• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How adequately did the Pre-Reformation Church in England meet the religious needs of the country?

Extracts from this document...


How adequately did the Pre-Reformation Church in England meet the religious needs of the country? The subject of the Pre-Reformation church and its effectiveness in meeting the religious needs of the people is an issue that divides historians. There are two main schools of thought on the subject; orthodox and revisionist. It is important that both sides of the argument are carefully examined to be able to formulate an accurate opinion. There are many historians who argue the orthodox point of view, experts in the field such as A.G Dickens, G.R Elton etc.. The long established view has always been that the people of England at this time were beginning to resent the Church for a number of key factors and they were only too happy to follow their king in overturning the Catholic Church. The followers of the orthodox view would argue that the consistent and high taxes (tithes, probates and mortuary fees) were causing widespread discontent and resent between the people and the church. They would argue that the people felt suppressed by the Church and its Cannon Law, constant taxation, debilitating and obvious corruption. A. G Dickens puts forward this attitude in a simple statement; "Anticlericalism had reached a new virulence by the early years of the 16th century." ...read more.


For example, he comments on Cardinal Wolsey: "Wolsey himself, for all his private vices, was an energetic reformer, who tried to produce better trained and better disciplined parish clergy." This is a very typical example of the revisionist view, recognising the humanity and failings of the clergy but also bringing out that they were still meeting the religious needs of the people. The revisionist argument is that the orthodox view is misleading and inaccurate, they are backed by the last 25 years of research that show that this supposed 'anti-clericalism' was merely a part truth and represented a miniscule percentage of the population. Haigh argues that the Reformation was caused by a number of factors not simply on account of corruption of the clergy. He argues that war costs, political machinations and Henry's strong desire for divorce were the primary cause of the Reformation in England. He proves that interest in the church is not waning at this point by commenting on evidence; "In the 1520's recruitment of clergy reached the peak of the half century expansion" This comment by Haigh helps to back up the revisionist argument that people were having their needs met by showing that more and more clergy were stepping in to help fulfil the religious needs of the English people. ...read more.


The true cause of the Reformation lies not with the people's dislike of taxes and of the clergy but rather with the King and other external factors. The picture that is painted by the evidence available to historians today would seem to suggest that England's people were torn in half, some feeling discontent and anger with the Church and the clergy and some feeling happy with their Catholicism and the way in which the Church met their needs. However it is important to consider whether the evidence is an accurate representation of the time. It may well be that the majority of people in England at this time were perfectly satisfied with the Church and were having their religious needs fully satisfied. There is an obvious possibility that the issues that are raised in the Orthodox view are only representative of small pockets of people and not of England as a whole. Whichever way your opinion takes you, there is not enough evidence to build a completely, airtight case of either of the Orthodox or Revisionist views. However, since the 1970's more and more historians have been joining the revisionist view of the Church's condition and ability to meet the religious needs of its parishioners. 1 D Gleeson 12 N ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Places of Worship section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Places of Worship essays

  1. The storm-troopers of the counter reformation. Is this an accurate description of the Jesuits?

    He was certain to become a soldier in the Spanish soldier in the army but he had epiphany in 1521 after he was wounded in battle. 'In a series of deeply religious experiences resulting from a detailed thinking and 'feeling' through of the life and sufferings of Jesus, he became

  2. Were abuses the source of the Reformation?

    not due to his religious convictions or dissatisfaction with the Catholic Church in England at the time. It is possible to assert that abuses could have been the source of the English Reformation, the abuses by Henry VIII of his power and manipulation of intricate clauses for personal gain.

  1. English Reformation

    blocked reform.'5 Haigh clearly supports the idea that several bishops endeavoured the preservation of pastoral care and suitable resolutions for local disagreements. This demonstrates however, it is inevitable at times that the views provided are merely the personal opinions of historians, and are bias, since many other historians who have

  2. Describe the development of the doctrines of Christ and of the Trinity during the ...

    Light, true God from true God, begotten, not made, one in Being with the Father. Through him all things were made. For us men and for our salvation he came down from heaven: by the power of the Holy Spirit he was born of the Virgin Mary, and became man.

  1. To what extent did Ferdinand and Isabella succeed in dealing with religious problems in ...

    Of those that stayed, many of the Jews who 'converted' in 1492 continued to practise Judaism secretly. Although the new policy of limpieza de sangre created a less tolerant Spain than had existed under the idea of convivencia, it did increase the Catholic Church's support for the crown, strengthening Ferdinand and Isabella's position.

  2. St Germans Church in Cornwall

    But we can see a definite break in the wall, where we think the door was situated; there is evidence of a doorway that has been covered up. The whole town declined in the last years of the monks living at St Germans Church and was being descried as a fishing village (or Fischar Town)

  1. There are many factors that suggest the use of the printing press to spread ...

    The Pope was guilty of a number of abuses. The first was nepotism which monks were also guilty of; Pope Leo (1513-21) was particularly blunt in the way he abused his position by appointing his relatives and political allies instead of people who actually deserved the position. Another abuse the Popes like to indulge in was immorality; some popes

  2. Homosexuality and the Church.

    These strongly believe that, homo or heterosexual, anybody could and should be appointed as clergy. These contrasting views in one article therefore represent some neutrality of the source, an attribute which further confirms its reliability in providing unbiased information for the research.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work