• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Was the collapse of the provisional government inevitable

Extracts from this document...


Was the collapse of the provisional government inevitable? By definition, a provisional government is an emergency or interim government set up when a political void has been created by the collapse of a previous administration or regime. A provisional government holds power until elections can be held or a permanent government can otherwise be established. Provisional governments often occur as the result of a revolution or in wartime when an occupied nation or territory has been liberated or when a government has been deposed by an invading army. In this case as a result of revolution and with abdication of Tsar in Feb 1917, the provisional government consisting mainly of liberals from the old Duma was set up. Until a new elected government- the constituent assembly was set up, they were to keep the country running. Alexander Kerensky, a member of the social revolutionaries became the Prime Minister after Lvov resigned. Yes, I agree that the collapse of the provisional government was inevitable to a larger extent than to it being evitable The provisional government also had one major disadvantage: its leaders - especially Kerensky - were associated with the middle class. ...read more.


The irony part is that the revolution, made partly based on dissatisfaction with the war, led to the election of socialist partied that tried to turn political power over to Russia's landlords and capitalists who continued the war as if no revolution had happened. In fact, the latter initially believed that the revolution might restore the faith of the masses in the war effort and lead the troops to fight hard for their newly won "freedom." Far from making the war more efficient, the February revolution ushered in a period of intense class conflict which fatally undermined the army's discipline and cohesiveness. The army, made up of predominantly peasant conscripts, increasingly came into conflict with the officer corps, drawn heavily from the families of landlords and nobles. The struggle in the countryside between the peasants and landlords infected the army, as both officers and soldiers heard news from home about forcible land redistribution, and even more directly when the military was called on to repress the peasant movement in the countryside. When they 'gave up' on the war, not only did the Russians feel sad, they felt that they had 'lost face' as well. ...read more.


Even though most of the reasons why the provisional government collapse could have been solved if the leaders had been more observant and alerted earlier but if they were not so, as proven in the case here, the collapse of the provisional government was inevitable as they could not always satisfy everyone even if they had though through, thus inevitable, nor have everyone's support because of that. If they lost support through a wrong move (which could have been avoided) or they could have tried to have a strong relationship with the people, thus not losing support under any circumstances, the collapse would have been evitable although it would have taken a lot of speculation and planning in front of time, which was quite impossible so I think that the collapse of the provisional government is inevitable to a larger extent than it being evitable. A provisional government holds power until elections can be held or a permanent government can otherwise be established so it will have to 'retire' sooner or later, thus showing its inevitable in this case that it has to 'collapse' no matter what happens. Done by Anthea (2006) ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. "The Provisional Government was overthrown because it decided to continue fighting in World War ...

    However, the troops obeyed the Soviet's order no.1, which encouraged the soldiers to disobey government orders which contradicted those of the Soviet.

  2. Was the Provisional Government doomed to failure?

    The people of Russia were strongly opposed to the war, so when the Provisional Government announced the formation of a new 'Coalition Government' on the 5th of May, in order to control the conduct of the war, criticism was piled on the Mensheviks and the Socialist Revolutionaries who had taken

  1. Comparing the German and Russian systems of government

    The prime minister is selected by the president but must be approved by the Duma. If the president's choice is rejected however, the chamber can be dissolved by the president and new elections called. The Russian president, unlike the German counterpart, has strong control over his executive branch.

  2. Was the Provisional Government fatally weakened from the first? Notes

    It had, therefore, to compromise with the Soviet. Between February and April this arrangement worked as a reasonably effective accord, which allowed a series of important changes to take place. A number of factors helped this 'dual authority' to operate. One was the euphoria experienced in Petrograd in the weeks following the tsar's abdication.

  1. Was the provisional government doomed to failure from the beginning

    vast amount of the population and the vast amount of the revolutionary movement. He knew to keep them happy would be to gain power. The Bolsheviks also had an organised army called the Red Guard. The provisional government's army was very quickly becoming very corrupt and unorganised so the army of the Bolsheviks offered a huge threat.

  2. It was the weakness of the provisional government that brought the October revolution about ...

    Faced with an incompetent and weak government, increasing food and fuel shortages, and the lack of police or army presence, much of the country turned to desperate crime. In the country, peasants seized land as fast as they could, often looting and burning the large, stately mansions of landowners as they went.

  1. The Provisional Government, March-November 1917.

    Victory in the war would have been a great boost for the Provisional Government but it did not come in time. `The Petrograd Soviet issued Order Number One which advised the soldiers to ignore normal military discipline: this meant that officers no longer had to be obeyed and revolutionary committees could take over'.

  2. Why were there two Revolutions in Russia in 1917? Why did the Bolsheviks ...

    Eight Principles were produced to try and put an end to the restlessness. These Involved; "Freedom of Speech, Assembly and Right to strike, No religious, national or social privileges, organising a Constituent Assembly and elections for local councils and Zemstva and the abolition of police units.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work