• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'In the light of ethical theory, discuss arguments for and against pacifism.'

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'In the light of ethical theory, discuss arguments for and against pacifism.' Pacifism subscribes to the idea of peace being the best goal and they best means of achieving peace is always through peaceful methods. So pacifists reject the use if physical force, even in the defence, and maintain war is always wrong. When it comes to pacifism there are arguments both for and against its wide spread use. Arguments for include the teachings of Jesus, which show that he taught about love our neighbours as ourselves and that we should turn our cheek to violence against us. This is shown in Matthew 26:52 Jesus instructs Peter to drop his sword and not fight the Roman guard and says 'all who live by the sword, will die by the sword.' And again in Luke 6:7 where he instructed 'if someone strikes your cheek, turn to him the other also.' These show Jesus was very much a pacifist himself and as we are taught to follow Jesus example we should also adopt pacifist views. ...read more.

Middle

The second example is that of the Hindu, Indian leader Mahatma Gandhi who through peaceful methods fought to overcome British rule in India. Both these men however did lose their life. Arguments against it come from such people as Jeff McMahan, the Roman Catholic Church and the just war theory. Then there are the arguments against pacifism the first of these comes from Jeff McMahan who insists that pacifism is difficult to maintain. He believes this to be the case as it takes away the decision of a victim whether a violent response is just. Pacifism expects a person to stay non-violent in every situation. Which can be very difficult if you are faced with violence against you. So another problem which arises from this is that pacifism treats every situation as the same whereas in fact situations are very different and unique. The argument against pacifism put forward by the Roman Catholic Church. They say that it is your duty to try and stop sin or wickness if it arises using whatever means necessary to overcome it. ...read more.

Conclusion

However for it to be able to exist you need a society where every evil or conflict can overcome by using peaceful means. Seen, as we don't live in a society like that it would be very difficult to live by pacifisms principles, about the best means of achieving peace is always through peaceful methods, making conflict inevitable as it is the only way of dealing with many of the evils in today's society. So as it has been said "to secure peace, is to prepare for war". Also how realistic is it to be able to stay peaceful when you are faced violence either against you or you property. I know if I found my self in a situation where I was faced with violence I would feel that meeting violence with violence was justifiable. So basically I pacifism is a great idea but putting it into practice in the type of society we live in today just wouldn't we are faced with to many evils that wont be removed by peaceful means. Naomi Grundy ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Morality of War section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Morality of War essays

  1. Christian views on a just war.

    An issue closer to home regarding conflict and Christianity is the fighting in Northern Ireland regarding the Catholics and Protestants. The two communities are constantly at war with one another over their faiths and in doing so are abandoning the core values of their religions.

  2. Describe the teachings of Christianity about war and pacifism

    ways of resolution will be blessed by god and will be called the 'children of God'. These two quotes demonstrate Jesus praising those who are peaceful. Peter "Put away your sword," Jesus told him. "Those who use the sword will be killed by the sword."4 This teaching is the opposite

  1. Explore the idea that organisations fail when it comes to supporting domestic abuse survivors ...

    By talking out there may be shame brought upon the family. For Muslim women there are also cultural beliefs that suggest that men are the dominating person in the relationship and that women should obey and respect their husbands at all times.

  2. Domestic violence.

    greater understanding and clarity for the reader throughout the remainder of the study. Haraway & O'Neil (1997) describe a multivariate model explaining men's violence towards women. The multivariate approaches explain the perceived causes of men's violence in the form of four factors (see appendix 2).

  1. Domestic violence is a complex issue, which affects the whole of society.

    and Itzin (2000), a 19 year old girl discussed how powerless it made her feel to hear the violence of her parents and not be able to do anything about it to protect her mother, "We use to be up in bed and we use to hear them arguing all the time, fighting and we could hear her crying.

  2. We live in a world of armed conflict - Explain what differing Christian beliefs ...

    Nuclear war splits many Christians as some support it and others do not. Nuclear war is the use of radioactive elements such as uranium and plutonium in weapons. The disadvantage of science and technology is revealed in these bombs which are very difficult to construct and cause mass destruction.

  1. What Teachings would I include in a Christian Booklet on Warfare

    Christians until the church allied itself with the Romans in the 4th century, it is also used by certain churches in their moral views; the Quakers, for instance, believe that by setting a loving example to their aggressive neighbours they can influence them towards peace and away from war.

  2. To what extent if at all might a religious ethic be pacifist?

    Whilst religion is not intended as a social construct as implied by Freudiii, it still must meet the needs of society otherwise the religion is inapplicable to life. To not adopt the pacifist approach is not to suggest Christians are to act violently but simply accepts that in our ever-changing environment there is the possibility that force may be necessary.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work