• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What are the advantages and disadvantages of the devolution process in Scotland and Wales?

Extracts from this document...


What are the advantages and disadvantages of the devolution process in Scotland and Wales? Devolution as described by Bogdanor is the delegation of power to local or regional administration, so power is dispersed from a superior to an inferior political authority, or to be more precise it consists of a sub-ordinate elected body on a geographical basis of functions at present exercised by Parliament. It is possible to trace the origins of the move towards greater self- government in Scotland and Wales as far back as the nineteenth century. Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland were promised a devolved assembly by the labour Party in the 1997 elections. Referendums were held in 1997, soon after the general election. In the event just over 60% of Scots voted which was just enough to give the vote authority. However in Wales voter turnout was just over 50% and this had the effect of reducing the authority of the referendum. However both countries came out with a majority in favour of devolution and the Scotland and Wales Acts were passed in 1998. There have been many advantages to devolution. In Scotland the nature of politics has changed positively since the introduction of devolution. It has brought government closer to the people of Scotland in that Scots feel more engaged with the political process, whereas before decisions were made for them in Westminster hundreds of miles away. ...read more.


Local issues are represented better than could be done at Westminster and steps can be taken in order to solve them. Both Scotland and Wales have been given responsibilities over local affairs such as healthcare, education, housing and transport. This has produced two advantages; it helps to lighten the workload on Westminster allowing more time to be spent on English issues and foreign affairs. It has also meant that local parliament would be able to focus on specific areas in order to improve conditions. By 2003 Scotland had introduced forty pieces of legislation that would only apply to Scotland, such as no tuition fees and free elderly care. Wales have also introduced new policies like the introduction of the Baccalaureate system of education as well as the banning of school league tables and SAT tests for seven year olds. This shows that devolution has had a positive effect and has lead to effective self-government. Also local people are more likely to accept new legislation if it has come from a more local source that understands their position better. Devolution has shown an increase in democracy as the Scottish and Welsh people have been given more say in matters that could affect them. The Scottish opposed a 'Beef on the bone ban' in 1999 that could have caused problems for Scottish farmers and the Welsh opposed the growth of GM crops because they feared the risk of cross pollination with their crops. ...read more.


There have been arguments about devolution in relation to it being seen by Scottish Nationalist as a stepping stone to independence. Before the UK general election the Conservative Party said that devolution would create a 'slippery slope' to Scottish independence and provide the SNPs with a route to power. John Major claimed that the Parliament could end '1000 years of British history'. The equally pro-Union Labour Party met these criticisms by claiming that devolution would fatally undermine the SNP, and remedy the long-felt desire of Scots for a measure of self-government. In practice the Tory fears have proved unfounded. Even after the SNPs gained a majority in the Scottish parliament after 2007 there has been no further surge towards independence. Support for the Scottish Nationalist Party has decreased as Scotland can now handle their own affairs and are over represented at Westminster. In Wales this issue is not as pressing because it is obvious that Wales could not cope independently so devolution has just allowed them to have some responsibility in handling their own affairs and reduced the workload at Westminster. To conclude, there are advantages and disadvantages to the devolution process in Scotland and Wales but mostly devolution has been effective. It has lead to a more effective government because Welsh and Scottish people have far more of a say in issues that concern them and it has decreased the support for independence in both countries. Kate Manson ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Describe the process by which MPs are elected to Westminster. What are the ...

    4 star(s)

    Many will also argue that this political stability is due to the fact that there are only two strong parties within the Parliament, one in charge of the government and the other acting as the opposition.

  2. The advantages of the Uk having a constitutional monarchy are greater than the disadvantages. ...

    Thirdly, some critics claimed that the royal family is expensive. According to the report of civil list, the Queen's official expensive is '�7.9m a year until 2011'.iii What's worse, maybe we can still clearly remember that in 1993, Windsor Castle caught a fire and it cost approximately 37 million pounds to rebuild it.

  1. The Uk policy making process.

    of Government policy, there is no real opportunity for the Government to be defeated. This mechanism of Adjournment Motions may also be used to allow the House of Commons as a whole to express its view on subjects for which the Government has no particular policy or which are very

  2. Devolution is not a "constitutional settlement" but a dynamic (and potentially destabilising) process. ...

    a result, Scottish and Welsh spending is estimated to be 23% and 16% per head higher respectively that the English average."9 This allocation of generous funding further exasperated anti devolution campaigners, particularly when the building of the new Scottish Parliament turned into a farce.

  1. Scottish devolution.

    The majority voted for Home Rule, but due to a clause in the bill about a minimum percentage of turnout at the voting, an assembly was not created. Then in 1997 a referendum was held and Scotland voted for a devolved Scottish Parliament with limited tax varying powers.

  2. In this essay I will explain the distinctive features of the Scottish political system, ...

    Unlike the English legal system, the Scottish system has depended more on the principles of continental jurisprudence derived from Roman law than on indigenous common law. Whenever a piece of legislation has been intended to apply to Scotland as well as to England and Wales this has had to be

  1. Spain and Devolution

    One expression of this is resentment of the level of Catalan financial transfers to the central exchequer. This resentment is all the greater when it compares its fiscal powers with those of the Basque country. The challenge which such a high level of 'regionalisation' has posed to the Spanish state,

  2. Critically evaluate the impact of the National Lottery since its inception on the arts ...

    or more Arts Council regions with up to �200,000; and Grants for Stabilisation and Recovery, aimed at "large-scale organisations that are central to arts provision in England and have a financial turnover of �250,000 or more and audiences in excess of 25,000 per year" (Guide to Arts Funding in England, 2003, http://www.culture.gov.uk/global/publications/archive_2003/arts_funding_guide.htm).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work