• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Weimar Republic governments were remarkably successful in dealing with the economic and political problems that they faced 1919-23" Do you agree?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Weimar Republic governments were remarkably successful in dealing with the economic and political problems that they faced 1919-23" Do you agree? When the Republic was first 'born' in 1919 they faced a huge amount of problems - both internal and external. Not only did they have a remarkably unstable government, but also faced threats from both the left and the right. Furthermore to this their economic problems were extremely acute. Historians such as Stephen Lee believe that the government "emerged by 1924 with a stability that suggested reasonable success". Whether this is to be taken as true or not, it cannot necessarily be taken as true that the government were responsible for creating that stability. To decipher their role in stabilising events between 1919-23 it is necessary to look at each problem individually and asses the governments role and the outcome of these events. At the very heart of problems was the fact that the government was remarkably unstable. Hannah Vogt believes that 'the men who were to pick up the reins of government faced a tremendous, thankless task'. With this in mind it is obvious the need for a stable government was great, as they were not to be given much support from others they should at least obtain it from themselves! Their first stumbling block was the constitution and voting system. The constitution, though well thought out and well meaning, had one fatal flaw: article 48. ...read more.

Middle

However the army were quick to act and hundreds were killed as the Reichswehr restored normality. There is little success or control in this action, merely brutality. Also extremely significant were the Right wing uprisings, including the Kapp Putsch. Both General Von Luttwitz and Wolfgang Kapp strongly disagreed to the army cuts the government had agreed to by signing the treaty of Versailles. The men of the Balitkum Brigade and also a Brigade led by Hermann Ehrhardt (who were due to be disbanded) joined with members of the Freikorps, making their numbers up to 12,000 men. They then chose to march through the Brandenburg gates and Kapp planned to become chancellor. The Reichstag members were forced to flee to Bresden and then to Stuttgart. Although the army was not in support of the Putsch, they refused to act. General Von Seeckt claimed, "Reichswehr does not fire on Reichswehr". Before leaving, Ebert and Bauer had urged the workers to strike. "No factory must work while the military dictatorship of Ludendorff and the others rule. Down your tools! Come out on strike! Fight with all means for the Republic" This proved very effective. There was no water, electric, gas, or public transport. Civil servants would not follow Kapps orders and the banks would give him no money. After only 4 days it collapsed. "in reality, the putsch had been mistimed, badly planned and failed to muster anything like to expected support. ...read more.

Conclusion

The French tried to deport those who tried to strike, and 150 workers were killed. During and after the invasion of the Ruhr there was massive inflation. In 1914 £1 was worth 20marks, by 1919 it had risen to 250 marks. However there is great debate as to what caused this inflation. Synder claims that, "the entire problem was closely connected with the reparations demanded by the allies". Stephen Lee believes that "the dramatic collapse of the mark was the direct result of this occupation [of the Ruhr] and the passive resistance to it". There is then another argument from Kolb who believes "the governments passiveness in the matter of currency stabilisation is no doubt to be interpreted as part of its strategy over reparations". Synder rejects this view as "incorrect and unjust" He maintains that "the process of inflation was already under way when the French occupied the Ruhr". No matter which Historians version you choose to believe the governments coping methods can be judged similarly. Looking at Stephen Lee and Kolb's argument the government's actions can be seen as pitiless. Looking at the results of their action i.e. loss of German life and the huge inflation it was a merciless and selfish act. By looking at Synder's view, it should have been obvious to the government that a general strike would only further aggravate the problem of inflation. From looking at the problems faced by the Republic, and the way in which they dealt with them, it can be said that whilst they managed to get through them, this was mainly through either sheer force or luck. Mhairi B Thomson Word count: 1929 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. How successful were the Labour governments of 1924 and of 1929-31?

    A clear example of this was with the case of unemployment where there was no such strategy. Although raising unemployment benefits was mentioned as a positive, there was the obvious negative to follow, that more people would just prefer to be unemployment and collect about half of what they would normally collect in exchange for doing nothing.

  2. To what extent was Northumberland more successful in solving mid Tudor political problems than ...

    As a result of this, grain prices soared. The Population, and inflation had both risen rapidly. This meant that the living standards of the masses continued to decline and the work was more difficult to find. In 1551, the country was confronted with a slump in the cloth trade, England's

  1. DanielO’Connell – 1775 – 1847

    King George IV (formerly the Prince Regent) sulkily acquiesced, and the bill became law in April 1829. The influence of the Protestant supporters of emancipation in the House of Commons was essential to the passing of the Act, and they were helped by the disunity of the Tory party.

  2. How far do you agree that it was Cavour's diplomacy rather that Garibaldi's ideas ...

    National unification was achievable only through the cooperation of the two elements - The Monarchy and the Revolution... (Garibaldi) dictatorial by nature neither understood nor respected the prosaic working of a constitutional regime ' 21 Garibaldi himself recognised there was tension between himself and Cavour.

  1. To What extent did the Weimar Republic recover by 1929?

    having a Kaiser. This shows that the public liked the old system as well as they had elected him. The government situation was not stable as there were 25 government in 14 years. Stresemann who had helped Germany a lot and made some very successful political decisions died.

  2. Why was the Weimar Republic able to survive the difficulties between 1919-23?

    However, there is truth in the claim that certain clauses caused anger towards anything related to the Treaty. The main two clauses responsible for this sentiment were the 'War Guilt' clause, as many Germans did not feel solely responsible for the Great War, and the hugely restricted army which had

  1. It is not enough for governments to have power, they must also have authority

    However, this does somewhat justify citizens to defend themselves with weapons if the state is deemed oppressive and ruthless. So, it is fair to say that although the government does not need authority to impose its will, a misuse of power will simply lead to rebellion and perhaps even civil war.

  2. Minority Rights, Identity Politics and Gender in Bangladesh: Current Problems and Issues

    But although women have been neglected in the formal peace process, they have had a large role to play informally. One of the shining examples of this has been the Naga Mothers Association. In the face of warring factions and ethnic strife, the Naga Mothers Association has initiated dialogues with the 'undergrounds'(militant factions)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work