that Cromwell never actually "pushed his authority to the point where he had a genuine controlling power". However, there is agreement in that Cromwell did attempt to achieve "effective civilian government" and that "religious difficulties were in a large measure overcome". But, it needs to be taken into account that as Cyril Robinson is a Whig historian, this school of thought portray as Cromwell as a strong dictator, which is not necessarily a bad criticism. Overall, the Protectorate was dependent on Oliver Cromwell, but not necessarily "wholly", because Cromwell did have to work with Parliament in order to achieve a settlement. But, the Protectorate did heavily rely on Cromwell's personality and political as well as military skills. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Evaluate the extent to which the United Kingdom Parliament is sovereign. Consider both legal ...

    Furthermore, in law the courts are duty bound to follow legislation, and it has been suggested that perhaps the courts have a more passive role in applying and interpreting legislation. Legally, this may be true, and in fact Dicey has even stated that a law binding future Parliament's would be valid.

  2. Assess the strengths and weaknesses of Pluralism in domestic politics

    of human nature is that the individual can learn, change and progress. The constant evolution of human nature has led to the development of a complicated structure of groups of individuals who have different roles in the societies they live in.

  1. To what extent was religion the main causeOf rebellion in the reign of Henry ...

    Robert Aske named this uprising using a religious name. This meant that many more people would join, as all the people of England didn't agree with Henry VIII's new religious policy, thus gaining the most support. Calling it anything else might of stopped the appeal, or destroyed it.

  2. Evaluate strengths and weaknesses of various voting systems regarding voting

    group of the electorate have significance out of proportion to their number. Mainly because of the problems of disproportional and unfairness in the British simple plurality system, since the 1970's discussion of reform has become almost a permanent feature of the political system increasing as either Labour or Liberal Democratic parties feel more disadvantaged.

  1. Sharpeville Massacre Sources Question

    held for such long periods in detention and then often either released without being charged or when charged usually acquitted; but this does not free them from police harassment. Though often declared innocent by the courts, they are often punished by being banned (again without recourse to the courts)

  2. The Negative Impact Of World War 1 On Italy: Weaknesses Of The Liberal State, ...

    By late summer 1922 public opinion in Italy had fully polarised, the Liberals left almost irrelevant in the middle, having already lost effective control in some provinces. But the fascists had the upper hand. When the Socialists called a general strike in August (in an attempt to force the government to act against the fascist violence)

  1. How has the role and impact of military rulers and civilian politicians differed in ...

    his rule were forced to tender their resignation or were posted as Officer on Special Duty (OSDs)14. Zia in order to give the President more powers introduced the 8th amendment in the constitution according to which the President has the authority to dismiss the elected governments.

  2. Assess the strengths and weaknesses of Parnell as a leader of the Irish cause.

    To Parnell, these months had been spent gaining support for nationalism, and forging new alliances with the agrarian masses. By showing his support for them, and by declaring that they should "deprive this [landlord] class of their privileges", he

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work