• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss and evaluate ethical dilemmas - Euthanasia

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

During this essay I will discuss and evaluate ethical dilemmas. The two words which are used to 'make up' this are 'ethical', dealing with the debate of ethics and questions connected with them, and 'dilemma', a situation with two or more solutions, equally unfavourable. The medical profession face many ethical dilemmas, many of them dictate the patients future. Patient confidentiality has long been integrated into medical procedure, however, should the parents of a fifteen year old girl be told that her daughter is pregnant, even if the girl wishes for the situation to be kept confidential? The parents of the child would certainly want to know about their daughters pregnancy, and as the child is under the legal age for such responsibilities , should it be the parents right to know. Cosmetic surgery on the NHS raises a few eye-brows. People who receive burns and other devastating injuries to the face who are less well-off often have their social lives shattered by receiving these injuries and not being able to afford private surgery. ...read more.

Middle

What is right, what is wrong? Finally we come to euthanasia, a mercy killing by means of non- treatment (passive) or deliberately attempting to end the life quickly and painlessly (active). This has been debated widely especially between pro-life groups (including the catholic church) and pro-euthanasia groups such as EXIT. Should the right to die be the responsibility of the person involved or the doctor? If the patient is in a 'persistent vegetative state' then who should decide their fate, the doctors or the family? The legal situation of euthanasia is very cloudy throughout the world, in England legal precedents are commonplace and these precedents make the law more complicated. In the Netherlands euthanasia is illegal but tolerated by the authorities if a certain procedure is applied, prosecution if this procedure is applied is rare. The Tony Bland case was a legal precedent in England when the courts allowed for him to be euthanised after his brain shrunk through oxygen starvation during the Hillsborough disaster which left him in a 'persistent vegetative state'. ...read more.

Conclusion

A case which would have been an excellent milestone did not go to court as the child in question died in his home from cerebal palsy. The parents of Thomas Creedon, who could not hear or see, claimed that their son was paralysed, had constant fits, was in constant pain and suffering by being forced to stay alive. The Times newspaper states that 'Thomas's doctors wanted to continue feeding him and were set to oppose his parents application. They disputed the Creedons belief that he was constantly in pain. Mrs Creedon had said "Thomas has a very distressing existence and I find it difficult to see how the medical profession in this particular area is prepared to perpetuate that suffering, no matter what the realistic outcome is likely to be.".'This was a case of distress for Mrs Creedon. Euthanasia raises many questions, is a doctor a judge or is he just a doctor, is one who involves oneself in euthanising another a saint or a sinner? What constitutes unbearable pain, whose dcision is it? All of these questions and many more all constitute to the cloudy and complicated legal system. Should euthanasia be legalised, is it right. ?? ?? ?? ?? Stephen McManus ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Abortion and other medical issues section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Abortion and other medical issues essays

  1. Abortion Debate - Pro-Life Stance

    accredited hospital deemed that continuation of the pregnancy constituted a severe threat to the life and health, mental or physical of the women. Threat to health was not defined and so it is variously interpreted to mean very real medical disease to anything that interferes with even social or economic

  2. Abortion and Euthanasia

    This gives them a responsibility, as true Christians, to speak out if they believe that something is not just. This can be used when referring to the ideas of life on the subject of abortion. For example, an unborn foetus, which has not done anything wrong, is about to be aborted, which some Christians would consider to be unjust.

  1. The Chamberlain Case -

    Finally Lindy chamberlain had said that her baby daughter, Azaria, was wearing a Matinee jacket on the night of her disappearance. This accusation was said to be untrue and that Mrs Chamberlain had made the whole thing up. Once the Prosecution had prosecuted its arguments to the court, it was then the defences turn to present theirs.

  2. "Scientific advances continue to arise ethical questions within the field of medicine, which can ...

    Incest and rape is another reason for aborting the baby. Both these are very emotional issues to come across and traumatic for the victim but even though pregnancy from rape or incest is very rare it does happen and women do abort their babies because of this.

  1. Is Euthanasia ethical?

    * would sick people be pressurised by relatives ? * would it lead to involuntary euthanasia for the old or handicapped ? * is it not our duty to care for those in our society who are ill ? * isn't life always precious no matter what sort of life it is ?

  2. Abortion and Euthanasia

    However, the Act contained a clause allowing account to be taken of the woman's 'actual or reasonably foreseeable environment', and this allowed doctors to interpret the act in such a way that a great variety of social, financial or emotional problems could be considered as justifying abortion.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work