• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast 'Maternity', written by Lilika Nakos and 'The Lemon Orchard', by Alex La Guma.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and Contrast essay (1st draft). 'Maternity', written by Lilika Nakos and 'The Lemon Orchard', by Alex La Guma both present an insight into the strengths and weaknesses of human nature. The teenage boy, Mikali, in 'Maternity' stands for courage and determination, who tries at any cost to save his infant brother. Similarly, in 'The Lemon Orchard' the protagonist is a man of great self-respect who retains his pride against great odds. The story is mainly about a black man who is to be beaten up by a mob of white men solely because he has dared to ask for justice. The ominous atmosphere established in this short story is primarily evoked through the use of symbolism. Despite the striking similarity, 'Maternity' concludes on an uplifting tone, conveying that although racism leads to conflict it can also be an opportunity for a rewarding and enriching experience. There is always hope, and it takes unique situations to overcome racism, as well as compassion from people who know no barrier of creed, caste and colour. In contrast with the serious approach to racism is 'The All-American Slurp', written by Lensey Namioka. This is a humorous approach to a young girl's encounter with a foreign culture. This short story playfully mocks culture groups who want to 'fit in', by watering down their own culture to adapt and feel accepted. ...read more.

Middle

The Chinaman retains his sense of humanity, whilst selfishness prevails amongst the women. The Chinaman's wife is portrayed as the 'ideal mother', evokes culture warmth and etiquette as she accepts the child as it is. One parallel between 'Maternity' and 'The Lemon Orchard' is their use of tactile imagery and symbolism, which is so delicate, the reader, may not consciously recognize it, yet it helps immensely in creating the menacing atmosphere desired. Alex la Guma also wants to show the conflict between man and nature. So uses detailed description and pathetic fallacy to make the reader feel apprehensive and make the weather, scene and story fit together: "... there was a chill in the air; and the moon was hidden behind long, high parallels of cloud, which hung like suspended streamers of dirty cotton wool in the sky. In 'The Lemon Orchard' the notion of 'chill' and 'winter' keeps circulating; it has a strong metaphorical significance, representing the indifference and coldness of the white man. On a very basic level, one can already note the significance for the use of night and dark imagery - to portray a sense of secrecy and fear of the white men. On a further level, Alex la Guma's use of night imagery indicates the white men's blindness towards racism. ...read more.

Conclusion

This technique portrays the realism whilst also helping immensely in bringing out the irony. The young Chinese girl thinks that because she comes from a different ethnic background she that the American family will be less receptive and assume that they are 'weird'. It is her hypersensitivity that makes it so difficult for her to 'fit in' the American way of living as she does not want to disgrace herself. "Mother picked up one of the green stalks, and father followed suit. Then I picked up a stalk, and my brother did to" The mother is able to adapt, whilst the patriotic father is set in his own ways. The mother inverts the stereotype as she seems to be in control and her family looks up to her. Amusingly the Chinese family thinks the American family is primitive and backward and they are more advanced, however by the end the story highlights the endless similarities that often mark as differences. All of these short stories give the reader an insight in the flaws of human nature. Yet also helps the reader understand the concept that everyone is equal and entitled to the same amount of respect. These stories are voices to make people aware of what is happening to society and convey in a world of slander, ignorance and discrimination that there is always hope. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Prejudice and Discrimination section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Prejudice and Discrimination essays

  1. In "The Lemon Orchard," La Guma uses a number of techniques to convey his ...

    The word "quivering" and the moon's emergence also suggest the Nature is waiting for the impending beating. La Guma's depiction of Nature condoning the violence, shows that Nature has made a paradoxal U-turn from its initial position of condemning racism.

  2. show racism the red card'

    "In the next few years there may be a small number of black and ethnic minority graduating into football. However, if these become successful the situation could snowball" "[Black and ethnic minority heritage players] are following a similar pattern

  1. Crooks is a Negro stable buck

    Moreover, Crooks possessed "a tattered dictionary" and "a pair of large gold-rimmed spectacles" revealing to the reader that he reads a lot and is literate. This suggests that he is a very intelligent and a well educated man as during this time not many people could read.

  2. Using the poems- 'Telephone conversation' by Wole Soyinka and 'Nothing Said' by Brenda Agard, ...

    As it says in the pun, 'hide and speak', this is what we "see" of him. But we learn what kind of a person he is "inside" his mind. He is sensitive, tolerant and has a dry sense of humour.

  1. With reference to culture and tradition, discuss the presentation of themes and characters in ...

    the direction of the gate" Another main act of culture we see in this story is male dominance and female submission, "...., but they dared not to talk" In "Coffee for the Road", the author presents the identity of protagonist as to her background, "handsome Indian face".

  2. A reply to an angry letter.

    Finally, in July, they captured Kigali. The government collapsed and they declared a ceasefire. As soon as the new leaders took over, an estimated two million Hutus fled to Zaire (now the Democratic Republic of Congo). These refugees include many who have since been implicated in the massacres.

  1. Lost Hope.

    When an employer discovers that a candidate is Hispanic, the candidate's opportunity to acquire the job diminishes.

  2. Equality: Have We Mastered It Yet?

    Racial discrimination is evident in every state and in all sorts of people. Racial Profiling is an excellent example of racial discrimination today. A study by the University of Pennsylvania showed blacks were stopped three and half more times then whites and yielded only thirty three percent of contraband carried.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work