• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Jesus made a mistake in choosing his disciples, they all failed miserably.'

Extracts from this document...


Part Three of Three Year Ten Coursework 'Jesus made a mistake in choosing his disciples, they all failed miserably.' Initially, this statement presents many views and arguments, as it is a very controversial one. I am trying to weigh up and examine these opinions in order to then form my own based on my initial views and feelings. It is definite from Mark's Gospel that the disciples did fail on many occasions. Stories in the bible show us the nature of their failure and we can decide form this whether Jesus intended them to fail. In The story of Peter's promise and denial, (Mark 14:26-31) several things are shown to us. On one hand, the argument of Jesus being all knowing is presented when he predicts his own resurrection and the disciple's failure. Peter especially denies that he would ever do something like this, saying he would die with Jesus, only later to deny him three times in the face of death. This in itself provides a good lesson to us about the challenge of discipleship. ...read more.


To avoid this, a disciple must keep Jesus the key of his life and always follow what they feel as his will for them. The disciples also mistook what Jesus wanted at many points in the Gospels. The story of Jesus and the Children in Mark shows a big confusion of what Jesus' mission was about. After witnessing the transfiguration, Peter's offer to build tents and glorify the Lord shows misunderstanding about the way in which God's mission was one of humility, and in their own requests for power (story of James and John) they showed their misunderstanding of the humble role of a disciple and the whole nature of the Kingdom of God. Their basic misinterpretation of many of the parables show how we must pray to God the for understanding and faith which the disciples lacked, in order to be able to pass this love, faith and understanding onto others. Now, having presented these failings, I shall try to realize whether they were due to Jesus' failing. ...read more.


Being chosen by God does not make you perfect, and the disciples, if they had been perfect, would have not had to learn and follow God in the way they did, an would have led Christians away from the true role of a disciple as 'one who learns' and would have also led less people towards God by being too perfect and making Jesus look more human and ordinary next to them. In conclusion, I feel that Jesus never wanted perfect disciples that nothing could be learnt from and no one could hope to follow in the footsteps of. I agree with the view that Jesus was all knowing and knew they would fail, and chose them because their failings could teach us. I also feel that their failure shows us many things about God including his willingness to forgive and his love for everyone, even the Judases of today. This love, mercy and forgiveness are what makes the Christian message so unique and has kept it strong for 2000 years. ?? ?? ?? ?? Anna-Marie Treloar 10 Campion ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Christmas section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Christmas essays

  1. RE coursework - parables

    Christians however need to exercise this quality of forgiveness. We see that God is very forgiving to all mankind and Christians can show this same quality by not holding grudges against others and freely forgiving one another. They could do this by showing courtesy on the roads, for example allowing a car to turn in front of them without getting angry or aggressive.

  2. Did Jesus Make a Mistake in Choosing His Disciples? - Part 3

    They both want positions of importance alongside with Jesus but disciples aren't expected to have a desire for personal glory they are meant to put others before themselves. Another two faults of the disciples were that they were constantly afraid and unable to understand.

  1. What is a Christian disciple? What did Jesus expect of his disciples?

    In a vocation such as marriage you have to be committed in order for the marriage to work and succeed. This is the same for a disciple to fully commit himself towards his work in order for the word and work of God to spread.

  2. What is a disciple?

    said to the disciples, "The sorrow in my heart is so great that it almost crushes me. Stay here and keep watch." Jesus prayed to his father, "Father, my father take this cup of suffering away from me. Yet not what I want, but what you want" he returned and found the three disciples asleep, "Simon, are you asleep?

  1. Describe from Luke's Gospel, how Jesus presented his teachings through parables.

    The parable almost prophesies to the people about what the church would become. It was to grow from small beginning into something significant, which would give shelter and protection to people. The most important teachings that Jesus used parables to convey were God's care for the lost.

  2. Parables.Describe from Lukes Gospel, how Jesus presented his teachings through Parables.

    The main theme of the parables is the central theme of the Gospel, the kingdom of God. The kingdom of God is not an area of land. It refers to Gods new society, to people who live according to Gods new rules.

  1. What Discipleship meant to the first disciples and for Christians today.

    After Jesus taught the disciples what they have to do he sent them on their first mission (Mark 6: 7-13). He gave them authority over evil and gave them instructions saying don't take anything with you on your journey except a stick- no bread, no beggar's bag, no money in your pocket.

  2. 'Explain The Meaning Of Discipleship For The First Disciples And Christians Today'.

    They too were brothers, and both fishermen. When mentioned in Mark, they are generally referred to as a pair. Jesus gave them the title 'The Boanerges' - meaning 'Sons Of Thunder', yet there is no clear reason stated why they were given that particular title, it has only been suggested that they were somewhat thunderous in their behaviour.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work