• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"BismarckFailed To Control The Catholic Church In Germany" Discuss.

Extracts from this document...


"Bismarck Failed To Control The Catholic Church In Germany" Discuss Witold Kozlowski 6EN This essay will set out to present the reasons for Bismarck's failure to control the Catholic Church in Germany. It will mainly concentrate on the May Laws, since the Church's strong opposition to this particular legislation, was what brought about the causes of Bismarck's failure. The doctrine of papal infallibility by Pope Pius IX, published on 18 July 1870, immediately created a division within the German Catholics. The New Catholics regarded the question of papal infallibility as another of his attributes to be accepted, while the Old Catholics found this objectionable. Both sides of the dispute appealed to the state: the former for the support of the Pope's bulla; the latter for protection against the Episcopal inhibitions disallowing them to perform their functions (mainly university professors). ...read more.


The extreme measures contained in these laws were to force the 'weak' Catholics into utter submission. Without going into great detail of the May Laws the fundamental aim of this legislation was to make Germans attach more importance to the state than to the Church. This was done mainly by establishments such as: the state taking complete control over education, making Church appointments veto-able by the state, making civil marriage and state examinations for clergy (in philosophy, history and German literature) compulsory. Further on, most religious orders were closed down and the state discontinued maintenance for Catholic bishops and priests. Contrary to Bismarck's expectations, the reaction of the Church against these laws was exceptionally strong. The clerics built up a powerful and extraordinarily well-organised party, with great financial resources and influential press. This was the Catholic Centre Party, which informally already existed (since it consisted of Catholics). ...read more.


Furthermore, Bismarck failed to note that by taking over matters such as education, vetoing church appointments, etc., of the German Catholic Church, he stumbled onto the main ideas of the Catholic Church, as a whole, which was an international institution; and a powerful to that, with tremendous resources, power and influences in Europe. It was only when he faced the well-organised Catholic Centre Party, backed up by the whole Catholic Church, did he realise that his failure of controlling the Church lay in his misjudgment of the Catholics' response. Nevertheless, the government made no effort to enlist the sympathy of educated Catholics for the cause of freedom of opinion, which might have lessened the fierce and united Catholics' riposte thus leading to compromise on the issue of the May Laws, instead of complete withdrawal from the idea. Furthermore, a subtler legislation against the Catholics might have not caused such a united stance against the state hence gaining some control over the German Catholic in place of none. 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Places of Worship section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Places of Worship essays

  1. Why was the Catholic Church so weak by 1780?

    Europe and were in many ways the 3'embodiment of baroque Catholicism' of this era. They held a truly privileged position as the 4'educators of the elite the confessors of kings and evangelized on the furthest frontiers of overseas empires'. Even the Vatican subscribed to Jesuitism and it was closely associated with the ruling elites.

  2. The unrest caused by the religious wars and thereformers exaggerated church with the devil ...

    Augustine, however, argued that magic was the work of evil spirits, and this became the accepted view within the church (Middle Ages 169). In 906, the first important European legal text to refer to witchcraft, Canon Eposcopi, was written.

  1. St Germans Church in Cornwall

    Stone Work The stonework is made out of large stones; some of the stones are made from the local query. In this picture you can see some of the stonework. Windows The windows are narrow nocks hafts with a rounded pointed top.

  2. Why did Germany respond so rapidly to Luther's message?

    Even before the reformation started, the majority of peasants lived in villages, on the land, cultivating it with 'indefatigable labour and primitive technology' (Mullet pg. 16) and even though some peasants were not badly off, even the condition of the more prosperous was gruelling and required 'an ever watchful suspicion, especially towards landlords' (Mullet pg.

  1. Explain why the PresbyterianExperiment of the 1640's and 1650's largely failed

    the debate about Church Government was raging and the question about who in the place of Anglicans had ultimate disciplinary power was never satisfactorily answered. Divided reformers lead a somewhat divided church. Oliver Cromwell talked freely about 'God's people' (the Presbyterians, independents and Baptists)

  2. Discussion on why Christianity failed to gain popularity in modern Japan?

    However, the kind of intimate bonding that takes place in many congregations coupled with the high expectations for involvement can scare away inquirers even when they are already Christian. . This closed characteristic of the church has left many Christians estranged from the church who might otherwise contribute to the vitality of the church.

  1. The Church In Nazi Germany.

    Only invited Nazis were allowed to give sermons in a Reich Church. Hitler gave his support to the "German Christians", who believed that pastors (=a person/priest authorized to conduct religious worship) should take an oath of loyalty to Hitler, and that any member of the church who had Jewish ancestry should be sacked.

  2. Explain why Luther's protest spreads so quickly in Germany in the years up to ...

    Machiavelli is quoted as saying that the Emperor had "no power to enforce his will". At this time, Maximilian I was the Holy Roman Emperor and was not particularly successful as he lacked skill and persistence. The estates liked this because it meant that he seldom interfered with their affairs,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work