• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"It is not possible to be a true disciple of Jesus in the modern world."

Free essay example:

RE Coursework Specification A Option 1C

Question 3

“It is not possible to be a true disciple of Jesus in the modern world.”

Do you agree? Give reasons for your answer and show that you have considered more that one point of view. Refer to Christianity in your answer”

        There are many varying opinions on what it means to be a true disciple in the modern world.

                It is arguable that people are becoming far too materialistic and becoming obsessive with their possessions which is worshipping false idols. For this reason people may be getting distracted or distancing themselves from God and making it more difficult for them to become disciples, a good example of this is the rich young man (Mark 10: 17-27). But this would not make it impossible to be a true modern day disciple; it would only make it more difficult. This could mean that it is harder to be a true disciple if the one you are following, In this case Jesus, is no longer alive in a physical sense.

        Some people might believe that because Jesus is no longer alive physically it is not possible to be a true disciple because a disciple is a follower of Jesus and if Jesus is no longer alive it is impossible to be a true disciple. But Catholics would strongly oppose this view because they know that Jesus is alive and always will be, as taught in Mark’s gospel. There are many references to Jesus rising from the dead and being eternally alive in Mark’s Gospel.

        Some people may agree that it is not possible to be a true disciple of Jesus in the modern world because Christians do not have to meet the ultimate challenge of a true disciple today because martyrdom is extremely rare; therefore they are not meeting Jesus’ idea that we should “take up our cross and follow him”. But it is apparent that it is not impossible to be a true modern day disciple. A perfect example of a true disciple of the modern world is Mother Teresa.

        If we look at the position the church’s are in it is evident that there are declining numbers. This would seem that fewer people want to be disciples. It also indicates that that it is harder for people to stand up for what they believe especially if their Christians.

        Another reason why it is harder to be a true disciple is because of the practical difficulties for example, shops are now open on Sundays which is supposed to be a day of rest for all Catholics. Peer pressure may also be causing difficulty for people to be true disciples and follow Jesus’ message effectively.

        Some of the demands of discipleship, like giving away all of your money, are not possible because in some societies if you have no money you die.

        From Mark we learn that true discipleship is not to be perfect. Peter, James, John and Judas all made mistakes in Mark’s gospel; this tells us that in the modern world you don’t have to be perfect to be a true disciple.

        One of the key qualities of being a true disciple is selflessness. We see lots of examples of this both at time of Jesus and today.

        Overall, I think that Jesus is still present today through the church and the Bible and through other people so therefore we can still follow Him and become true disciples. Although it may be more difficult today it is never impossible to be a follower of Jesus.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Discipleship section.

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Related GCSE Religious Studies (Philosophy & Ethics) Skills and Knowledge Essays

See our best essays

Related GCSE Discipleship essays

  1. Discipleship coursework

    are more in that league, as they are 'in touch' with the people, they have the task of getting people to think about religion, and they have to survive getting mocked, being shunned. They have to also give up many of what we would call "life essentials" to do these things, like the disciples had to.

  2. It is debated whether it is possible for Christians today to be true disciples.

    The word 'disciple' has also been translated into the phrase 'one who learns'. This means that it actually is possible to be a true disciple of God in the modern world, as some Christians spend much of their spare time at their local church worshipping and learning.


    Every Christian is called to serve God. A Christian vocation could also be served at home, school, work or through marriage as long as we follow the commandments Jesus gave us. Jesus' commission to those who wish to follow him, to be his disciples, is based on two principles, Christians should: - "Love the Lord God with

  2. "It is not possible to be a disciple of Jesus in the modern world." ...

    (Mk 15:42), as well as anger (Jesus Clears the Temple and Curses a fig tree- Mk 11:12-19). Peter, the apostle who would later become leader of the Church, denied Jesus three times (Mk 14:66-72). I believe that instead of cowering away from the demands which being a disciple places on

  1. Year 12 RE Coursework

    People devote their lives to God through prayer and good works. These people are members of contemplative orders; these people live a hidden life of prayer and work. They are enclosed in orders like Carmelites and Cistercians. Also people devote their lives to God through apostolic orders, but these people

  2. Disciples in christianity.

    These people give away all they have to depend on God knowing he will help them. Then there are normal people who live everyday lives yet their heroism shows they are true disciples as they may risk their lives to save others.

  1. Discipleship is usually thought of as following Jesus, being a preacher, teacher.

    They show just how hard it is to enter the kingdom of God, real sacrifices must be made, and Mark allows us to appreciate this. "The Son of Man must suffer much and be rejected by the elders, the chief priest and the teachers of the Law" (Mark 8:31-38)

  2. "It is possible to be a disciple in the modern day world" Do you ...

    These teachers also try to train young students to live by the Lords commandments. Priests choose to sacrifice their family, free time and choose to give up any sort of a family life including any sort of sexual intercourse, to preach and avoid temptation or distraction.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work