• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

“God gives life only he can take it away.” Do you agree or disagree? Give reasons for your answer showing that you have considered more than one point of view in your answer.

Extracts from this document...


"God gives life only he can take it away." Do you agree or disagree? Give reasons for your answer showing that you have considered more than one point of view in your answer. This is a very difficult question to answer, as it is a very complex subject. The law in Britain disallows for euthanasia however it is legal for abortion to take place. Killing has always been seen as immoral. (Genesis 27) "Thou shalt not kill." In the story of creation God built up the world in seven days. He made plants and animals to serve us. Its whole point is to show to us that we get life from God and that we must respect and be thankful for the gift we have been given. Despite this there are many occasions were people feel that euthanasia and abortion are necessary. Euthanasia is a gentle or easy death and is used to show compassion to those who are in incredible pain. E.g. Diane Pretty is a sufferer or motor neurone disease. She is currently fighting for the right for her husband to kill her without him getting imprisoned after wards. Since she caught the disease the condition of her life has deteriorated immensely. She is now in a wheelchair, her limbs do not work and she has to be fed through a tube. She is in a lot of pain however her intellectual abilities and he capacity to make decisions is unimpaired. This woman is an adult that should be allowed to make decisions for herself. It must be causing her much physical and mental distress the pain she is going through, waiting for the time when her lungs will collapse and she will suffocate to death. Euthanasia is an easier way out for her. She will be able to die with dignity and her family will no longer have to watch her suffer any longer. ...read more.


But if she was to use euthanasia legally it would path the way for others to do so as well, and could even lead on to involuntary euthanasia. It has occurred in the past that patients that have been written off by doctors have recovered fully. People when they are in a lot of pain make decision that they don't really mean because they are not thinking straight. Many patients who would have decided to opt for euthanasia are relieved now that it wasn't made legal because they are now living a better quality of life than they ever were. Some feel that the pain they went through made them stronger and a better person, as it was a time for them to reflect on the way that were living their life. For abortion- having a baby can be stressful, especially if it is an unwanted one. If there is a chance that having the baby would physically harm the mother then some believe that it is justifiable to terminate the baby's life. However God does everything for a reason. It could be time for the mother to die and the baby to go and live a fruitful life. It can also be justified to have an abortion if the baby is going to be born seriously disabled, however Stephen Hawkin is an example of a man who has still managed to achieve great success despite his serious disability. If a woman was rapped and left pregnant it would be a very hard decision to keep the child. It wasn't her fault for having an unwanted child, and it would be understandable for her to have an abortion. If the baby was spared its life then it could be left with living a life of resentment, but we also have to remember that it is not the baby's fault as well. I have a very open minded opinion when it comes to euthanasia however I do not endorse it. ...read more.


If someone who was close to me was ill, and dying was the only way of alleviating their pain and it was their definite choice then I would probably fight to help his or her cause. However I do believe that involuntary euthanasia is wrong and that it is the same as committing a murder no matter how much the person who has done it believes it to be an act of mercy. My opinion on abortion is much stronger. I believe abortion on demand is very wrong. Contraceptives are not hard to get and if those involved are thought responsible enough to have sex then they are also responsible enough to look after the child. Unfortunately this is not always the case. However there is another option of adoption. Many young parents who cannot have children would love an opportunity to raise a child and call it their own. This I believe is a much better decision. I do have more sympathy for girls who have been rapped and left pregnant but I believe that it would be better for the baby to be given up for adoption, as it was not the baby's fault to begin with. I have reservations about babies who are endangering the life of the mother. I think a course of action should be taken up with doctors to decide what is best. If there was no chance of the baby living without the mother then abortion is ok as it is better to save one live than lose two. So to summarise my opinion I think that Euthanasia is more acceptable than abortion. As euthanasia is the taking of your own life, if the person is really so determined to die then I say let them and end their suffering. Abortion however is the taking of someone else's life and is not acceptable but I do have reservations about it. QUESTION TWO-EUTHANASIA AND ABORTION 1 ERIN DOHERTY 12J ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Abortion and other medical issues section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Abortion and other medical issues essays

  1. " God gives life and only God can take it away". Do you agree ...

    This way no one is hurt and the baby still get a chance at life and to make a contribution to the human race. However this may not always be the answer because many of the children who are put up for adoption may have to live, with foster parents or in orphanages.

  2. "Abortion is never justified". Do you agree? Give reasons to support your answer & ...

    Christians who believe this can see abortion as a procedure to terminate a "mass of cells" not a human life so it is not going against God and the 6th commandment. Another reason is the belief in the Christian love, agape.

  1. Abortion is never justified. Do you agree?

    Because of their faith they may wish to support the family directly, because they may wish to support the family directly, because it maybe that they just wouldn't be able to if they gave birth. So a Christian could offer to baby-sit, become a foster carer for a long-term basis, instead of the women having an abortion.

  2. What Christians believe about life is up to them. They should not try ...

    to listen to other beliefs to decide this way we are not giving in to a blind faith of something we know little about but instead have looked at the different sides and views of the topic at hand. This is to form our own beliefs.

  1. "Abortion is never justified." Do you agree? Give reasons to support your answer and ...

    are to the notion that the value of our human life lies in physical perfection." The ProLife Alliance supports her, saying, "The eugenic practice of aborting babies with a disability is a particularly horrifying act of discrimination." However, many Christians who are ProChoice may disagree, saying that abortion may be

  2. "God gives life and only God can take it away" Discuss. ...

    Some would argue with that, claiming that we live strictly by other ethics from so long ago, such as 'do not kill' or 'do not steal', why should we ignore the abortion ethic? Medical authorities determine a person to be 'alive' if there is either a detectable heartbeat or brain-wave activity.

  1. AO3 "Abortion should not be allowed by law in a truly Christian society" do ...

    The choice of abortion is only acceptable for certain reasons, such as if the baby is going to be deformed. The woman has the right to decide what way to bring up the child, but not if it should live, that is God's decision.

  2. Decisions on life and living.

    would grow up like it's father the mother may suffer from psychological issues due to the attack. In which case the baby would be a permanent reminder and could lead to it's mother never fully recovering. But whilst many Christians believe life begins at conception and 'thou shalt not kill'

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work