• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A God who intervenes miraculously in the world cannot be benevolent

Extracts from this document...


A God who intervenes miraculously in the world cannot be benevolent . Discuss This statement is a paradox in itself, as it assumes that God can act miraculously, and that He is benevolent. This can be seen as a contradiction, as these two beliefs are incompatible. A God who intervenes miraculously in the world cannot be benevolent, because of the presence of natural and moral evil in the world. Surely a God who was able to act through miracles and prevent such evil and chose not to would be partisan, which would obviously detract from his benevolence. Therefore this statement poses a challenge to the theist, who believes in both a benevolent God who cares for humanity, and an omnipotent God who is able to perform the miraculous. ...read more.


Gareth Moore develops this point further, and suggests that it is possible that God is irrelevant to the concept of miracle, and that miracles are simply events, which cannot be explained. With this interpretation there is the implication that if miracles cannot be explained, the motivation for God creating them out of his benevolence is even harder to establish. If there were reasons and explanations for miracles, and God was seen to decide when reasons are justified for a miracle to take place, it would be hard to equate the God of the Bible who is benevolent with such harsh and partisan actions. However there is evidence in the Old Testament, that suggests that God is partisan, for example the idea that God will come to judge us on Judgement Day seems unjust and shallow. ...read more.


However as Kenny points out, 'God can only do that which is logically possible for God to do.' Thus if God's power or benevolence is limited then His actions will be limited accordingly. We have no way of measuring His power or goodness, because it is a relative concept. To talk of goodness as a measuring stick would imply that we know the extent of it. It could be argued that as finite beings we cannot grasp the concept of God's infinite goodness, and therefore cannot judge Him in relation to the suffering of this finite world. By questioning God's actions, and judging His acts of miraculous intervention in the world, it implies that we know the extent of God's power and goodness, and thus know how He should act. However this is not the case, and we cannot understand God's actions logically but only through faith. ?? ?? ?? ?? Ailsa Bulloch Theology Coursework ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Existence of God section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Existence of God essays

  1. Good and Evil

    The freedom to choose leads on to another problem - the problem of evil. Who is responsible for the suffering in deprived 3rd world and war torn countries? Again, who is responsible for the ecological rape of our planet, the pollution of the oceans and the atmosphere, and the destruction of the forests?

  2. Why does God allow Evil if he is omnipotent, omniscient and perfectly benevolent?

    and no point of existing so you could say that "Free Will" is worth all the suffering but then is god not evil to make a decision he knew would make our lives extraordinary but filled with suffering? Could he not do so we have a "Free Will" but a will of making and creating peace, prosperity and love?

  1. "The miracle stories in the New Testament suggest a God, who can do the ...

    The standard outline of the problem of a belief in miracles is outlined by Hume. Hume argues that miracles are not impossible but it is impossible to prove them. He considers that the laws of nature continue to happen and we have millions of examples of this, millions of people do not return from the dead to life.

  2. Explain how miracles are portrayed in the Bible.

    Surely they were people too? Some might argue that they were against God and therefore they were the advocates of the devil, but what happened to God being forgiving? Often, particularly in the Old Testament, Gods motives are brought into question, particularly in the book of Joshua when the fall of Jericho takes place.

  1. Evil and a God of love are incompatible so there cannot be a God ...

    If we do without the goodness of God, it seems that God will not prevent or overcome evil. Most theodicies attempt to show that this dilemma is only apparent and that it is possible to affirm both that God is all powerful and perfectly loving, despite the presence of real evil in the world.

  2. Preliminary Interpretation of Descartes Meditations

    that subjects such as physics, astronomy, medicine that involve the examination of complex things, can be doubted since they are based on things which have to exist, however other disciplines that discuss only very simple and general things that do not necessarily have to exist in nature, contain at least some certainty in his mind.

  1. The Old Testament.

    One of these gods, Ea, kills Apsu first. Tiamat becomes enraged, and increasingly threatening towards Ea and the remaining gods for killing her mate. One by one, the gods seek to quiet Tiamat, but each fails. However, one god, Marduk, agrees to stop Tiamat, but only if he is granted sole dominion over all other gods.

  2. The Holocaust - personal response to Anne Frank's diary and the problem of evil ...

    In her bedroom there were posters of famous actors, the royal family and theatre. Her passion for reading was mainly due to her father, Otto Frank, having a vast library as he encouraged his children to read. Anne was born in Frankfurt, Germany but grew up in Holland, therefore she was also to some extent a linguist.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work