• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"A religious experince is a sponatnious or induced,mental event over which the recepient has relatively little control

Extracts from this document...


"Religious experiences are all in the mind of the believer." Discuss "A religious experience is a spontaneous or induced mental event over which the recipient has relatively little control. It is often accompanied with the gaining of certain knowledge and the experience is always unique."1 Elton Trueblood's definition of a religious experience is very broad, including any experience of feelings of 'love, power, glory or strength from God.' This differs from a simple experience which can be defined as "an event or series of events participated in or lived through, especially one that makes a powerful impression on the mind and sense."2 It is obvious that religious experiences are all in the mind of a believer because a non- believer is capable of arguing against their existence and what people perceive to be a religious experience is just simply an experience or merely a 'coincidence' as Holland would state. This view is supported by Freud who takes a psychological approach and perceives religious experiences to be "a reaction to a hostile world."3 Furthermore Freud believes we feel helpless and seek a father figure, thus we create God, who satisfies our needs. Personally, I perceive God to be transcendent; "having existence outside the universe,"4 which supports my view that religious experiences do not exist, because God cannot intervene with our world. Religious experiences can be interpersonal, for example a numinous experience involving a sense of an awesome power which you are separate from. Alternatively they can be personal, like a mystical experience that includes a personal involvement with God such as a vision or trance. Religious experiences are very much a private matter rather than a public one, and it is not possible therefore to check someone else's religious experience. ...read more.


Intellectual conversions involve conflicts between two systems of thought, and can often result in the new thought being 'true' and the old one as 'false'; this can either be from one religion to another or to or from a religious system of thought. Intellectual conversions clearly provide no evidence for the existence of religious experiences because as human beings we question everything and therefore our thoughts are continually changing. It is highly unlikely that when experiencing an intellectual conversion even theists would not claim to experience feelings of 'love, power, glory or strength from God' as Elton Trueblood defined religious experiences. These types of conversions could realistically occur on a daily basis and this therefore does not fit the description of religious experiences being irregular unique and rare. Professor James H. Leuba (1868-1946) views religious life as "almost purely moral."11 A moral conversion involves a change in one's lifestyle rather than a system of thought, as an intellectual conversion does. The story of 'Swearing Tom' as told by Robert H. Thouless provides an example of a moral conversion. Moral conversions are more plausible as an example of a religious experience because religion can affect and change your life and therefore it follows that a religious experience would have a similar effect. Thus moral conversions provide credible support for the existence of religious experiences. Finally, a social conversion consists of a conversion taking place slowly in the subconscious followed by a rapid and sudden conscious experience, alternatively described as a "subconscious incubation'" by William James.12 - an example being the type of conversion witnessed by St Paul on the road to Damascus. A social conversion experience is very similar to that of a moral conversion, as it likewise causes change. ...read more.


Religious experiences consequently do not exist and therefore solely exist in the mind of the believer. For theists, religious experiences strengthen their beliefs and provide further proof for the existence of God, who they claim provided them with their religious experiences. However as these experiences are often personal, the claims rely solely on the individual's testimony, which can often cause difficulties in terms of reliability. For example, St Bernadette testified that she had seen and spoken to the Virgin Mary; others who witnessed the 'experience' stated they only saw her talking to an unseen 'someone'. In such circumstances it is impossible to obtain any form of empirical evidence, causing others to argue such claims are either a 'coincidence,' as suggested by Holland, or simply an 'experience.' Moreover, a theist would always be seeking and hoping for any form of communication with God, and as a result may interpret a regular and daily experience, such as a sunset, as a religious one, in order to subconsciously ensure themselves of their beliefs. Whereas an atheist would simply interpret a sunrise as an 'experience.' Finally in many cases, drugs or alcohol can produce very similar effects to a religious experience. In The Varieties of Religious Experience, (1902) James refers to experiments using nitrous oxide and anaesthetics, and suggests when mixed sufficiently with air, these substances 'stimulate the mystical consciousness to an extraordinary degree.' Therefore scientific evidence has proved that such experiences, similar to those of religious ones, can be caused due to substances. Even though there have been many claims of different types of religious experiences, these problems of verification clearly demonstrate that they are a fabrication of the mind. In conclusion I continue to share and maintain a similar belief to Freud; namely that religious experiences are 'all in the mind of the believer. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Existence of God section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Existence of God essays

  1. Religious Experiences

    of miracle as the waters at Lourdes are said to have healing properties. So a miracle is where God has acted on Earth and the people witnessing it have direct contact with God. Miracles are a major part of Christian beliefs.

  2. "Religious experience is all in the mind of the believer" -Examine and comment on ...

    It could be that through working for it a Buddhist may put their body through strenuous ordeals that could lead to some sort of psychological effect, where they thought they had a religious experience but really it was all in the mind. Other examples can relate to this claim, i.e.

  1. Compare and contrast two of the following and evaluate their significance for understanding religious ...

    Where as Aquinas, using the example of God being all-powerful explains that we know the properties of power in the world we live in but we do not know the extent of the word power when referred to God: we only know it in proportion to how we see power in our lives.

  2. Logical Positivism and the Meaninglessness of Religious Language.

    Ayer's Language, Truth and Logic of 1936. Its most famous spokesmen were Rudolf Carnap and Moritz Schlick. Religions like Christianity, Judaism and Islam, for example, in some sense assume some sort of 'factual' character in their belief assertions. Logical Positivism developed a criterion by which to distinguish the factual from the non-factual.

  1. Corporate religious experiences such as the Toronto blessing tell us nothing about god. Discuss

    Christians most holy book would be the bible and the gospels, however Muslims holy book would be the Qur'an or Jews holy book would be the Mosaic Torah. What ever the religion, there is anther common factor with religion, they have some holy book to which they refer to many

  2. Critically Discuss D.Z. Phillips Conception of Immortality.

    Surely if it is not me that lives on, but something of me, then we are talking of something which essentially is other than me. One may read Phillips as implying that there is, in a sense, a part of God within us and by harmonising ourselves with the good

  1. Explain why religious people may have problems with transplant surgery.

    the United Kingdom in 1995 saying that Muslims could carry donor cards and have transplants, Islam aims to do good and is not intended to put burdens on people which they can not bear for example if a close relative is dying and a transplant would save them, then it should be given.

  2. Individual religious experience means individual religious fantasy; corporate religious experience means corporate religious fantasy; ...

    With these points William James obviously felt that both individual and corporate experiences were not fantasy and genuine to the person. Albert Einstein said that "The fairest thing we can experience is the mysterious...a knowledge of the existence of something we cannot penetrate...

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work