• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why were there two revolutions in 1917?

Extracts from this document...


Carla Searle Why were there two revolutions in 1917? The revolution during February 1917 was instigated the Tsar's loss of military support and the failure of the First World War. Also, the growing protests on the streets of Petrograd, fuelled by the demands of Russian women who joined the strikes on International Women's Day (February 23rd) played a part in the downfall of the Tsar. The February revolution lasted from the 18th of February to the 14th of March and it was during this period that Russia saw the greatest political changes for generations. It is however, also important to ascertain the reasons why, having put an end to an unpopular autocratic system, there was another revolution several months later. The key events of the February revolution were the large-scale strikes initiated by employees at Putilov steel works from the 18th of February onwards. As well as this, by the 26th of February, all but a minimal number of garrison troops had deserted the army. Also, Nicholas was advised by Rodzyanko that only a major concession by the government could offer any hope of preserving an Imperial power, this led to the abdication of Nicholas as tsar and, therefore, the end of an autocratic rule in Russia. It was on the 3rd of March that the Provisional Government, a group of Duma members who had continued to debate political matters after the dissolution of the Duma on the 26th of February. ...read more.


The Soviet approved of government issues such as the continuation of the war in an attempt to prevent a right-wing backlash. The Provisional Government also had to deal with the problem of breakdown of law and order. This mainly occurred in rural areas by peasants who, to demonstrate their resentment at the lack of reform, attempted and succeeded in seizing estates from wealthy landowners. Also, after the February revolution, the economic crisis in towns greatly worsened. Because of the Soviet, workers realised they ad the right to a better political representation and began making somewhat unrealistic demands of the Provisional Government. As a result of this, fierce clashes between factory committees and employers ensued. The army also saw a breakdown in law and order; the influence of soldier's committees undermined the leadership system within the armed forces, causing the collapse of authority. By May 1917 divisions had already begun to occur within the Provisional Government. The main reason for the separation was that those on the right wanted social reform while those on the left wanted to see a restoration of law and order. Because of this, the government faced an uphill struggle in maintaining its authority. The Bolsheviks also seriously threatened the Provisional Government. The general amnesty after the February revolution allowed Bolshevik leaders such as Lenin and Trotsky to return from exile to Russia. ...read more.


By nightfall, most of Kerensky's ministers had fled the Palace, leading to the Bolshevik victory. The revolution was, ultimately, a non-violent takeover; few people died, there was little opposition and Trotsky had planned strategic points effectively. When the Congress of Soviets met after the revolution, Lenin, therefore, proclaimed that the Provisional Government had been overthrown. The Bolsheviks held a 60% majority in the congress and Lenin held control of the Council of People's Commissars. The fact that all Commissars were Bolsheviks led to Menshevik and SR deputies leaving the congress in revulsion. To conclude, the Provisional Government appeared to be undermined by problems from the start of their period of influence on the 3rd of March 1917. This was because the government lack real legitimacy, it failed to hold Constituent Assembly elections or initiate land reforms. The Provisional Government also was unwilling to pull out of the First World War and competed for power with the Soviet. The government also had problems keeping control of the army, peasants and workers. The Bolsheviks were a major threat to the Provisional Government and were able to use the Kornilov Affair to their advantage. However, it can be argued that the October revolution was to be expected and was not the fault of the Provisional Government, as many of the problems faced by the Provisional government were simply continued from the Tsar's reign and would have needed to be overcome by any new governmental group. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Why Did Revolutions Break Out so Widely Across Europe in 1848 and Why Did ...

    Britain, scared of Irish nationalism did not support the Italian movement despite liberal sympathies, and her opposition to Prussian annexation of Schleswig-Holstein discredited that state in the eyes of the liberal-nationalists at Frankfurt.

  2. Was the Provisional Government doomed to failure?

    The last key issue the Provisional Government faced was the deteriorating economic situation. Shortages of fuel and raw materials led to factories cutting output or closing and laying off workers; 568 factories in Petrograd closed between February and July with the loss of 100,000 jobs.

  1. Why did another revolution take place in Russia after the 1917 February Revolution?

    to place their hope in before they could turn against the provisional government. The Bolsheviks were a group that could be that alternative. The Bolsheviks were headed by Lenin and Trotsky and believed in launching a socialist revolution in Russia Every step towards revolution planned out and was clearly written in :Lenin's work That is to be done?

  2. It was the weakness of the provisional government that brought the October revolution about ...

    In the towns, where daily bread rations for workers had dropped from 675g to 110g in just seven months, the situation was reaching fever pitch. N. Sukanov, living in Petrograd at the time, recalls "destruction of homes and shops... unauthorised arrests, seizures and beatings up were recorded every day."

  1. Was the collapse of the provisional government inevitable

    failed but while it may appear that Kerensky came out of this well, the real winners were the communists. The Red Guards were credited with saving the city and the workers who formed the Red Guards were sympathetic to the communists.

  2. Was the Provisional Government fatally weakened from the first? Notes

    by which it could obtain power in the name of the proletariat. The Bolshevik takeover of the soviets would be the prelude to Bolshevik takeover of the state. Main Points in Lenin's April theses: o Ferbruary had not been a genuine class revolution but a palace coup, which had simply given authority to the bourgeoisie.

  1. How did the failure of the Provisional Government allow for the rise of the ...

    Also, the members of the government were only versed in the Duma (a former government with little power) and not in the workings of a real democratic government11. The failure of the government was also caused by indecisiveness between the members in how to implement democracy.

  2. Timeline of Events Leading Up to the Russian Revolutions of 1917.

    Problems he inherits include: * General unrest within the multi-ethnic population. * An antiquated class system. * A badly led military in which the soldiers were actually referred to as dogs. * Much corruption within the government. * The current immense famine.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work