• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'In the light of ethical theory, discuss arguments for and against pacifism.'

Extracts from this document...


'In the light of ethical theory, discuss arguments for and against pacifism.' Pacifism subscribes to the idea of peace being the best goal and they best means of achieving peace is always through peaceful methods. So pacifists reject the use if physical force, even in the defence, and maintain war is always wrong. When it comes to pacifism there are arguments both for and against its wide spread use. Arguments for include the teachings of Jesus, which show that he taught about love our neighbours as ourselves and that we should turn our cheek to violence against us. This is shown in Matthew 26:52 Jesus instructs Peter to drop his sword and not fight the Roman guard and says 'all who live by the sword, will die by the sword.' And again in Luke 6:7 where he instructed 'if someone strikes your cheek, turn to him the other also.' These show Jesus was very much a pacifist himself and as we are taught to follow Jesus example we should also adopt pacifist views. ...read more.


The second example is that of the Hindu, Indian leader Mahatma Gandhi who through peaceful methods fought to overcome British rule in India. Both these men however did lose their life. Arguments against it come from such people as Jeff McMahan, the Roman Catholic Church and the just war theory. Then there are the arguments against pacifism the first of these comes from Jeff McMahan who insists that pacifism is difficult to maintain. He believes this to be the case as it takes away the decision of a victim whether a violent response is just. Pacifism expects a person to stay non-violent in every situation. Which can be very difficult if you are faced with violence against you. So another problem which arises from this is that pacifism treats every situation as the same whereas in fact situations are very different and unique. The argument against pacifism put forward by the Roman Catholic Church. They say that it is your duty to try and stop sin or wickness if it arises using whatever means necessary to overcome it. ...read more.


However for it to be able to exist you need a society where every evil or conflict can overcome by using peaceful means. Seen, as we don't live in a society like that it would be very difficult to live by pacifisms principles, about the best means of achieving peace is always through peaceful methods, making conflict inevitable as it is the only way of dealing with many of the evils in today's society. So as it has been said "to secure peace, is to prepare for war". Also how realistic is it to be able to stay peaceful when you are faced violence either against you or you property. I know if I found my self in a situation where I was faced with violence I would feel that meeting violence with violence was justifiable. So basically I pacifism is a great idea but putting it into practice in the type of society we live in today just wouldn't we are faced with to many evils that wont be removed by peaceful means. Naomi Grundy ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Morality of War section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Morality of War essays

  1. Describe the teachings of Christianity about war and pacifism

    of the two other teachings, it condemns violence, it directly tells Peter, one of Jesus' disciples that he should not use violence, even in this context when it is to protect Jesus. On the other hand some of Jesus' actions that are written in the Bible completely contradict Jesus' teachings

  2. Domestic violence.

    Civil courts can bring claims for injuries 9699564 inflicted before birth if the child survives and is born alive, but these claims are rarely brought before court. In Britain until recently, a charge of murder or manslaughter could not be brought in such cases as the victim was not a "person in being" at the time of the act.

  1. Christian views on a just war.

    However once captured Saddam was not subjected to the torture that he imposed but treated in a Christian and humane manner. Though as the passage states we should still maintain our Christian values and be forgiving, `to turn the other cheek`.

  2. Explore the idea that organisations fail when it comes to supporting domestic abuse survivors ...

    The woman will have fear that people will turn against her for speaking or even may not believe her as he appears to be a well mannered, respected person at all times and the situation only happens behind closed doors.

  1. Explain the arguments put forward by Christians pacifists and demonstrate how Christian non-pacifists might ...

    goes on to describe God in a different light to the loving father figure he is portrayed as by pacifist Christians. With texts such as these, non-pacifists interpret that God is on their side in a particular war and that it is his wish for them to show their love by fighting for their country or their neighbour.

  2. Free essay

    The Role of the Accident Compensation Corporation in the Prevention of Family Violence in ...

    Evaluation of this project indicates that completion of the programme leads to reports of increased wellness from child participants, the development and implementation of safety plans by children and an increased awareness by parents of the effect of witnessing family violence on children.

  1. Why has American society developed so violently?

    more prominent, and countless violent family feuds occurring with general urban unrest due to economic expansion.

  2. Explain why the first Christians were persecuted The persecution of Christians by the Roman ...

    Since Jesus knew that it was not true, He left the truth to be revealed on its own, and this exactly what happened as all the evidence of the people did not match. When it is clear that a person is being accused falsely, it is better to keep quiet

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work