• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

If an action is done as a result of affection, rather than as a result of obedience to a rule, can it be a moral action?

Extracts from this document...


If an action is done as a result of affection, rather than as a result of obedience to a rule, can it be a moral action? If an action was done as a result of affection, rather than as a result of obedience to a rule, then the action would not be moral in a sense because it was out of affection - but obviously to the person who is doing the action - it would be seen as moral for they will see that they did it out of love. And it is for the reason that love is portrayed to be the strongest emotion, which in my opinion, it makes people use this as an excuse to do immoral things. The action was done neither from duty nor from direct inclination but merely from a selfish view. It is important to distinguish which are 'in accord with duty' from those done 'from duty', as Kant puts it. ...read more.


Some philosophers have held that in matters of morality, one should act upon one's inclinations. He/she should do that act pleases him/her, or which he/she wants to do in those circumstances but Kant strongly rejects such an account of morality. He feels that a person is acting morality only when he suppresses his/her feelings and inclinations, and does that which he/she is obliged to do. Hence 'doing one's duty', is doing something which one is not inclined or will do, but which he/she does because he/she recognizes that he/she to do it; an obligation exists and he/she must fulfil it. So if a person does something merely because he/she is afraid not to do it (such as the fear of being imprisoned for not repaying a debt) is not a moral person: nor is a person moral who repays a debt merely because he/she wants to, or inclines towards doing that rather than something else. ...read more.


depressing wishes for death, and yet preserves his life without loving it - from inclination or fear but from duty - then his maxim has a moral worth. A good person is a person of 'good will', i.e., a person who acts from a sense of duty. As Kant puts it in a famous phrase, 'nothing can possibly be conceived in the world, or even out of it, which can be called good without qualification, except a good will.' In short, we may summarize that a moral action is one done from a respect for duty, and correspondingly, a moral person is a person who acts from duty, not from inclination or even with accord with duty. So if an action was done out of affection, it would be seen as selfish. Some may argue that it cannot be selfish because they are doing something for the other person that they love, but in Kant's theory, this would just be stated as a selfish act. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Ethics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Ethics essays

  1. TOK Essay: Reason and Emotion

    It was unreasonable firstly because as a member of a team he has a responsibility to his teammates, and by taking this action he did not only let himself down but his teammates as well.

  2. life after death

    A functional Christian would also disagree because they believe to get in heaven you need good deeds. I disagree with this statement I believe that if people live their lives not worrying what happens next they will face judgment and probably go to hell.

  1. With reference to abortion, examine and comment on the view that the sanctity of ...

    been given the right to do what we please with it, in this instance, is God's power limited to just giving life? Because if we have been given life to do as we please with it, then with that, all god's power and control, which is what is implied in the sanctity of life, is taken away.

  2. The Canterbury Tales: A Moral Reading.

    receive the cake made out of the flour they were cheated out of, and don't get injured in the fight like the Miller does. Despite this information, there is still a moral in the story, to not cheat others. This moral seems to over ride a moral of not coveting

  1. A classmate has cheated. You have seen him/her. Discuss the several elements from a ...

    Thirdly, in response to the natural feelings of fear to fail the exam, the student may "develop a vice" to "against the fear". In the case of cheating in the exam, in order to eliminate the fear, the student chose to get a good grade by cheating.

  2. Do Some of Us Take the Moral High Ground?

    very limit of a limitless goal.Science does not contain any order as each technician is trying to outdo the next.Making their invention ,more ,better and bigger by varying degrees this way or that.Science makes itself indispensible ,by throwing up new problems that only themselves can solve,Bauman 1996.It is as though

  1. Explain how a moral life could be said to be at the heart of ...

    There are no dogmas to be believed and followed blindly, without reasoning and putting to the test. Praying to the Buddha or other beings, the performance of superstitious rites and ceremonies, meaningless sacrifices and penance's are not helpful. Morality in Buddhism provides human beings with guidelines of conduct of what

  2. Discuss whether moral judgments are subjective or objective

    Yet, this too faces criticism; what if a situation were too arise where the majority of people wanted something to be done that was clearly reprehensible wrong. For example, during WWII, Hitler and his Nazis followers began the extermination of all Jews.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work