• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Capital Punishment

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Capital Punishment Capital punishment is a government's response to what society considers the maximum crime. The crimes that are usually deemed the worst are usually limited to intentional murder or treason. However, not all governments consider capital punishment appropriate, and a number of countries do not provide for it. Capital punishment is a nice way of saying execution or retaliatory murder. Simply put, a person who is sentenced for a capital offense faces execution. While the method differs according to what state you live in, the result is nevertheless the same. The larger question concerns the morality of government-sponsored killing. An examination of the issue reveals valid arguments on both sides of the debate. The issue has faced man since society began to develop. It is very likely that the debate will endure long beyond our lives. Those that support capital punishment use a variety of arguments. Some of these begin with the very traditional-the Bible. "An eye for an eye" is often used as an appropriate argument. "The punishment should fit the crime" is another one. ...read more.

Middle

When they leave prison will they be able to function in society in a law-abiding way or not? In capital cases, where the prisoner would not be released, it almost doesn't matter what happens to the criminal. The U.S. Constitution prohibits 'cruel and unusual punishment". Is not an execution "cruel and unusual punishment"? The Supreme Court says that it is not, and for years has allowed for executions. Texas and Florida are two leading states in the area of executions. Yet the result of those states' activities is meager. If advocates of capital punishment believe that it is a deterrent, why is it that the murder rate in these states continue to climb, while in states where there is no capital punishment (Vermont, Massachusetts) the murder rate has actually decreased. Aside from the deterrent debate, there is the moral one. As stated above, does a civilized society have the right to take a life? How can a culture that preaches forgiveness and the value of life, argue in favor of executions? Isn't it interesting that those who generally oppose abortion (basing their argument on the sanctity of life) ...read more.

Conclusion

Yet those who argue for it have not all lost a loved one to murder. Even in the case of Timothy McVeigh, the Oklahoma bomber, a number of relatives of the victims oppose his death. Yet McVeigh himself has dropped his appeals and has asked to be executed as quickly as possible. I find that the entire issue of deterrence is flawed. Murder, by definition, is an irrational act. An irrational person who does not stop and think of the consequences of his action certainly does not stop and think of the possible punishment. In addition, the lack of statistical evidence merely adds to my feelings. With murders continuing to rise in states with plenty of executions, how can one argue that it is acting as a deterrent? As long as we claim that we live in a civilized society, the government must set the standard of our civility. Permitting executions is wrong on its face. We do not prevent murder and we do not promote morality; we merely give in to our weaknesses and uncivilized past. Capital punishment may have been acceptable years ago, but it no longer can be considered civilized. It leaves us no better than the criminal, only with a moralistic excuse for revenge. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Capital Punishment section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Capital Punishment essays

  1. The Punishment must fit the crime

    The main theory of punishment in Islam is retribution. They teach 'an eye for an eye a tooth for a tooth.' The idea is treat others how they treat you. This is mainly the belief because it is contained within their holy book which is the word of god.

  2. Capital Punishment

    Therefore, to summarize, Kaiser says, "It was because humans are made in the image of God that capital punishment for first degree murder became a perpetual obligation. To kill a person was tantamount to killing God in effigy. That murderer's life was owed to God, not to society ..."

  1. Free essay

    "Death is nothing to us." How good are the Epicurean arguments for this ...

    Epicurus thinks that if there are gods then they are divine and so are not concerned in human affairs, so then why should humans be concerned with theirs? Lucretius (on the symmetry argument) says; "nature shows us this as a mirror of the time that will be after we have finally died".

  2. Capital Punishment Workshop.

    This helped me to understand how dire capital punishment can be. It also helped me how to understand prisoner's points of views and what triggers their behaviour. Judging from this play it still did not change my final decision on capital punishment that it should be legalised but only for

  1. Capital Punishment, is it an effective or ineffective deterrent?

    It would occur that people are convicted of murder when they should really have only been convicted of manslaughter as happens now but without the execution. There are the feelings of the condemned's family, it is hard enough accepting the death of a loved one in normal circumstances, but one

  2. Analyse the philosophical principles of at least one ethical theory and evaluate its application ...

    Murder, unlike assault and battery, demands exact retribution, the death penalty, because no amount of jail time or other punishment can be realistically equated with the loss of the victim's life. The murderer is executed, and the principle stands. What happens, then, to a man convicted of rape, torture, and murder?

  1. Justice and Forgiveness.

    Some murders are effects of the hatred that's been storing up inside you over a very long period of time and when it comes down to doing it, nothing would stop you.

  2. Capital Punishment Amendment Act 1868

    In part because of the fact that it is middle class writers whose accounts are most relied upon, on the basis that they were the most literate and therefore the most able to take note of what was unfolding than any other.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work