• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Which electoral system, the USA or the UK more effectively allows the views of the people to be promoted?

Extracts from this document...


Which electoral system, the USA or the UK more effectively allows the views of the people to be promoted In American and in Britain the electoral systems have both seen change, even though Britains system has developed over a much longer period than that of its American counterpart. Both systems have seen the working class and women strive to get the vote and Americas system has seen, famously the fight of Negro's to achieve the right to vote. In the present day it is fair to say that both countries offer a system which is fair to all people regardless of race, social background or sex. In America the contest for President is a long and very complex process. In Britain this is not the case with the Prime Minister, the system being much "quicker" and "simpler". Presidential primaries are the first form of public involvement in America, with each party's candidate for president being chosen. This process alone takes months, with state primaries followed by the party conference and finally the presidential election. ...read more.


This has had the effect that the people running both the countries haven't been given a mandate to do so by less than half the eligible population. In America although there are more elections which allow peoples views to be promoted because of the volume of these elections the population has become bored and has started to be turned away. In Britain there are far fewer chances for the electorate to influence the running of their country and therefore more people, at present are taking the opportunity to express their views. The two systems used in both countries to elect their leaders have been in place for relatively long periods of time, however for an equally long period many critics have questioned whether or not they are representative of how the electorate votes. The recent elections of George W. Bush and Tony Blair's Labour Party have highlighted this problem. In the last American presidential election Al Gore received more votes than the Bush but because of the Electoral College system Bush came out the President. ...read more.


America and Britain's systems both offer the people the chance to express their views. Hypothetically America's system is much more geared for the people, in terms of allowing them to choose not only individual senators and house representatives, but also presidential candidates, and eventually the president. The increasing amounts of political apathy, and the Electoral College mean that the system is not truly representative and a democratic deficit occurs. In Britain the population is given fewer opportunities to express itself, and when it does, because of the system its opinions are not fully represented in the House of Commons. In conclusion Americas system more effectively allows its peoples views to be promoted if all of the eligible population takes the opportunity, in the UK the system will always produce a democratic deficit. Alan Bottomley LUSC - Chiltern branch ?? ?? ?? ?? Alan Bottomley - LUFC - Alan Smith - England's No.9. Paul Robinson - England's No.1. Danny Mills - England's No.2. Jonathon Woodgate - England's No.5. Lee Bowyer - England's No.11. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. The Impact of Electoral Design on the Legislature.

    [DIAGRAM 1 ABOUT HERE] Majoritarian electoral systems In a recent worldwide survey 83 out of 150 countries were found to use majoritarian systems (Inter-Parliamentary Union 1993). This is the oldest electoral system, dating back at least to the 12th Century, and also the simplest.

  2. The Uk policy making process.

    The Public Accounts Committee is chaired by a very senior Opposition Member, and is respected partly because it undertakes its inquiries in a non-partisan manner. Its reports are invariably taken very seriously by the Treasury. Other non-departmental Select Committees deal with such matters as European Legislation, parliamentary procedures, Statutory Instruments

  1. Is Party Identification still the main determinant in Electoral Choice?

    Though both types vote through self-interest it could be said that the character of the voter is the deciding factor in relation to the two systems. The rational approach requires thought and some general research, since facts and policies are the basis of decision, identification on the other hand lacks any mature procedure or thought and shows a childish haste.

  2. The American Two Party System

    Although the Constitutional Convention is often regarded as the birth place of the American party system, there had been political parties in the colonies for as long as there had been governing bodies (Newman 108). During the colonial times, it was not uncommon for groups to form in legislative assemblies

  1. To what extent has Germany's party system evolved from a multi-party system to a ...

    The German constitution was drafted in 1948-49 and was called a Basic Law rather than a constitution in order to avoid giving it a sense of permanence as the German people did not want Germany to be permanently divided. Germany's national parliament is elected by proportional representation on the basis of universal suffrage.

  2. An Introspective Study: Elitist Views of Political Socialisation in Education.

    Nicholas- 19, comes from a relatively upper class Christian family. His British father is one of the region heads of an MNC while his Chinese mother is an English teacher in an elite school. Also an ex-RI boy, he was one of the best in history among the Arts classes and a top-scorer in General Paper.

  1. Albert Arnold Gore.

    Albert was physically strong, as Bill Clinton said, which was important considering the energy needed to wage a forceful campaign. Gore was mentally strong as well. When his sister Nancy lost her battle with lung cancer and Albert Gore III was struck by a car and seriously injured, he entered a slight stage of depression.

  2. In Britain, Immigration is the process of people living in other countries coming to ...

    In regards to education, training and employment in the country, due to a regulation passed in January 2005, the Visa holder must be on the Register of Education and Training Providers to apply for college, University and School level educations within the country.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work