• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What has been the impact of the use of proportional systems in the UK?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

What has been the impact of the use of proportional systems in the UK? The current First Past the Post system used for general elections does not link the number of seats won to the share of the national vote. As shown in the 2005 general election when Labour gained only 35 per cent of the vote, but won 355 seats. A simulation of the last election under a system of proportional representation indicates that Labour would have at least 120 fewer MPs. There are three main proportional representation systems that have been developed in parts of the UK that try to ensure that party's seats are earned more proportionally. The use of the Single Transferable Vote, List and Additional Member systems has changed UK politics, effecting representation, governance, policy and parties alike. The first form of proportional representation systems is the Single Transferable Vote (STV). This is in use in the Republic of Ireland and for European Parliament elections in Northern Ireland. It has also been used since June 1998 for elections to the Northern Ireland Assembly. ...read more.

Middle

However AMS corrected this with the allocation of top-up members. Hence Labour's final share of the seats worked out at just over 43%. AMS has also helped small parties to gain representation. Indeed, in the Scottish Parliament, the Green Party and the Scottish Socialist Party each won one top-up seat in the 1999 elections. AMS is more likely to produce coalition governments, which can encourage a more co-operative style of politics, producing stable and long lasting governments. In the elections of the Scottish Parliament and the National Assembly for Wales, Labour won the most seats in each body, but failed to secure an overall majority in either. Coalitions now exist in both countries formed by Labour with the Liberal Democrats. One advantage of using this system is that it allows electors to choose a constituency representative from one party and yet support another party to form government. After the signing of the Good Friday Agreement, and its endorsement by the people of Northern Ireland on 22 May 1998, power was devolved to the Northern Ireland Executive, on 2 December 1999. ...read more.

Conclusion

It is a system close to AV, and is likely to produce a very similar result. As such it has had a very similar impact on the voting systems in the UK. Its essential difference from AV is that it allows the voter to exercise only a second choice, and not a third, a fourth or even a fifth one, and thus avoids weak choices from occasionally illegitimately influencing the result. In conclusion it would seem that the general impact of proportional representation in the UK would be a positive one as it has created stronger constituency links and creates governments based on what the people really want. The current UK situation would not have happened if all parts of it had continued to use the First Past The Post system. Proportional representation has meant that people's opinions are now being heard and parties are being assigned seats in accordance to the number of votes that they have gained. The argument is now one of whether the rest of the UK (i.e England) should now also reform its electoral system thus making it more representative and fair. ?? ?? ?? ?? Caroline Hood 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    What have been the effects of the use of proportional electoral systems in the ...

    3 star(s)

    Furthermore, only a party, or coalition of parties that wins more than 50% of the public vote can form a government, and thus it is representative of the majority of the populations preferences. This is relevant to the Good Friday Agreement of 1998 which stipulates that a coalition must be

  2. Arguments for and Against the use of Referendums in the UK

    An example of the unfairness of referendums took place in 1997 when the referendum for the devolution of Wales happened, which allowed Wales to have an assembly. The Neill Committee's report said the campaign could have gone the other way if it had been fairer.

  1. Critically evaluate the impact of the National Lottery since its inception on the arts ...

    Other programmes run by the Arts Council are Grants to Organisations, awarding grants mostly under �30,000 to organisational development and research; Grants to Individuals, including residencies, bursaries and arts projects led by individuals with awards from �200 - �30,000; Grants for National Touring, for any art form that tours two

  2. The Uk policy making process.

    Parnell, who used it as a way of forcing the British Government to give more consideration to policy on Ireland. More recently, a Labour MP, John Golding, spoke for almost 12 hours on the British Telecommunications Bill in 1983 - after he left the Commons, Mr Golding was appointed General Secretary of a communications workers' trade union!

  1. What is Politics UK politics revision notes

    * Tories/Whigs * Tories/Liberal * Tories/Labour * Majority of seats have belonged to 2 parties * The British system shows confrontation Not a 2 Party System- * 3 or more parties have formed Government-Wartime Coalitions. * Confrontational politics depends upon the region * Windsor - Tories/Liberals * Slough - Tories/Labour

  2. Legislators have three essential functions: representation, law-making and control of the executive. How does ...

    Combining all of the above one could be led to the thought that the German legislation body, the Bundestag, is indeed effective. Although there is no system of checks and balances between government and the Bundestag has established a tactic to control the Chancellor and his\her cabinet.

  1. What has been the impact of the use of proportional systems in the UK?

    These results in Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales have reduced the probability of a single party gaining complete control of the legislative organizations which use these proportionally representative systems, therefore avoiding the single party dominance or even electoral dictatorship linked with first past the post system.

  2. Political parties and representation

    the sovereign... cannot be represented by anyone but itself." Direct democracy was assumed to exist in classical Athens, where all citizens (though that excluded women, aliens and slaves) could vote in general assembly. Direct democracy survives in some Swiss communes, and in the principle of referendums (see below): one sometimes encounters the suggestion also of 'electronic direct democracy' in future.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work