• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluate the Ethical Arguments For and Against Voluntary Euthanasia

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Evaluate the Ethical Arguments For and Against Voluntary Euthanasia Euthanasia is defined as an 'act of killing someone painlessly to relieve his or her suffering'1. It's etymology is derived from the Greek 'eu thanatos' which means a good death. It is a contentious issue that provokes strong arguments for and against changing UK legislation to permit it. The UK currently prohibits active euthanasia. Active euthanasia is an act where the intention is to end or deliberately shorten someone's life. A doctor will administer a drug such as morphine or potassium chloride. Such an act is considered to be murder and a doctor found guilty of this offence faces a long prison sentence. An extremely significant case which played a part in determining whether voluntary active euthanasia is illegal was the case of Dr Cox. His patient Lilian Boyes, who was seventy years old and suffering from severe rheumatoid arthritis, asked him to kill her. She was expected to die within a matter of days, but the pain she was suffering from was unbearable. Out of compassion he gave her a lethal dose of potassium chloride. As there was a possibility that she could have died from other causes due to her condition, he was only charged with attempted murder. Some people may believe that this case was unfair and the fact that Dr Cox was acting out of mercy and compassion should act in favour for him. Even with modern pain control people can still suffer right to the end of life. ...read more.

Middle

Therefore a crippling illness is not enough to take away the intrinsic value of life. They say that ending our own life is rejecting Gods sovereignty over our lives, and the freedom that God gives us should not stretch as far as being able to end our own lives. We do not have the right to die. This does not mean that we cannot allow ourselves to die by refusing harsh and unattractive medical treatment as it is seen as accepting one's fate.7 Roman Catholics believe that we do not have the kind of freedom necessary to take someone's life as we are made by God for the purpose of loving him. John Stuart Mill has views which are strongly against those of the Catholic Church. In his book 'On Liberty' he said that if someone is faced with a decision which does not directly affect others then the person should be given total autonomy. 8 Another reason for Catholics to believe that euthanasia is wrong is because of the fact that it is believed that suffering has a special place in God's plan. This is backed up by the idea that Jesus died on the cross and so if we suffer at the end of life, we are being connected to the suffering that Jesus felt. This doesn't mean that people should go out of their way to seek pain, but it does mean that a positive effect can be had on the individual. ...read more.

Conclusion

The recent incidents involving Dr Harold Shipman could also be repeated if voluntary euthanasia were legalised. He managed to kill dozens of elderly people and got away with it even under the current regulations. Some people believe that voluntary euthanasia may lead to other schemes carried out by the Nazis which involved the involuntary euthanasia of the sick, disabled and the elderly. When the constraints on killing are loosened, undesirable effects must occur. This is called the slippery slope argument. However this is fairly unconvincing as that situation has not occurred in Holland. 13 The final argument against voluntary euthanasia is the idea that it is totally contrary to the initial aim of medicine, to promote the health and life of people. The opposite act is being carried out and medical practitioners are failing at their jobs. These people should not be put in the position where society expects them to take a persons life. 1 'Collins Pocket English Dictionary'. 2 Withdrawal is to stop treatment, withholding is to never give it and both are seen as legally equal. 3 Tony Hope, Julian Savulescu, Judith Hendrick. 'Medical Ethics and Law'. pp157. 4 Campbell, Alistair. Gillet, Grant. Jones, Gareth. 'Medical Ethics-Third Edition'. pp200 5 Alison Davies. 'Briefing notes on voluntary euthanasia/assisted dying.' 6 In fact, the term 'best interest' is easily miss understood as meaning the patients 'wishes'. What it really means is what will preserve their health or prevent them from dying. 7 www.bbc.co.uk/print//religion/ethics/euthanasia/rcatholic.shtml 8 Robert A Bowie, 'Ethical Studies'. pp190. 9 'Declaration on Euthanasia' 1980. 10 www.hospicecare.com/Ethics/fohrdoc.htm 11 www.ves.org.uk 12 Glover, 1977, pp.92-93. 13 'Kusha', 1991, pp302. ?? ?? ?? ?? Sam D'Arcy ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Euthanasia section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Euthanasia essays

  1. My hypothesis: Euthanasia should be legalized in the UK.I am going to answer a ...

    You don't have the time to collect this amount of information and therefore it is useful if someone can do it for you. There is lots of information to look at and therefore you can investigate many of issues. You can answer all your key questions and it will also give you other areas that you can investigate.

  2. What is meant by euthanasia?

    In the Sanctity of Life teaching, human life is sacred from the moment of conception. It teaches that God remains the absolute owner of all our lives, the Christian tradition has held that it is a sin deliberately and directly to kill an innocent person.

  1. “An acceptance of the practice ofvoluntary euthanasia is incompatible with Christian belief in the ...

    Alastair Campbell (12) writes of a woman named Anna. Anna was tetraplegic as a result of a road accident. She also suffered diffuse phantom pain, which had to be made bearable by high doses of analgesic. Anna decided she wanted to die and made it clear that she didn't want to be resuscitated if she had an arrest.

  2. Is Euthanasia morally acceptable?

    Then I was able to show how much the public knew. This question on reflection I do not think was very well designed because it makes it all more complicated in the long-term, it should have just been they say places where they think euthanasia is legal and I mark them right if they mention places where euthanasia is legal.

  1. Free essay

    Euthanasia - Good Or Bad?

    Religious people have a point of view for euthanasia but they also have views against euthanasia to. Christians have hospices around Britain, which are specially for looking after terminally ill people while making sure that they don't lose their dignity, Christianity believes euthanasia is wrong as they believe in the

  2. Choose a case which you consider to be of crucial importance for medical ethics ...

    This case involved a married couple, the marriage was in difficulties the husband suffered from depression and attempted to commit suicide on a number of occasions. The husband asked his wife to help him commit suicide by bringing him drink and drugs, she did so without attempting to dissuade him knowing that she would profit from his death.

  1. Euthanasia should be legalised in Queensland under very strict conditions - Discuss.

    However, after the autopsy confirmed that Nancy had not sign of cancer, but evidence of an inoperable twisted bowel at the time of her death, the public opinion, which had been solidly behind her, became confused and there was perception of a bad mistake (www.vesv.org.au).

  2. What are the religious and ethical considerations to the issue of euthanasia?

    Human life is a gift from God. We are stewards of this gift, not owners. It is our responsibility to nurture it, respect it, and protect it. Human life has value regardless of its nature or quality. Life has special dignity and worth.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work