• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Were the policy intentions of the Thatcher governments assisted or hindered by the structure of the British state?

Extracts from this document...


Were the policy intentions of the Thatcher governments assisted or hindered by the structure of the British state? Prime Minister from 1979 to 1990, Mrs Thatcher had one of the most significant, and controversial, premierships of post-war Britain. She attempted to transform Britain at political, economic and social levels. The Thatcher government considered itself 'a radical government which sought to reverse British decline'1 and Thatcher claimed that 'the balance had be tilted too far in favour of the State at the expense of individual freedom'2. The title contains two key elements: 'policy intentions' and 'the structure of the British state'. The former may be taken as the plan or purpose of the Thatcher governements to achieve their aims. Many of their fundamental objectives were outlined in their 1979 Manifesto. The latter proves more difficult to define precisely. The definition of state, given in 'The Routledge Dictionary of Politics', is 'the whole fixed political system, the set-up of authoritative and legitimately powerful roles by which we are finally controlled, ordered, and organised'3. This is to include primarily Parliament and local government. However, trade unions have represented a large proportion of the British labour force and have been integral to the functioning of the British state, so they shall also be included as part of the structure. Firstly, this essay shall consider the reasoning behind their policies and place the rise of the New Right in context. Secondly, it is necessary to analyse what exactly were their policy intentions before assessing their success. ...read more.


Financial stability was extremely important because the government wished to avoid the recession and potential depression in the 1970s and they recognised that financial stability would give an impression of political competence. Moreover, it was a fundamental principle of monetarism. Much of the shift towards monetarist principles had already occurred under the Wilson-Callaghan government so the Thatcherite policies were not as radical as perhaps suggested. It could also imply that further monetarist policies would meet less resistance from the Opposition. Although not mentioned in the 1979 Manifesto, denationalisation became a crucial part of Thatcherite policy. However, no industry strategy was devised and the restructuring of British industry was left alone by the government. Privatisation involved little consultation with relevant parties before legislation was passed, but was also passed with few amendments. The Thatcher government wanted to increase firms' international competitiveness and transparency. Given the trade unions' power during the 1960s and 1970s, the 1979 Thatcher government was initially very cautious and modest in its approach towards trade union reform. They saw the trade unions as potential obstacles to policies of redundancy and restructuring in order to increase profitability. However, the trade unions proved to be less of a hindrance to policy intentions than initially thought. Their blanket immunity was removed in 1982 and other immunities were also reduced. According to the 1990 Employment Act trade unions could be held responsible for unauthorized strike action unless they categorically opposed it. Trade unions had little impact on policy and the few consultations they had with the government were effectively futile. ...read more.


Profound social change was important to the government in fulfilling their policy intentions. Although not directly part of the state, social attitudes of the electorate can influence discussion and debate within Parliament and other elements of the State. The government had already proved that it could control Parliament but in order to carry out its policies, it needed electoral support to be re-elected. In conclusion, the Thatcher government met relatively little resistance to its policy intentions throughout its time in office. The electoral system and the ineffectual Labour Party meant that legislation was hardly questioned before it was passed, assisting Thatcher Governments' policy intentions. Trade Unions did not hinder the Government as regularly as might have been expected and, following legislation, retreated from political debate which arguably assisted the Thatcher Governments. Local government did hinder policy intentions because they were increasingly incensed by central government policy and did not cooperate easily. Either as a result of existing conditions or due to Government manipulation, policy intentions were generally unhindered. However, this did not guarantee policy success, which was affected by wider socio-economic and global factors as well. 1 The Free Economy and The Strong State, The Politics of Thatcherism. A Gamble, Page 121 2 The Free Economy and The Strong State, The Politics of Thatcherism. A Gamble, Page 121 3 The Routledge Dictionary Of Politics, David Robertson, Page 457 4 The Free Economy and The Strong State, The Politics of Thatcherism. A Gamble, Page 121 5 Thatcherism, ed. Robert Skidelsky. Chapter One - Has the electorate become more Thatcherite, I Crewe. Jessica Mead 10/05/2007 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Why Did the Post-war Consensus Breakdown?

    First, the Conservative defeat resulted in a serious reconsideration of policy which eventually resulted in Margaret Thatcher's New Right social market strategy. And second, Labour came to power just as a series of domestic and world economic crises were about to break out.

  2. "The British Parliament is weak whereas the US Congress is powerful." Discuss.

    Prime Minister has prerogative powers, which allow him to act without consulting Parliament. The status of Parliament is in decline if the Prime Minister does not have to consult Parliament, especially as the Royal Prerogative provides the ability to declare wars without consulting Parliament first - in the US, the Senate must approve a president's declaration of war.

  1. How successful were the Labour governments of 1924 and of 1929-31?

    The final failure was to dismiss Mosley's radical alternative. It would have been unlikely for a government to simply accept such a radical proposal, but Labour failed by simply not even considering parts of it, but rejecting it. As AJP Taylor said about the programme - '...offered a blueprint for

  2. "In the two decades before the outbreak of the American Revolutionary War, a profound ...

    V. Old Colonial Government a. The British colonies were settled without any particular plan. They received little direction form the imperial government. b. The crown never developed administrative measures over the colonies. c. Colonial problems received little attention in Britain. While colonial governors might have provided the needed strength and stability for imperial administration, they

  1. What Are The Key Elements Of Thatcherism? To What Extent Was It A Reaction ...

    This was directly an attempt to break with the post war concensus and the strong Thatcher followers concentrated as much power as possible into their hands whilst ensuring that alternative, opposition sources of power were controlled or removed. An authoritive stance is central to Thatcherite ideology.

  2. Politics A: Analysing Theories of the State and Individual - Evaluation of Pluralism.

    But there was a fear in a pluralistic democracy of the tyranny of the majority a fear of how popular pressure may threaten individual freedom. The aim of pluralism is to set limits on the power of the rulers over the community.

  1. 'How far had the British Government abandoned the policy of laissez-faire by 1914?'

    It cost the British Government �8 million to provide for 668000 people, which helped to add to the budget crisis of 1909. it was not as successful as the other schemes introduced in other aspects of society as the budget was too low and the age limit too high in accordance to the lower life expectancy at that time.

  2. The Impact of Electoral Design on the Legislature.

    In the simplest with the Hare quota, used in Denmark and Costa Rica, the total number of valid votes in each constituency is divided by the total number of seats to be allocated. The Droop quota, used in South Africa and Greece, raises the divisor by the number of seats plus one, producing a slightly less proportional result.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work