• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Charity Does Not Have the Effect Christians Want

Extracts from this document...


CHARITY DOES NOT HAVE THE EFFECT CHRISTIANS WANT IT MAKES PEOPLE LAZY AND KEEPS THEM POOR. DO YOU AGREE? GIVE REASONS FOR YOUR ANSWER, SHOWING YOU HAVE CONSIDERED MORE THAN ONE POINT OF VIEW There is much conjecture about whether charity really helps those in need or whether it promotes laziness and keeps them poor. People that believe that the giving of charity works, argue that underprivileged societies would suffer more than they have without it. Perhaps recognising that just giving money to poor people will promote laziness, many Christian charities now try to give aid in the form of knowledge and skills rather than simply throwing money wantonly at the problems faced. For example, the Catholic charity CAFOD, who recently sent a guest speaker (Dermott McNulty) to our school, showed us some of the work he did for CAFOD in South America. Instead of simply giving money and leaving, CAFOD stayed and gave the people the equipment and skills necessary to work their own way out of poverty by running operations like soup kitchens. ...read more.


They hold the view that it is clear that no amount of charity can ever fully solve the problems faced and charity only makes matters worse by giving them a taster of what they are missing. Also, they believe that recipients of charity can often lose any motivation to work or improve things for themselves. Why work when your needs are being provided by others? Such advocates believe that charities are making the situation worse for the poor by giving their governments' an excuse not to take more responsibility in solving the problems. They contend that whilst charities keep providing resources, their governments' are able to abandon their responsibility to their own people. We can surmise that Jesus is suggesting in the Parable of the Talents that Charity does not necessarily have to be a Christian obligation. The Parable tells us that the third servant used his talents badly and is punished as a result. This implies that just because one (in our case, .developed countries) has talents i.e. monies/resources, this does not mean that those talents have to be used in one particular way. ...read more.


Arguably, without the aid, it would have been more likely that the Bangladeshis would have tried harder to solve the cause of the problem. This situation has moved on in more recent times, and now much of the aid ( in collaboration with the government) is focused on providing longer term solution for the people most affected. e.g. building of levees, irrigation systems, re-forrestation etc. After considering the different points of view and the supporting evidence, I think that charity, if used well, can be very beneficial to small communities. It can give poor people a chance to work and improve their conditions. As in the example set by CAFOD in South America it can give people the opportunity to work themselves away from poverty by offering them some measure of self sufficiency. It can provide incentives to work rather than take the easy option of being lazy. . Charity needs to be well conceived and planned. It is not just about money and 'having its heart in the right place'. Otherwise, things can turn out badly and the people can become lazy and more dependent on the charity they get given. 1 2 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Charities, Poverty and Development section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Charities, Poverty and Development essays

  1. Explain what Christians believe about their responsibility for other people.

    Another main problem is hunger. People in less developed countries are unable to gain the resources or money for food and drink. This results in starvation, malnutrition and death.

  2. World Poverty Coursework - Are A Christians Attitudes Towards Charity right? And Do They ...

    God divides the souls of some people who are to be judged, into two groups like a shepherd would do with his sheep and goats. He places the righteous on the right and the others on the left. He tells the souls on the right that they can go up

  1. Explain what Christians believe about their responsibility for other people.

    This is like when Jesus said to the rich young man to give up his wealth and follow Him. The man couldn't and could not follow Jesus. Do Helder Camera realised that this was like the rich people not giving to the poor in the city.

  2. Weber’s Cookbook: The Missing Ingredients

    Secondly, Catholics believed in a justified, fair price, but capitalists seek profits in any way. Thirdly, economic traditionalism despised greed when it came to wealth and considered it as a sin. On the other hand, capitalism encouraged avarice, a lust for seeking vast amounts of wealth.

  1. In this essay I will be looking at how Christianity and charities relate to ...

    to actually give what you need and by doing so you are giving more because you are prepared to give it up for someone else's sake. 'No matter who says what, you should accept it with a smile and do your own work,' Mother Teresa.

  2. Missionaries of Charity

    The order was established in 1949 and its charter states that they should only receive monies that individual people give them.

  1. "Charity does not have the effect Christians want. It makes people lazy and keeps ...

    An important factor to bear in mind is that Jesus does not appear in the 'Parable of the Talents' to condone simply giving aid to people in the form of money - the people in need must use their talents.

  2. Christians and Jews want to care for the planet because they believe that this ...

    An example of this would be the Chipko Movement in 1970?s. This was when people started hugging trees to prevent them from cut as they knew they were important. Quotes like this show ?Everyone rests on me as pearls are strung on a thread.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work