• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Human rights - abortion.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Luke Marsh - Human Rights Essay (Abortion) The right to abortion has been recognised in the USA since 1973, following the Supreme Court decision of Roe v Wade. The decision was seven judges to two, so was a clear majority. Despite this it is still a very controversial decision that is continually facing attack, even now on its 30th anniversary. In this case the Supreme Court held that it was unconstitutional to deprive the woman of a right to an abortion in the first trimester of pregnancy, in most instances in the second trimester and for some reasons in the third trimester. The decision in this case was based on the Constitutional right to Privacy implied by Amendment 14 of the US Constitution. The Court made it clear that their decision as to the right to privacy only extended to privacy in the sense of personal sovereignty.1 This is important because if the argument that because of privacy abortion is not the State's business, the result could have been extended, in manners that even the pro-choice lobby would not have liked. A fuller privacy would have suggested that sex in all its forms and results was private, the State then would not be able to provide protection for women from being raped or mauled in private environments. ...read more.

Middle

The foetus on the other hand may have a right to life under article 2 but only if they can be considered a person. There have been four major cases in the European Court of Human Rights. The first is the Open Door and Dublin Well Woman v Ireland in 1992, Paton v UK in 1980, Boso v Italy in 2002 and Takrczyk v Poland also in 2002. Dublin Well Woman case was mainly concerned with the right to access information on abortion in Ireland, where abortion was illegal. Therefore there is little article 2 or 8 debate in these cases. Similarly Takrczyk does not discuss article 2 or 8 in depth as it is more concerned with helping woman leave Poland to have abortions, then the right to abortions in Poland. In the more relevant cases the Court held that article 2 includes two fundamental aspects; the right to life and the prohibition of intentional killing. The court in Paton noted there was no definition of 'everyone' which is used in the right to life in article 2 but that the use of the word meant that it could only really apply post-natally, so did not include the unborn. In Boso the court was not this strict. ...read more.

Conclusion

The provision that is easiest to satisfy, s1(1)(a) has a time limit, which prevents its use after 24 weeks and the other provisions have requirements that are more serious and harder to meet, despite lacking time periods. As a result other implied protections of the woman over the foetus would be likely to protect these provisions as well. So the European Convention on Human Rights is unlikely to interfere or lead to a change in Abortion law in the England. Of course the application to Northern Ireland may be affected, especially if the health of a woman is superior to the right to life of a foetus in the future, in this case the right to abortions in more extended circumstances then present may need to be recognised. If the same Human Rights approach was taken in the US, there would be problems with abortion on demand for the first trimester, but the Supreme Courts ruling on second and third trimester State restrictions would be able to stand, as the English law would. 1 Dworkin, Life's Dominion (???) pg52. 2 L Tribe, Abortion and the Clash of Absolutes (Norton & Company, New York) 1992, pg13 3 L Tribe, Abortion and the Clash of Absolutes (Norton & Company, New York) 1992, pg11 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Abortion and other medical issues section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Abortion and other medical issues essays

  1. Is the law on abortion in this country in a satisfactory state at present?

    Morgan notes that if 'foetal handicapped' ground is to be construed in terms or 'parental interest' then it is superfluous and unnecessary to repeat the provisions in S1 (1)(c) 'women's mental and physical health' combined with s 1(2) doctor takes account of the woman's 'actual or reasonably foreseeable environment'.

  2. The Chamberlain Case -

    his explanations of why Joy Kuhl's test results were wrong were far too difficult for the jury to understand. He had found that there was a fault in the anti-sera that Joy Kuhl had used to form her conclusions. He believed that it was highly likely that it had not

  1. What is meant by abortion?

    When used at 13-19 weeks, it is often necessary to use other instruments to remove or crush parts of the baby that are too large to pass through the tube. Artificial dilation of the cervix in pregnancy carries the risk that the cervix will be damaged and will be insufficiently

  2. What is meant by the word abortion?

    injury to the physical or mental health of any existing children in the family than if the pregnancy is terminated.' And between 24 and 40 weeks, an abortion is only legitimate if the 'mother's life is in danger, if grave permanent injury to the physical of mental life of the

  1. Religion and human relationships

    They say life is a gift from god. Catholics believe that the sixth commandment "you must not commit murder", says abortion is wrong because it deliberately brings life to an end. Scriptures contrast the blessing of life with a curse( which is the opposite of life-death.)

  2. Challenges to Roe v. Wade - women's right to privacy?

    United States (1928), where it was regarded as "the most comprehensive of rights and the right most valued by civilized men" (The Center, 2003, p.26). Following that there is the case Skinner v. Oklahoma (1942), where the court in a unanimous opinion held that forcing a prisoner to undergo sterilization

  1. Christian values for human life.

    Protestant Christians do not see the Sacrament of the sick as a sacrament because there is no correct statement about it from Jesus. Protestants do heal people, though in the letter of St.James it states, "he should send for the church elders, who will pray for him and rub olive - oil on him, in the name of the Lord.

  2. Do Animals have Rights?

    Animal rights supporters believe that it is morally wrong to use or exploit animals in any way and that human beings should not do so. Animal welfare supporters believe that it can be morally acceptable for human beings to use or exploit animals, as long as: the suffering of the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work