• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically Assess the Claim that the Idea of God is Innate

Extracts from this document...


?Critically Assess the Claim that the Idea of God is Innate? The claim that the idea of God is innate is the idea that we are born knowing about God a priori. To claim that we are born with the idea of God, doesn?t necessarily need to mean that from birth, we are always aware of God?s existence, but rather it lies dormant within our mind, ready to be triggered by some form of stimuli. Hence, although we have discovered the concept of God through our parents or spiritual leaders, it is not the origin of the idea; rather it is the activation of the idea. Father of modern philosophy, Rene Descartes was a very influential person in trying to formally prove that the idea of God is innate. One of the main arguments he uses to do this, is his ?Trademark Argument. The ultimate purpose of the Trademark Argument put forward by Descartes is to attempt to show that he can only have the idea of God in his mind, if there was originally a God to put that idea in his mind. For example, in the same way how the trademark on a piece of clothing tells us the maker; Descartes states that the idea of God within his mind reveals its maker, God. ...read more.


This is the theory that a butterfly flapping its wings in one part of the world might ultimately cause a hurricane in another part of the world. Therefore the cause is not adequate to the effect, and disproves the casual principle. Hence, it essentially disproves Descartes trademark argument, because the idea of God doesn?t necessarily have to come from an equally supreme being. Philosopher David Hume stated that we cannot determine the cause of anything simply by examining the effect. By saying this, Hume is effectively arguing against Descartes? causal principle. Hume says that just by seeing the window breaking, he can?t infer what must have caused it to break. In the example of the shattering window, it was stated that we know that something large, with enough force, must have been caused the window to shatter, but how can we know this? Hume claims that we can?t know this through a priori reasoning, but rather through recollection of a past experience of glass shattering. We have learned from experience, which sort of objects can cause the window to shatter. If we came across a shattering window for the first time, we wouldn?t know what caused it to occur. ...read more.


Thus we get the idea of God as an infinite being, innately. In conclusion, although Descartes had a fairly strong argument with the trademark argument, there were a few problems with it. If God was the cause of the concept of God in our minds, or the ?trademark?, then surely each and every person would have the same ?trademark?. Yet, everyone has a different concept of God, or different ?trademarks?. Furthermore, Descartes causal principle, which states that the cause of something must be as great as or superior to the effect, also faces some problems. One of the main problems to Descartes causal principle is that there are in fact effects that can be much greater than the cause, for example, a single match causing a whole bonfire. Philosophers like Hume have shown that you cannot work out the cause of something, by simply examining the effect. This is true because, for example, if you have never seen a window break before, then we can?t know through a priori reasoning alone that we need a large object with enough force. We can only know through experience. In the same way, we need to experience God coming into existence to actually know that he is the cause of our idea of God. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Existence of God section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Existence of God essays

  1. Explain the Christian idea of God. How is this idea of God reflected in ...

    They are the earliest set of laws written by the Jews in the Old Testament. Some of the commandments are religious and some are related to the social system. The first commandment "Serve God alone." This is a religious commandment it asking Christians to do everything in the name of God.

  2. 'An analysis of arguments for the existence of God will result in valid philosophical ...

    The only problem I can see so far is the discrepancy between these religions - each seems to claim mutually exclusive truths. For example, Christianity believes Jesus to be a historical and physical incarnation of God, whereas Islam judges him to be a true prophet and a man who never died at all, but rose to Heaven.

  1. Explain the Ontological argument.

    Irenaeus then continued to look on to Heaven, where everyone would have completed the development into Gods likeness and where the suffering of Earth would have long been forgotten. It is vital that everyone achieves this stage, as it marks the completion of Gods creation.

  2. T H E D E S I G N A R ...

    The design argument does not demonstrate God's infinity: Hume previously pointed out these weaknesses. For Kant the design argument could never demonstrate the existence of God because it was based on information filtered by the human mind, and may be mistaken.

  1. "Discuss critically religious and secular ethical arguments about environmental issues"

    As everything has a purpose, nothing exists unless it of some use to man, we should use other creatures as we wish and see fit[7]. However, contrary to this, deep ecologists are often attracted to Aristotle's philosophy as he considered the world to be a whole, with all beings striving to reach their purpose, or 'end'.

  2. "Religious experience is all in the mind of the believer" -Examine and comment on ...

    An example of this is a Buddhist mystical experience in which they meditate to try and awaken the 'Oneness of life itself and experience reality as it truly is' (www.buddhistfaith.tripod.com/integrated/id10.html). To me in this example it seems like Buddhists train to receive a religious experience and that it does not always come naturally but they have to work for it.

  1. The idea of God - Who was Emily Dickinson's God?

    Dickinson parallels her way of keeping the Sabbath to the traditional way of keeping the Sabbath throughout the poem. She capitalizes both the traditional methods, and her methods. "God preaches, a noted Clergyman," (Hillman 36). Dickinson is not trying to prove that her way is better but rather that her way is just as good as the way of others.

  2. Describe some of the arguments which followers of the religion which you are studying ...

    What if a mother's son or daughter committed suicide, surely they would not sigh to theirselves and think its chain of events which caused this and this was meant to happen because its Gods plan. I don't think that they would accept that, it would be a very difficult thing

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work