• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

“The methods one chooses depend upon the research questions asked and the ultimate purpose of the knowledge produced” (Mattingly and Falconer-al-Hindi, 1995). Examine this statement with reference to at least two specific geographical projects w

Extracts from this document...


"The methods one chooses depend upon the research questions asked and the ultimate purpose of the knowledge produced" (Mattingly and Falconer-al-Hindi, 1995). Examine this statement with reference to at least two specific geographical projects with which you are familiar. When choosing a method to answer a research question an academic will have in mind a desired outcome from their research, therefore an appropriate method will be used to this end. An academic will do this for the ultimate purpose of validating their theories or epistemological viewpoint. An economic geographer is likely to choose a different method of research (collection of statistical data) than a social geographer (participant observation and surveys) as the purpose of the knowledge produced will be different in each case. As Geography is a multidisciplinary subject the sheer amount of data and previous studies that are available to a geographer are boundless. Robinson (1998: 12) writes, "Geographical data may take many forms, being obtained from a number of different sources and generated in a variety of ways". Geography is open to interpretation; there is no right or wrong answer and as there is so much data the purpose of the generated knowledge from the research can be suited to a desired outcome. Welsh et al. ...read more.


The interviews were tape recorded, transcribed then analysed to pick out specific themes. Such as all respondents agreed that it was the teenagers own choice as to whether they have an abortion or not. The purpose of the knowledge is of an informative nature interesting to not only academics but also policy makers. Abortion is an extremely topical issue and a comparison between select western countries with varying attitudes towards the acceptance of abortion gives the countries involved an insight how their citizens view abortion. Interviewees in Sweden are described as using mild words "the Swedish way", whilst interviewees in the United States describe a polarised view of the subject (ibid: 76). The study then describes on an individual country basis its recommendations on strategies for change based on the interviewee's responses. Llanos (2001) 'Understanding Power in Argentina study of the policy of privatisation in the 1990's', uses a completely different method to answer the articles research question. Here he is trying to show us the power relationships between the President, Congress and the Lower House in Argentina through the case study of privatisation. This is done via the use of secondary data in the form of quotes and philosophies from other writers, to give us a view of how Argentina's political system has developed and how the issue of privatisation came about and then carried out. ...read more.


The first paper looked at humanistic viewpoints to do with the issue of abortion in adolescence and the geographies of this phenomenon, which is deeply embedded in social geography. The methods used were qualitative using a structured interviewee led questionnaire, with some statistical analysis of responses and an in depth comparison between attitudes in the four different countries. The second paper is an analysis of what has been written by an array of different authors, no primary data was collected in the method of this paper it was simply an analytic view of different philosophical viewpoints to prove that democracy exists in Latin America. To try to apply the same methods as in the teenage abortion study to the Argentinean study would be unworkable. Firstly the study on Argentina is carried out in only one country, and secondly the Argentinean study is carried out on historical data from academics and not humanistic opinions from related professionals, to try and apply the methods of the Argentinean study to the teenage abortion study would be equally fruitless. The methods chosen in each of these papers are inextricably linked to the ultimate purpose of the knowledge produced, neither of the studies methods are transferable to the others study because the research questions asked are fundamentally different. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Abortion and other medical issues section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Abortion and other medical issues essays

  1. Arguments for and against abortion in America.

    The foetal dependence cannot be used as an issue in the abortion debate because the baby is still dependent on the mother and the father after the baby is born. Therefore if it is said that it is ok to kill a baby because it is dependent then the question

  2. "Scientific advances continue to arise ethical questions within the field of medicine, which can ...

    A mother may feel that she cannot cope being a single mother and therefore can lead to a termination. A person may feel that her partner is not willing to have a child at this stage so it may come as a bad idea bringing the issue up may lead

  1. An evaluation of Theatre Alibi's production of The Freeze.

    ironically makes him feel safe, this is a turning point for Sarah as this is when she starts to 'thaw'. At the end of the play we find out that she calls her baby Rosa, this reinforces the fact that this is a turning point for Sarah.

  2. A Comparison of the poems ‘You’re’ and ‘Morning Song’ by Sylvia Plath

    its owner by a chain, similarly as to how an unborn child is attached to its mother by an umbilical cord and the ticking of the watch could be a reference to the child's heartbeat. The use of the word "Love" could also suggest the initial intimacy the mother felt towards her child.

  1. Both 'Veronica' and 'Country Lovers' look at failed relationships, family and community. How do ...

    Veronica is shocked by this because she believes that women should stay at home and look after the house.

  2. Childbearing Among Teenagers

    Teenage mothers run a large threat in contracting pregnancy-induced hypertension, anemia, STDs, cephalopelvic disproportion, renal disease, eclampsia and depressive disorders. These health problems are known to haunt mothers who had their first child when they were a teenager, not only initially, but in their future.

  1. Write a character study of each of themain female characters in the stories you ...

    "Yes, I want you to go."(Armand) I feel sorry for Desiree because she was abandoned by her real father, but was then taken into the house of Valmonde by Madame Valmonde, but she then marries into a rich family, "What did it matter about a name when he could give her one of the oldest and proudest in Louisiana?"

  2. "Scientific advances continue to raise ethical questions within the filed of medicine, which can ...

    Nevertheless, others would claim that animal testing has helped to develop vaccines against polio, measles, meningitis etc...They believe that animals and humans are similar and there are no differences between the two that cannot be factored into tests. Another topic I will be evaluating will be the field of 'Cryogenics'.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work