• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Examine at least 2 reasons for believing in life after death

Extracts from this document...


Examine at least 2 reasons for believing in life after death (12) There is one thing on which all philosophers agree: " our earthly life in our current physical form will end"(Jordan). According to Collins English dictionary death is "the perminent end of all functions of life in an organism." Many people accept death as the end of any form of existence. Others would argue that death is not the end of life, and that we continue in some form after death. However, there are various reasons for believing in live after death, all of which differ in nature. Some believe the existence of an afterlife is necessary on, moral grounds. Immanuel Kant taught that when we look about the world we see many injustices that seemingly go unpunished. Kant based his argument on a similar question: why do some people who lead an almost sinless life end up being killed at an early age or die of rape, and some who sin all through their life die rich and happy? The fact that many injustices go unpunished in the world, led to Kant (and Hick) to adopt a belief in an afterlife as a "necessary postulate." In other words, people believe and see life after death as a place where unjust and just will be finally dealt with. ...read more.


Many mediums have passed on messages from departed spirits that contain accurate information, which was previously unknown to the medium. These messages give comfort to the bereaved, as they suggest that their loved one is still 'alive' in another dimension, and that at some future they will be able to join them. However while some see it as good evidence for life after death use this as a base for their belief in afterlife, many simply see it as fraud and therefore it cannot be viewed as evidence. Although nearly all 'spirit experiences' are argued to be false and therefore are not seen as evidence of afterlife, however, as the principle of credulity states: in the absence of special circumstances, what we preserve to be the case, is probably the case. Why might these reasons be problematic? "Whether we are to live in the future state, as it is the most important question which can possibly be asked, so it is the most intelligible question which can be asked." The confident opening of Bishop Butler' dissertation "Of Personal Identity" asserts that the immortality of a person is a coherent doctrine and asks whether it is true. Flew however stated that it is impossible to be immortal, after death, as he claimed that it is simply not possible to be both "dead" and a "survivor;" likewise he argues that "surviving death" is self contradictory and therefore meaningless. ...read more.


Ryle called the idea of a soul "a ghost in the machine," because our body's functions are simply physical: emotions, thoughts, dreams, are the result of brain's activity, just like our movements are the results of muscle contractions. This in result means that there is once again no need for a soul and therefore no possibility of afterlife. According to logical positivism, claims of experiences which point out to afterlife, such as talking to spirits of the ones that died etc, are impossible due to the fact that they cannot be verified via empirical evidence. Ayer claimed that a proposition is meaningful if it is known how to prove true or false, and if such verification cannot take place, then a proposition is meaningless. This means that there is no life after death, because there is no evidence that could prove this. In result we can therefore see that although the idea of afterlife might sound appealing to men, and therefore has tendency to be convincing, in fact it seems that there is no empirical evidence to suggest the existence of afterlife. More over it is questionable whether we need or have the soul, which can carry on living. This leads us to conclude that the argument of afterlife is seen to be a weak one. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Capital Punishment section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Capital Punishment essays

  1. Outline the arguments for and against life after death? Assess the significance of the ...

    This view that the body can survive as a disembodied state does not lack modern supporters. According to Richard Swimburne it is coherent to suppose that a person can exist without a body. Swimburne argues that if X can be without Y then X and Y are distinct.

  2. Describe the teachings and beliefs of Islam about death and what may happen after ...

    Both women and men need that reminder. It also helps to view matters in the right perspective. Explain how a particular belief may affect the way in which followers in this religion may live their lives? The fact that Islam states that there is a life after death and a Judgement Day affects the way Muslims lead

  1. In this philosophical study of applied ethics the concept of punishment will be argued ...

    In contrast to retributive punishment is deterrence. Deterrence has a forward-looking view of punishment because it views punishment essentially as a means of enabling society to function fully in the future. The retributive aim does not rule this out as an aim of punishment, but deterrence differs because it doesn't punish the offence for its on sake.

  2. Death and Immortality in The Epic of Gilgamesh

    It is during this period of the story that one can truly see the sympathetic and compassionate side of Gilgamesh. The grief in his heart has far exceeded the magnificent pride that he has previously displayed to the people of Uruk.

  1. Matters Of Life and Death.

    Before, you can really make your mind up; you need to decide if we have a soul. I kind of think we do have a soul.

  2. What Is Donne's attitude to death in his poems? You should base you answer ...

    The alliteration used here emphasis this point. He then says that some of our best people are lost to death where their body rests, "rest of their bones" and souls are set free, "soul's delivery". This is a very positive comment; it makes death something to look forward to rather than fear.

  1. Free essay

    "Death is nothing to us." How good are the Epicurean arguments for this ...

    Our final need is not one that is made up of feeding bodily pleasures nor is it one that can be replaced by mental ones, but it is to satisfy needs which results in satisfaction rather than one which leads to further needs and pains.

  2. Explain the reasons why some religious people believe in life after death.

    It is taught in the Bhagavad Gita that yoga and regular praying can achieve good karma.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work