• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How does Mary Warnock persuade the readers to accept her viewpoint?

Extracts from this document...


How does Mary Warnock persuade the readers to accept her viewpoint? The article observes the viewpoint of Mary Warnock on the Diane Pretty case. Diane Pretty had motor neurone disease and was almost at the point where she wouldn't be able to move. She appealed to the judicial system in order to claim the right for her husband to assist her in ending her life, and not being prosecuted for doing so. This presented the government and courts with a very tough decision. There are two main parts to Mary Warnock's argument. One is that Diane Pretty should be granted assisted suicide, and the other is that the judges need to make an unbiased decision. However, her opinion is highly biased. She leans towards Pretty's argument throughout her own. She is not, however, able to put forward just her own thoughts. Warnock has also to incorporate the opposite side of the argument. At the beginning we see a hard, negative fact, referring to sickness with no recovery, which makes an impact on us, the readers. This increases our sympathy for those with terminal illness; in this case, Diane Pretty. ...read more.


The readers are subtly convinced into taking this side of the argument. Additionally, there is the religious counter argument towards Diane Pretty's case. Religion says that life is sacred and as a gift from God, it is His to give and take as He pleases. Those who are terminally ill and religious believe that they must have been sent to suffer in the world. What she thinks the views of disabled people on the issue of abortion and euthanasia, is used as an example here. However, for a disabled person to be able to forward opinions such as that, would mean they could not be too badly disabled, therefore not having the right to place that kind of opinion in an instance such as this. Warnock uses a lot of dramatic language such as "condemned", "distressing" and "painful" to form an impact on the readers. She ends on a rhetorical question to involve the reader in the article. The third counter-argument, forwards the fact that life is a gift from God and it is His to give and take as He pleases. Warnock uses analogy to connect this to something that people can relate to. ...read more.


To conclude the article, Warnock shows her belief that the moral judgement is better made by the judge, rather than third parties who may make a biased decision. It also prevents the families etc. from making a potentially difficult decision. What persuaded the judge to rule against Diane Pretty's bid for euthanasia? Why did the court rule in favour of Tony Bland and not Diane Pretty? Is it sexism? Or is it simply the way things have changed? Thousands of people campaign for the right of euthanasia; but this particular case attracted media attention because Pretty and her husband believed so strongly in it that they decided to take their campaign to the highest level. Had the courts ruled in favour of Diane Pretty easily, they would have shown the world how flimsy their system is. They had to at least put up a fight in order to prevent others with terminal illness thinking that it would be easy to get granted the right to euthanasia. I personally believe that Diane Pretty should have been granted the right of assisted death on the basis that this wouldn't set a precedent and all future cases would be judged on their own merits Robert Matwiejczyk 10BZ ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Euthanasia section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Euthanasia essays

  1. My hypothesis: Euthanasia should be legalized in the UK.I am going to answer a ...

    I don't know, it depends on the situation. Things are a lot different now days, there's so much help and medicine out there. But that doesn't change the fact I believe people should be allowed to choose when they die, and the people they ask for help should not be prosecuted.

  2. Ethical Questions

    A Utilitarian: On this subject a utilitarian would be perfectly fine with it there base rule is the greatest good for the greatest number meaning If the pleasure out ways the pain it is ok and that rule can be applied here so for them as long as you have

  1. Whose Life Is It Anyway? How does Brain Clark persuade the audience that Ken's ...

    wasn't because he is a trained doctor and Ken is not putting up any opposition. I think it was the invasion of privacy and direct contradiction of his wishes that he objected to. This is just a small confrontation, but it is definitely a case of the authority versus Ken.

  2. The Language of Euthanasia

    To examine the term in itself, euthanasia, is any action taken to help procure death. It is here that we must understand that Euthanasia is different from prolonging inevitable death. Instead euthanasia is deliberately causing the death of someone who is not dying.

  1. Does the play use every device to persuade us that Ken is right in ...

    Emerson to admit that Ken will never walk again. I think this shows you that Ken is not depressed because he says thank you to Dr. Emerson for telling the truth when he could have been suddenly broken down and started crying. Another device is the selection and omission of scenes.

  2. Abortion has been used throughout the world for thousands of years. Discuss.

    quality of life for herself, the potential child, her partner and her family? Although it is women whose health and well-being are most affected by the availability of abortion, it is often men who have the power to decide. That is why pro-choice groups continue to press for a woman's

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work