• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Was Germany as a Nation Ready For a Democracy?

Extracts from this document...


Was Germany as a Nation Ready For a Democracy? The democratic Weimar Republic was set up in 1919, but was Germany ready for a democratic nation, where the people ruled the country indirectly through a government, instead of the autocratic system that they had been used to for so long? At the end of the First World War Germany was one of the largest industrialised nations in the world, amongst the USA, France, Great Britain, Russia and Austria. Of these the USA, France and Great Britain were all democracies, whereas the other three were not. The democracies at the time appeared to be the nations achieving victories in wars. An example of this, outlined in Encarta 99 by an unknown author, was Britain in the Boer Wars (1899-1902) fought Dutch colonists for possession of gold and diamond mining areas of southern Africa. In January of 1901 it appeared Britain had won, but then fighting broke out again, to be restored to a compromise of peace in 1902. On the other hand, those countries who were not democracies were losing wars, for example Russia's defeat in the Russo-Japanese War in 1905(information taken from Encarta 99, author not stated). ...read more.


(Williamson, D.G., The Third Reich, 1985) Germany's population in general had no real idea of what a democracy was, having never lived in one, and never having had a political system even close to a democracy. Many people wanted things to stay how they were, afraid of change. The Government before the Revolution contained a large variation within itself. It had two houses, the Bundesrat(upper house) and the Reichstag(lower house). The Bundesrat was formed of the aristocracy, the landowners and state governors. The Reichstag was made up of a number of parties, and a number of these showed the way forward for democracy, for example the SDP, liberal parties (e.g.. DVP) and conservatives. The spectrum of variation within the government showed there was room for political change, with a large number of different views held within parties made up of different classes of people, all interested in benefiting different sectors of the population. However, despite this contemporary willingness within the government for a move towards socialism and liberalism, previous political leaders had been very against both of these, and this attitude would have been drummed into the population, some of which would still have been remaining in them. ...read more.


Throughout German history one person had ruled the country, but changing to a democracy meant that the whole nation would, in effect, be ruling the country. This dramatic change could lead to extremism, with the autocracy fighting against communism. Was Germany ready as a nation to become a democracy? Although democracy appeared to be working in other industrialised nations at the time, e.g. the USA, Germany was not ready for the system. Pockets of the population, e.g. the Socialists, wanted a democratic system, but a combination of factors meant the country was not prepared. Generally within the public, following the First World War, there was an anti-socialist feeling(because of the "stab in the back" idea which blamed the socialists for losing the war), and as socialists wanted democracy this turned the population against it. Economic frailty following the Treaty of Versailles made Germany weak and meant it was not a good time for a dramatic political change. If Germany had changed to a democracy a decade or so later, after the repercussions of World War 1 would have had time to ease and die down a bit, it would have been more likely to be successful, but at this point in history Germany was not ready to become democratic. ?? ?? ?? ?? Megan Edwards 12HO ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. -Did the Weimar Republic become more stable?-How loyal were the elites and the German ...

    That was a big thing it was missing cos people looked up to charismatic and inspiring people. Further evidence of stability comes from the presidency election in 1925, presidency was important in the Republic, given its power to appoint and dismiss chancellors.

  2. Weimar Germany 1918-23: Was the Weimar Republic Doomed to Failure?

    This would ultimately lead to an indecisive government. Unlike the left-wing politicians, the entire right wing were unified in their fight against the democratic socialist system. The KPD and the USPD did not want a constitutional monarchy unlike the SPD leadership who were in favour of this. Similarly, the USPD admitted that the right wing revolts of their earlier days had been protests against militarism not capitalism.

  1. Nationalism as applied to business

    what is governing? and who is governed? 'In the one case it was in sum a matter of knowing how one 'governed' the mad, now it is how one governs oneself. . . . (H)ere I would like to show that the government of self is integrated with the government of others.

  2. The Advent of Imperialism

    With the introduction of Protestant missions during the nineteenth century, the trouble has grown apace. Though the Chinese as a nation have never displayed religious intolerance, they have naturally mistrusted the motives of Westerns who, calling themselves Christians, quarreled amongst themselves, and by their tactless zeal often caused local rioting which led to diplomatic or armed interference for their protection.

  1. Final Draft for Democracy

    is better than being ruled by England, a country that doesn't even know of the problems or happening in the new world.

  2. American Democracy: An Ongoing Experiment

    These parties have little bearing on government today. It was the American Civil War that prompted the inception of the prominent parties which run our modern government. Although its ideology may have evolved in years following the war, the Republican party was founded on the belief that no man should be the property of another.

  1. The Business Culture of Germany

    Reducing employment. 2. Bridging gaps between East and West Germany - "Aufbau Ost" Major branches of Industry 1.

  2. Notes on Citizenship and Democracy.

    Unfortunately such development was used in an incorrect way. For example the recent riots in England happened because the media showed the video were the police shot an innocent. 1. Because of easy communication and development in technology everything became cheaper and people starting migrating more to find better jobs.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work