• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What options do the Government have in their attempts to reform the House of Lords?

Extracts from this document...


08/05/07 Tim Gloster What options do the Government have in their attempts to reform the House of Lords? The government have seven options to choose from when they decide on how the House of Lords should be filled up, and by whom. The first option is to have a fully appointed house, this however is seen as undemocratic and having little advance on the current house. This option does have its positive side as it could include independents, experts, like doctors, lawyers, and academics etc. who all have experience and knowledge in their own particular field and it represents all sections of society. If this were the option chosen a committee would need to be set up to decides who is appointed, this would have to be non-partisan and independent of the government, a royal institute for example. ...read more.


The third option is an 80% appointed, 20% elected House of Lords. This was the proposed option in the government's white paper. Its advantages are that it mixes established figures with a democratic voice. However it is very confusing and elected members may struggle for power and attention over the majority of the appointed peers. Nevertheless this option does not seem likely as it has been abandoned by the government. The fourth option is to have an 80% elected, 20% appointed House. This option is backed by reformers as a compromise and most of the Conservative Party. Its advantages are that it allows effective elections but retains a handful of appointed experts. On the other hand this is a compromised option and is little advance on a fully elected house. ...read more.


It is backed by many MP's who want reform but fear an aggressive fully elected house, as mentioned in the second option. The chances of this option being implemented are excellent, it is seen as a good compromise and the government would accept it. The sixth option is a 50% appointed, 50% elected House. This option, even though it lacks strong support, is quite likely as all sides could settle for this. Its advantages are that it offers even numbers and neatness therefore making it easier to understand and bringing a balance of legitimacy and expertise. However this could lead to deadlock and the ultimate compromise. There is an eighth option but it is extremely unlikely. And that is to completely abolish the House of Lords. But this will probably never happen as it would give the Commons too much power and would not be very popular, even though some MP's are calling for it. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Serfdom – Emancipation, etc

    Much more was in the hands of private creditors. The sale of private estates was also rapid; between 1877-1905 the quantity of land owned by the nobility decreased by 37%. An increasing proportion of what remained was leased out to that of the serfs, by comparison with foreign yields the manor house lands were pitifully inadequate.

  2. The constitutional change in the House of Lords

    Seventy-five of these were to represent the political parties and Crossbenchers, fifteen peers were to remain as office holders and further two peers were to remain in a ceremonial capacity. Beside, ten hereditary peers were given life peerages in November 1999 and seven hereditary peers were given life peerages in March 2000.

  1. Civil Service Reform.

    They include reducing the responsibilities of government by the privatisation of former nationalised industries, reducing the role of local government as a provider of services - like education and house-building and enlarging the 'quango' state i.e. the performance of government functions by unelected government-appointed bodies.

  2. Discuss The Various Roles of an MP in the House of Commons.

    This can be through Private Bills, Public Bills and Private Members Bills. Private members bills are made on the behalf of a pressure group or an organisation. There can only be up to 20 put forward in a year and only about 5 get through.

  1. What are the arguments for and against electing all the members of the second ...

    The majority of hereditary peers are widely believed to be of Conservative loyalty politically due to the previous supremacy of the party in British history resulting in such ideals being shared by the people in power in the past when assigning peers.

  2. Electoral Reform

    This would cause coalition governments which are generally not as strong and decisive as majority governments which Britain has generally had. A decisive government is the most important attribute to a government as it can make decisions for the nation without having complications of a coalition government or a weak majority.

  1. Have Prior Reforms Of The Lords Been Effective And Can Anything Further Be Done ...

    The Conservative party does not believe that Parliament is need of reform, as their general belief is that institutions which have stood the test of time should be preserved e.g. Parliament and the Monarchy (D Roberts, British Politics In Focus, 2nd Edition, 1999).

  2. The need for reform

    To do this, political and social reforms were necessary. Why social reforms happened Historians have identified various factors and motives for the reforms being passed. National efficiency Fears that Britain was in decline as a world power led to the idea that Britain had to improve its national efficiency by taking steps to improve the quality of the workforce.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work