• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Would a Proportional Representation system produce a more representative and effective Government?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Would a Proportional Representation system produce a more representative and effective Government? Three major problems occur whilst answering this question. Firstly, how representative is the current (Past-The-First-Post) system. Secondly what determines a representative and an effective government and thirdly what devices does a PR system provide that will contribute to a more representative and effective government. Using FPTP in a constituency, one MP is elected and therefore, the people of that constituency will know who to ask or pursue if they have a query etc. In a multi-member constituency, in which a number of parties are represented, this would not be as easy. An effective government can be one that is considered to have a broad basis of support from the electorate whilst providing a stable government. It is vital for an effective government to be able to implement policies successfully unlike the 1997 Poll tax, which had to be withdrawn as it was heavily challenged by critics and public. ...read more.

Middle

In the 2001 election, Labour got 43% of the total popular vote whereas all the other parties got 57% - yet Labour maintained its very powerful position in Parliament with 413 MP's out of 659. It can be claimed that such a percentage of votes should not have given Labour such large Parliamentary majorities - but the workings of the FPTP system allows for just such an occurrence. Lord Hailsham once referred to this system as an "elective dictatorship" in that a powerful government can be created with overwhelming Parliamentary power which can usually push through its required legislation - but with only a minority of the country supporting it. At the 1997 national election, the Liberal Democrats gained 16.8% of the votes but only got 46 seats. Labour won 43.2% of the votes and gained 419 seats. Not only can the government be elected on less than half of the electorates votes but at a proportionate level, the Liberal Democrats should have got around 106 seats in Westminster if their representation was based on similar support for the Labour Party. ...read more.

Conclusion

won a constituency vote in the 1997 election and he lost his attempt to win another independent seat in 2001 using FPTP. An argument put forward against FPTP is that it might put people off of voting in an election for a minority party as they know that their vote will be wasted. The two-party system (which can sometimes been seen both positive and negative) is usually eliminated using PR and the end result is more 'pluralist'. The possibility of single-party 'elective dictatorship' is greatly diminished although does not completely rule out the possibility as can be seen from the elections in Sweden using PR system. The two main PR systems that I will analyse are AMS and STV. The STV system is in use in Australia (for the Senate), the Republic of Ireland and in Northern Ireland (for European elections and also for elections to the new Northern Ireland Assembly) This system assumes that the country is divided into multi-member constituency and parties may put up as many candidates as there are seats available in that constituency. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Comparing the German and Russian systems of government

    In terms of their executive Germany and Russia are quite different. In Russia the role of the president is one of the most powerful positions in the system of government. Unlike in Germany where the president is much less powerful in terms of decision making and it is in fact

  2. Key Elements of Representative Government.

    Power is divided between the commonwealth and the states. In the constitution the commonwealth's power is specified and all the powers not mentioned stay with the states. If a dispute arises concerning these power sharing relations, the High Court of Australia is called to interpret the wording of the constitution to resolve it.

  1. Is Britain a two-party or a multi party system, or something else?

    both a two-party system, and a multi-party system, the "something else" referred to in the title I will concentrate on is one of a 'dominant party system'. Andrew Heywood in Britain's dominant-party system suggests that in a pluralist system, it is possible to have one party dominating the elections.

  2. The Impact of Electoral Design on the Legislature.

    as published or to vote for an individual candidate, wherever that candidate appears on the party's list. The possible effect of this is to alter the order in which candidates have been placed on the list, and therefore the list of successful candidates, while still registering support for the voter's preferred party.

  1. Minority parties in Britain call for electoral reform whereas the two major parties tend ...

    Jones & Kavanagh (1990) suggest that another benefit connected with minority parties is that it reduces the "bargaining or 'blackmail' power of a small party" which could be critical in a hanging Parliament. What is seen to be another important advantage of the FPTP system is that due to it

  2. What has been the impact of the use of proportional systems in the UK?

    represented as their views were taken more seriously and if they wanted to change something just for Ireland that the rest of the UK did not agree with then it would be easier for them to do so. The Party List System (PLS)

  1. Legislators have three essential functions: representation, law-making and control of the executive. How does ...

    Bundestag has cast a vote of no confidence * Effectiveness * Although there is no system of check and balances between government and the Bundestag, and it could be argued that majority caucuses have more control over "their" government. * The question of whether the Bundestag is concerned with a

  2. Examine the significance of William Pitt, the younger's Government in reforming the British Parliamentary ...

    Pitt agreed with his peace campaign with the American colonies. Their main objective was to convince Lord North's, the then Prime Minister, to end the war in America. When Lord North's Government collapsed in 1782, Charles Fox became Foreign Secretary under the new Government.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work