• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss two criticisms of the argument from religious experience. To what extent is the argument successful in spite of these objections?

Extracts from this document...


1. Discuss two criticisms of the argument from religious experience. To what extent is the argument successful in spite of these objections? The use of religious experience to justify cognitive belief in a personal God has caused controversy amongst theists and atheists alike. The argument hinges on the principle of credulity; that is, consistency demands that we should treat apparently veridical religious sensory experiences the same as ordinary sensory experiences unless there are special considerations. This and the principle of testimony thus prove God's existence; if someone tells you that they have had such an experience, it is usually reasonable to believe them. Being non-empirical yet an inductive and a posteriori proof, this argument has attracted a variety of criticisms. One such challenge is the "Naturalistic Objection" which attempts to explain these supposed religious experiences atheistically, be it through psychology or socio-economics. ...read more.


an experience of "x" is genuine if the experience is caused by "x". 2. If there is a God, then S/He as the first cause is the initiator of events. 3. Therefore if there is a God, every experience of God is veridical. 4. Therefore the psychological origin of religious experience is not incompatible with the veridicality of religious experience. This seems an attractive stance, however Franks-Davis disputes God's place in this causal change. As the "first cause" of Aquinas' Cosmological argument, God appears less direct and personal in the chain of events. She simply proposes that one should reapply the "principle of credulity", one should assume that it is veridical unless under special circumstances. This objection does, however, highlight an important aspect of theistic faith. According to Vardy, religious experience should not be the sole reason for belief in God as an epistemological basis could be disproved. ...read more.


This particular rebuttal is modest at best as it hopes to eliminate any variation and subjectivity to its detriment. Hick asserts (with greater success) that although religions have different cultural perspectives, they each have an equally true idea of "the Real". This is in accordance with his idea of the world's "religious ambiguity"; as there is an epistemic distance between God and humans, all interpretations of an event are reasonable until they are eschatologically verified. The crucial difference between the argument from religious experience and others such as the teleological argument for several is that it goes beyond rhetoric; it uses what many theists see as explicit and incontrovertible proof for an interactive and personal God. To the individual who encounters the supernatural, the event serves to enhance their faith. Theists can use them to intellectually justify their beliefs as a part of Swinburne's cumulative case. An argument's worth is ultimately difficult to gauge because it depends whether one rates being able to convert atheists over inspiring organic faith or substantiating one's own beliefs. Religious Experience ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Existence of God section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Existence of God essays

  1. The Teleological Argument.

    Until a few years ago there were several gaps in science which have now been filled resulting in greater proof of the 'design argument'. A former professor at the University of Cambridge, John Polkinghorne speaks of the creation of the world as 'delicate and intricate in order to be able to support human life.'

  2. Logical Positivism and the Meaninglessness of Religious Language.

    * R.M. Hare's 'blik' Hare claimed that Flew was basically right about the falsifiability of religious beliefs (religious beliefs are not really cognitive assertions because they are not falsifiable) but wrong about the implications of this (nevertheless, they are meaningful and important).

  1. Corporate religious experiences such as the Toronto blessing tell us nothing about god. Discuss

    Prayer experience of the numinous which any believer weather be Muslim praying to Allah or Christian praying to God, this individual experience can take in any place for church as an example, where the believer feels that they can communicate with god through prayer the believer may feel that God

  2. What are the key features of the design argument for the existence of God? ...

    This idea caused such a stir within the philosophical and scientific community that the teleological argument was left hanging by a thread as another ancient, outdated idea. Charles Darwin, who conceptualised the idea was not a philosopher and may not have set out to destroy the teleological argument; portrayed the

  1. Individual religious experience means individual religious fantasy; corporate religious experience means corporate religious fantasy; ...

    Broad uses this analogy to demonstrate that it is reasonable to suppose that religious experiences are actual and can base an argument upon these experiences. William James (1842-1910) believed in a right each individual has to affirm religious propositions solely upon the basis of emotional predilection, but only under certain conditions.

  2. "A religious experince is a sponatnious or induced,mental event over which the recepient has ...

    This implies that by making such contradictions they cancel one another out and as a result also the existence of religious experiences. Swinburne identifies five kinds of religious experiences, two public and three private. The two types of public are firstly those in which God, or God's action, is identified

  1. Outline the argument from religious experience to the existence of God.

    For example, when you see a football heading straight towards you and subsequently colliding with your head, you not only see the football coming towards you but also feel the football when it hits your head. Through the interaction of the two senses of sight and touch it would seem

  2. A Big Bang Cosmological Argument for God's Nonexistence

    The first three scientific premises articulated in the last section, the Einstein equation, Friedmann's solutions to this equation and the Hawking-Penrose singularity theorem, provide us with the two premises (1) The big bang singularity is the earliest state of the universe.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work