• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Are all Christians Ministers?

Extracts from this document...


Are all Christians Ministers? INTRODUCTION John Collins' book "Are all Christians ministers?" attempts to examine the historical basis for the term ministry, to discover it's nature, scope and significance for the kind of church he believes, we have inherited from our traditions, in an endeavour to answer that all Christians are not ministers. MAJOR THEMES Combining a New Testament and historical background, Collins attempts to examine the original meanings and usage of the term ministry in the endeavour, contrary to the new dominant and popular stance held by many Protestant churches today, which is that all Christians are not ministers. [Collins,1992, p 1-3,13,22,51] Collins confides the exclusive rights to ministry to those officially commissioned to ministry in their churches in the role of an office. [Collins,1992,p 2,38-39] He argues that from the earliest tradition that "authentic" Christian ministry can only be a restricted role, unavailable to all, a historical succession of the sacrament of ordination, instituted and hierarchically structured by Christ himself. [Collins,1992, p 2-3,7-8, 26,38-40] Collins claims it holds power, creates a new being, involves preaching the word, leadership, dedication, trustworthiness, being a mediator and reconciler between God and humanity.. [Collins,1992,p 7-8,9,44-45] Collins appeals to Pope John Paul the seconds definition of lay ministry as ground in baptism and confirmation while ordained, grounded in the sacrament of order. ...read more.


[Collins,1992,p 1] Collins fails to name them and does not acknowledge authors such as Richard McBrien, Paul Bernier, Leonard Doohan, Brian Lucas and Thomas O'Meara of the Roman Catholic tradition who uphold an opposing view to hom when he makes this statement. [McBrien, 1987, p 21-22] [Bernier, 1992,p10] [Doohan, 1984,p 27] [Lucas, 1991,p p35-41] [O'Meara, 1983, p3] Collins also asserts that it is the "vanguard of that people of God whom historically the great church failed to make really part of the church" who are the ministerially conscious and applying pressure on church authorities. This assertion implies it is the outcast and perhaps bitter and vengeful people who only question the role of ministry. Collins fails to acknowledge those whom seek to be included, who search for truth, equality and want to grow in their Christian faith. [ Collins, 1992, p13] Collins identifies the confusion and risk of lessening of the distinctive role of the minister and threat of the commonness of one condition encroaching upon the exclusiveness of the other felt by the leaders of the Catholic church. He quotes the reformers stating that they believed that the lay person could not do the task of ministry. ...read more.


[O'Meara, 1983,p5-8] The history of ministry is not a set of norms to be maintained to the detriment of the changing needs of the church., rather it is located in God's grace and needs to be flexible in order to serve. [O'Meara,1983,p 13-14,44] PERSONAL RESPONSE & CONCLUSION Collins informative book arguing form traditional Catholic convictions has enabled me to appreciate the reasons the Roman Catholic Church highly esteems the role of the priest above all in the church. I can understand the threat the more broad usage of the term ministry causes to those whom so long have had a exclusive hold on ministry. However in the history of Nursing, roles previously having belonged to the profession of nursing became so specialistic that no one nurse could master them all. Other people took over various aspects such as Dietitians, wound therapists, that while grieved over for a time, allowed for the Nursing profession to focus clearly on its valuable contribution to the health care system. I believe this is also the case for the Catholic priesthood. I view the broad term of ministry in a positive sense as it is inclusive of all to build up the church through ministry, while maintaining the importance of the church as a priestly people still requiring it's own particular priests. -5- ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Places of Worship section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Places of Worship essays

  1. Factors which affect Tourism Flows on a general basis

    a sixty watt lightbulb powered by a hidden battery in his hand. The people of his home town were not spiritually orientated, so he hoped to use that to his advantage. The response was colossal. People flocked to him asking about his philosophy and how to become a member of his congregation.

  2. examine and outline the claim that luther's overriding concern was with his own salvation

    McGrath believes that it was simply an attempt at an academic debate: "The Lutheran Reformation was initially an academic movement" McGrath If Luther had really been concerned with the salvation of others at this time, he would have mentioned his own revelation.

  1. The Churches struggle against apartheid and a comment on the effectiveness of this Challenge.

    cope; during the campaign over eight thousand people were imprisoned.22 In November 1952 the government dismissed Luthuli as the chief of his tribe for his part in organising the defiance campaign, after his dismissal Luthuli made a speech and his faith in the church during the time of apartheid can be seen in these closing words: " I try...

  2. Our contribution to the arts.

    The last time they attended a youth conference was in Serowe (1999), after which they dispersed. There were usually bible studies on Saturdays, which were attended mostly by the youth; they went forever when they stopped. As usual, the youth are numerous on the Sunday that Moruti comes (-week of the month).

  1. R.s Roles of men and women

    Some Christians believe that the wife should obey the husband and support and care for him- in his career and his children. Therefore the man should be in charge and needs to look after his wife and children, and bringing food home for his family.

  2. women ordination

    Do not women show Christ like characteristics such as love, compassion, personal concern, nurturing, wisdom and sacrifice? What is essential is Christ's humanity not his maleness. Tradition- The "received" tradition in the church of women as inferior has excluded them from the sacramental role of priesthood and from other decision-making roles.

  1. Christianity - history and beginings

    Jesus had chosen 12 men, known as the apostles, to preach the gospel after His death. About 50 days after the Crucifixion, the apostles and other followers of Jesus claimed that the Holy Spirit had entered them and given them the ability to speak foreign languages.

  2. Write a brief critical introduction to the book of Psalms.

    This essay will focus mainly upon the critical approaches undertaken to investigate the origin and meaning of the Psalms. Gunkel and Mowinckel and the search for a historical background Although theologically used, classified, and commented upon throughout the ages, he exact origin of the Psalms have, until quite recent times, been somewhat of a mystery.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work