• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Given the Different types and also the mediators of Religious Experience, asses Momen's Physiological Model in relation to the evaluation of a Religious Experience

Extracts from this document...


Given the Different types and also the mediators of Religious Experience, asses Momen's Physiological Model in relation to the evaluation of a Religious Experience Edward Cohen Momen's physiological model is put into four stages; the first is preparation which is a situation an individual finds himself in which is beyond their personal bounds of existence leading to confusion, frustration and lack of understanding of the problem. The second is incubation, this is when the emotions that are caused by preparation leads to the individual being over perplexed and turns themselves away and proceeds to another activity. Others will feel illumination whereby the strange feelings one receives are converted by the mind to insights and a newer and greater understanding that is often unexpected. Finally there is verification, this occurs when the individual is baffled by the situation and tries to work out the problem using existing concepts and tries many different methods until a satisfactory conclusion is reached. This model can be used in a religious experience, and makes sense when the word crisis is swapped with religious experience. ...read more.


The third type of person seeks to attain a higher level of religious thought, this is far more valid than the previous two as the result, in a spiritual sense is far more rewarding. Some may argue that in a world which is becoming increasingly less spiritual, the first two can be seen as just a valuable and productive to the society because at least they have some form of further insight however small. On the other hand, others would argue that they make a mockery of religion and are potentially dangerous to religion as we know it. They would cite examples of American TV Christian Angelical priests, who feel they have Gods power within them to heal. Macintrye may describe it as 'the therapist' where the person gets a 'quick fix' so while Madonna feels she is becoming spiritually enlightened, it is just a falsehood and an artificial experience. Momen further narrows religious experience down to ecstatic experiences and more calming ones. The ecstatic experience is a short period of ecstasy whereby a sudden event results in the individual feeling as never before. ...read more.


It is very difficult to try to categorize mystical experience, James feels that they are 'ineffable,' so how does one propose to put them in a rational order is you can't even know what it really was. A Suffi Muslim describing his experience is the same as describing the taste of an onion. Where religious texts can be read and interpreted by people, religious experience is in a different league as there is nothing tangible to see and try and explain. Many would argue that it is a deeply personal experience whereby different people are triggered by different means in the world around, but the main goal is still shared by all. Many mystics, I feel, would be horrified by Momens vulgar table, religious experience is an individual activity that many take very seriously, they would argue that this form of rationalizing the irrational is a poor reflection on the Western culture where people are obsessed with rankings, tables and categories. What right does he have to say that some people's experiences are invalid and shallow whilst others are genuine? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Religion in the Media section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Religion in the Media essays

  1. Explain briefly Ninian Smart's seven dimensional model of religion. Do you think that ...

    Shaw's model is flexible enough to accommodate the various aspects of Hinduism; this shows the model to be diverse, adaptable and as it does not define religion in terms of a particular trait, it resolves the issues that arise from substantive and functional definitions.

  2. Discuss the merits of theories of secularisation with regard to religion in modern Britain

    The Level of Individual Consciousness: Religious Beliefs If the evidence we have looked at so far (both for or against secularisation) is not particularly conclusive, we can look finally at a third possible measure of secularisation, that of individual beliefs.

  1. Discuss Greene's use of religion and religious imagery in 'Brighton Rock'.

    They appear to be a satanic version of the Sacraments. Baptism could be interpreted from the book when Pinkie is 'baptised' as leader of the gang through Kite's death - Holy Eucharist when the gang share a meal of '...four fish and chips and a pot of tea'21 just after Hale's murder.

  2. Mystical experiance.A mystical experience is a type of religious experience. It is when a ...

    Therefore in his book he offers four characteristics, which he claims, will enable us to identify a mystical experience. These characteristics are that the experience will be ineffable, this means the experience is beyond verbal description, it is impossible to fully recall and explain ones own experience.

  1. Are Near Death Experience's a valid form of Religious Experience

    Otto, however in response stated that the previous definition outlined above is too subjective. The issue of subjectivity comes from Peter Vardy in his Internal/External Gap. The internal believes that the experience is true but the external is proving that the conviction is true.

  2. How Can Religious Experience Be Defined And What Are The Problems Of Defining Religious ...

    Swinburne's final example is one in which the perceiver experiences an awareness which cannot be sensed through eyes, ears, touch etc. However, Whilst Swinburne's theory of the five types of religious experience is true it is also the case that an experience may fall in to two or more of the categories.

  1. What is meant by conversion and how does it relate to religious experience

    One of them is 'Is conversion permanent?' When most people are converted, they may not know a lot about what they are converting to. The conversion could be more than the person expected and wanted, so they could decide to leave what they have converted to and go back to what they previously where.

  2. What is meant by a religious experience?'

    However, unlike dreams, religious experiences are remembered by individuals for the rest of their lives due to the impact and effects of them. This process is called transciency. A variety of famous scholars have come to the conclusion that whilst going through an experience of religions importance, the person involved

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work