• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Explain and evaluate the different perspectives on Religion offered by Richard Dawkins and Alister McGrath. Is religion really the 'root of all evil? '

Extracts from this document...


PRE BAC Assessed Essay 4 Explain and evaluate the different perspectives on Religion offered by Richard Dawkins and Alister McGrath. Is religion really the 'root of all evil? ' Joe Brann Autumn 2007 Explain and evaluate the different perspectives on religion offered by Richard Dawkins and Alister McGrath. Is religion really the 'root of all evil'? Two scientists and learned intellectuals study the same thing at the same place and eventually, reflecting long and hard on substantially the same thing, come out with the most profoundly different conclusion you could have; how? Alister McGrath is an atheist turned Christian who was awarded his doctrine in molecular biophysics in the Oxford laboratories of Professor Sir George Radda. He gave up science to study theology and became Professor of Historical Theology at Oxford University. Where Richard Dawkins is another Oxford graduate who studied the natural sciences and zoology and went on to become Professor of Zoology in the University of California, Berkeley. Since then he has become probably the World's most high profile atheist. This is one of the first questions that Alister McGrath brings up in his book 'The Dawkins Delusion', a book written in response to Dawkins's 'The God Delusion'. ...read more.


many religious scientists that find God so much in science for example Owen Gingerich discovery of a evidence of playing a large part in the origins of the universe. Or Francis Collins's discovery of Gods footprint in the Genome Project. One idea that they both do agree by both disagreeing is with Stephen Jay Gould, arguably one of America's leading evolutionary biologists. His idea of NOMA (non-overlapping magisteria) is the belief that science and religion can't overlap. Though they disagree for very different reasons: for Dawkins it is because Gould is still entertaining the idea of a possible second reality; where Dawkins says there is only one and that is our reality. McGrath theory (POMA) that there is a partially overlapping magisteria; is the idea that science and religion don't and can't completely overlap but there are various points that they agree on and this I think is the most sensible and correct point. Alister helps his theory throughout the book by naming numerous scientists who do in fact believe that they can overlap and scientist's who do indeed believe in God. ...read more.


This has already been partially covered over the idea of violence sprouting from almost and views it being the extremists and the fundamentalist who cause the evil not the religion. There is also the fact that when you look in to it all religion preaches a message of peace and the end to violence for as Alister says wasn't 'Jesus the object, not the agent, of violence'. This and lots of what I have written already I think shows the religion is not the root of all evil. Undoubtedly the root of some, and a lot, of evil and even more is in the name of it. Though there is also so much good in it and so much good comes of it. In conclusion I think that although it is the root of some evil religion is a good think that in this day and age, even with both Dawkins and McGrath's arguments can neither be proved, disproved or properly judged and even if we are one day to find out that it is not real or true it has been a great attribute and pillar for society and the human race that has, I think in the long run, had a positive impact on the world. ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 of 6 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Miscellaneous essays

  1. Good and Evil. Many Christians believe that Good comes from God, and Evil also ...

    Also, it seems to affect certain regions frequently, whilst other areas are always avoided. This poses more of a problem for humanity- is it fair to let innocent people struggle whilst others roam free of this? Furthermore, the people that are affected by natural evil are normally the poorer, less fortunate people who are unable to defend themselves.

  2. Racism in Society in the Past and Today. How do Christians view racism?

    If the black protestors responded with violence, it would prove the government right; it would show that black people may well be inferior. MLK: 'if he does not beat you - good! If he beats you, you develop the inner conviction of accepting the blows without retaliating" An example of

  1. Good and Evil

    believe that we should be able to make some choices for ourselves without having strict rules to follow all the time. If we all have to follow the same rules all the time then how can we make our own choices and our own mistakes?

  2. This paper reflects the lives of the historical figures Jesus and Mohammed, showing the ...

    He considered himself a shepherd of god that would sacrifice himself for his follow people, if needed be and explained that his teachings were from God (Fisher, 2005, p. 294). During The Last Supper Jesus warned his disciples of his coming death.

  1. Abortion: do you agree

    abortions are done between 12 and 16 weeks. Since the child is larger, the cervix must be dilated further. With a forceps, the abortionist reaches into the womb and grasps the limbs of the child, dismembering the body into small enough pieces to remove. The skull must be crushed before removing it.

  2. The Love of Money is The Root of Evil

    It could be said that the love of money causes some people to lie, cheat, steal from others to get more of it so perhaps, yes. The love of money causes temptation. The money itself doesn't do this. Money is neither good nor bad.

  1. Christian Churches

    It is also the largest piece of furniture in the church apart from the organ. This shows that God's message is the most important part of the service and is mainly used for sermons. Second to the pulpit is the lectern, this is a stand where the bible sits and it is from here that most scripture is often read.

  2. history cwk Question 1

    nearly one quarter of the world's population the right to live in Britain, spurring many to emigrate here. At that time the USA was restricting immigration, so many people may have come here as second choice. The labour shortage in Britain was helped by the advertising campaign abroad.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work