• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Explain briefly Ninian Smart's seven dimensional model of religion. Do you think that Smart's model solves the problems that arise when attempting to define religion Do you think that Smart's model soleves the problems that arise when attempting to defin

Extracts from this document...


Explain briefly Ninian Smart's seven dimensional model of religion. Do you think that Smart's model solves the problems that arise when attempting to define religion? For centuries Scholars have struggled to come up with a neatly defined term for what constitutes a religion. Many scholar definitions are either substantive or functional. Substantive definitions distinguish religion by common beliefs and practices such as (rituals, prayer or belief in one god). Substantive definitions tend to be too narrow and prejudiced; it would be difficult to consider Buddhism, which is atheistic, as a religion under this definition. Functional definitions tend to distinguish a religion by the needs it fulfils, (peace, comfort, security), the problem with functional definitions is they tend to be to flexible and vague to be considered as definite solutions to what exactly makes a religion "a religion" since there is no clear boundary to where a religion ends and something else such as a political movement or cult begins. Recent scholars have attempted to emphasize the broad nature of religion rather than define it within a narrow framework. One of the best known of these attempts is the seven dimensional model proposed by Ninian Smart, who suggested we approach each religion by looking at it under a number of different dimensions. ...read more.


Also related are Religious stories, for example the Christian Mass commemorates the Last Supper and the Jewish Passover commemorates the Exodus from Egypt. The doctrinal & philosophical dimension This dimension supports the narrative and deals with the philosophical questions of a religion. Doctrines vary from one religion to another, ranging, for example, from the doctrine of the Trinity in Christianity to the teachings of Hinduism and the nature of God or Buddha's philosophical vision of world. In some religions such as Hinduism, Buddhism, Judaism, there are scriptures in which religious narratives and doctrines are recorded The ethical & legal dimension Many Religions have laws that a believer must adhere to be a true and faithful follower. Judaism has over six hundred complex rules (Including the Ten Commandments) that dictate the framework for living within the community. Similarly Islam abides by law or Shari' which affects both individual and religious way of life. The social and institutional dimension The social side of a religion involves the gathering of the faithful - in a Church, Temple or Synagogue and many religions allocate special days in which they gather for the observance of prayer, family or rest. For Jews it's Saturday, for Muslims it's Friday. ...read more.


According to the scholar Eileen Barker, this would imply that ideologies such as Nationalism and Marxism would both be considered a religion as they both have their own doctrines, ethics, institutions, and so on. Transcendental Meditation would also qualify as a "religion" under this model, regardless of the movement's denial of it being a one. Steve Bruce, a leading sociologist of religion, believes that rather than opting for narrow substantive definitions or broad functional definitions, the definition of religion should reflect common sense and encompass what ordinary people mean when they talk of religion. He opts for the following substantive definition: Religion, then, consists of beliefs, actions, and institutions that assume the existence of supernatural entities with powers of action, or impersonal powers or processes processed of moral purpose. (Block 5, page 37) This would allow non-religions such as Marxism to be excluded, while still including such faiths as Buddhism. In conclusion, I would be more inclined to agree with Bruce's definition of religion, as the inclusion of common sense eradicates to some degree the problem of vagueness that arises from Smart's model. I would also agree that for many a 'religion' is a way of life, a philosophy that enables them to live by morals and principles that help make them better human being. (Word Count 1202) ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Religion in the Media section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Religion in the Media essays

  1. Comparative Study of Voltaire's and Molière's Views on Religion in Candide and Tartuffe

    In Candide, the examples of religious hypocrisy run on, one after another, as Candide travels around the world. Voltaire's tone is not didactic, but light and comical, and in his narrative of Candide's adventures, he presents the examples of religious hypocrisy more as comical anecdotes.

  2. Discuss the merits of theories of secularisation with regard to religion in modern Britain

    In the long term, religion would diminish in terms of its plausibility as science increasingly produced more plausible forms of explanation. However, as I have noted, in some areas of social life religious ideologies prove more plausible - hence the disappearance of religion is possible but not inevitable.

  1. Are the 10 commandments still relevant today?

    all born with the feeling we want to be like others, or want that car or house ect. I don't think this is relevant to society because everyone just naturally does want what others have. A book written 3000 years ago isn't going to change that.

  2. Critically discuss the problems faced by sociologists who attempt to define and measure religion ...

    Some sociologists may choose to measure religion by looking at the number of people who pray. This indicated that these people believe in some divine being that can act in the world to help them. The problem with this is that many people pray in hope, in times of need.

  1. How Can Religious Experience Be Defined And What Are The Problems Of Defining Religious ...

    Similarly an experience of God would be described using comparative concepts. Many criticise this by asking how we know what God is like under normal circumstances, however, Alston says we perceive Gods goodness, love, beauty etc based on the experiences of these things around us.

  2. Describe and compare two conversion experiences

    Although it is possible to state that a conversion is not genuine unless the experience is noetic because if the experience is not felt to be absolutely real to the individual, then the person does not have any valid reason to convert.

  1. Are Near Death Experience's a valid form of Religious Experience

    "I recognised my grandmother and a girl I had known when I was at school - Meeting Others" Famous cases include businessmen and wealthy men and women changing their lives from materialistic seeking to community work and giving others comfort and joy "Nice, great feelings of solitude" "I felt my troubles were gone" (Passivity)

  2. Given the Different types and also the mediators of Religious Experience, asses Momen's Physiological ...

    The second model would fit for someone that uses a religious experience and religion as a fashion and flitter from practise to practise, for example Madonna and the Kabala.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work